- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies tabular anomaly detection and proposes assigning fixed, feature-specific training noise scales based on the kurtosis of rearranged marginal histograms. The model learns the joint data structure through denoising training and performs single-pass scoring using the magnitude of its predicted correction in noise units. The authors also introduce EMA-teacher filtering to reduce the influence of anomalous samples in the training data.
Critical strengths
The problem has practical significance. Reducing inference cost while maintaining good detection performance is important for anomaly detection. The paper’s single-pass scoring procedure has clear value for deployment. The paper is well written and generally clear.
Critical weaknesses
1.The main methodological contribution is to compute kurtosis after rearranging marginal histograms and use it to allocate noise scales. The control experiments in the main text support the effectiveness of feature-specific noise allocation. My question is: why is it necessary to use kurtosis computed after rearrangement? The shared-scale and shuffled-scale controls examine the benefits of using different scales and assigning them to corresponding features, but they do not separately assess the necessity of rearrangement. I would like the authors to explain: with all other settings held fixed, how does performance differ between using ordinary marginal kurtosis and using kurtosis after rearrangement? 2.The rearrangement-based coverage analysis in Section 2.3 provides a reasonable motivation for the method. However, the affine kurtosis-based calibration relies on a specific near-Gaussian shape assumption, while the actual method applies this approximation to a broader range of distributions and incorporates empirical clipping and special-case handling. More importantly, coverage is an intermediate objective. The authors note that increasing noise may improve training coverage but may also weaken anomaly signals, and that marginal coverage does not guarantee sufficient support in the joint space. Therefore, even if calibration improves coverage, this alone does not explain why anomaly rankings improve. I would like the authors to clarify: which datasets or features show improved coverage, whether these improvements correspond to better detection performance, and why the method remains effective when the near-Gaussian assumption is clearly violated.
Questions for authors
Please see the specific concerns and questions raised in the Weaknesses section.
Response
Thank you for your reply. It partially solved my problem. I will maintain my score.