acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

LoadMatch: Balancing Memory and Compute Loads in Quantized Models using Speculative Decoding

Abstract

Quantization has become a standard practice for efficient large language model (LLM) inference. However, the exact mechanism behind this acceleration is often misunderstood. A common misunderstanding is that quantized weights directly speed up arithmetic operations: in reality, low-bit GEMM still incurs higher-precision dequantization, rescaling, and accumulation, so its compute-side speedup is much smaller than its memory-side gain. Consequently, the computation time itself remains largely unchanged. However, the perceived speedup stems from the efficiency gained by reducing the transfer time of quantized weights from the GPU memory to its cache. Because of this, quantized LLMs achieve significant speedups only in memory-bound scenarios, whereas their improvements in compute-bound regimes are marginal. To truly maximize the decoding throughput of quantized LLMs, a system must achieve a load-matched state where the memory transfer duration and computation time are equal so that neither the memory bus nor the compute units remain idle. To reach this state, we propose LoadMatch, which balances memory and computation costs using speculative decoding. We leverage speculative decoding, in which a draft model predicts multiple future tokens, called candidate tokens, and the target model verifies them in parallel. By precisely controlling the candidate-token count processed at once, our method deliberately matches the memory and computation workload. Empirically, LoadMatch compounds the speedups from quantization and speculative decoding, delivering a measured end-to-end speedup of over FP16 autoregressive greedy decoding on standard benchmarks. We will release the project upon acceptance.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Quantization, Dequantization Overhead, Memory-Compute Load Match, Speculative Decoding, Speculative Parallelism Throttling

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_ijdTOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents LoadMatch, a framework designed to maximize the decoding throughput of quantized Large Language Models (LLMs) by balancing memory and compute workloads using speculative decoding. The authors highlight a key architectural mismatch: while INT4/low-bit weight quantization reduces memory transfer time, it shifts the GPU roofline "load-match point" to significantly smaller token counts due to dequantization and higher-precision accumulation overheads. Consequently, applying standard speculative decoding to quantized LLMs often pushes verification into compute-bound regimes, collapsing the expected multiplicative speedups. To overcome this, LoadMatch introduces:

  1. Two-Stage Profiling Mechanism: An offline calibration procedure that profiles single-token and multi-token verification latencies to identify the GPU load-match point, subsequently refining it around hardware GEMM tile boundaries to optimize candidate token count without model retraining.
  2. Drafter Slimming: A joint compression technique (pruning and quantizing) applied to both the draft model and its heavy vocabulary projection layer (lm_head), restoring the low-cost drafting assumption for quantized speculative decoding. Evaluated on diverse benchmarks (math, code, chat, long-context, and thinking-mode reasoning) using Llama-3, DeepSeek, and Qwen models across different draft architectures (EAGLE-3, DFlash, DOMINO). The framework delivers up to an 8.8×8.8\times end-to-end speedup over FP16 autoregressive greedy decoding on standard benchmarks.
Critical strengths
  1. In-Depth Hardware & Architectural Insights: The paper correctly identifies and rigorously analyzes the "speedup collapse" phenomenon in quantized speculative decoding. Pinpointing how low-bit GEMM dequantization overhead shifts the roofline ridge point to a lower token count provides valuable technical insights for the hardware and systems community.

  2. Simple, Training-Free Calibration: LoadMatch achieves speedups purely through offline latency profiling and tile-boundary refinement without requiring any fine-tuning or retraining of the target or draft models.

  3. Broad Applicability Across Architectures and Workloads: The authors extensively demonstrate that LoadMatch generalizes across diverse model families (Llama-3, DeepSeek, Qwen), different drafting paradigms (tree-based EAGLE-3, diffusion-based DFlash/DOMINO), long contexts, and reasoning-intensive ("thinking mode") generations.

  4. Rigorous System-Level Engineering: Implementing a fully vectorized, graph-compatible pipeline within CUDA Graphs in vLLM provides a high-quality baseline and demonstrates practical applicability on consumer and laptop GPUs under tight power caps.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Fixed Offline Candidate-Token Count (γ∗\gamma^*): The load-match candidate count γ∗\gamma^* is determined offline on a small calibration set (80 UltraChat samples) and kept fixed during inference. In real-world generations, acceptance rates fluctuate dynamically depending on prompt complexity and context depth. A static γ∗\gamma^* may prove suboptimal during phases with low draft acceptance (where compute budget is wasted) or very high acceptance.

  2. Dependence on Drafter Vocabulary Pruning: Drafter slimming prunes 96K out of 128K vocabulary entries in the draft lm_head based on corpus frequency. While the authors demonstrate that target distribution sampling remains mathematically intact, heavy vocabulary pruning on specialized/out-of-domain topics (e.g., uncommon code symbols or multi-lingual texts) might reduce candidate acceptance rates, impacting overall throughput.

Questions for authors
  1. Dynamic vs. Static Token Budgeting: How sensitive is LoadMatch to dynamic changes in draft acceptance rates during a single long generation? Have you considered adapting the candidate token count γ∗\gamma^* dynamically at runtime based on recent acceptance feedback rather than relying strictly on an offline fixed γ∗\gamma^*?

  2. Impact of Drafter Vocabulary Pruning on Out-of-Domain Tasks: Since 96K vocabulary tokens are pruned from the draft lm_head using frequency statistics from SlimPajama, how does LoadMatch perform on out-of-domain benchmarks with highly specialized vocabularies (e.g., obscure programming languages or multi-lingual datasets) where low-frequency tokens occur more often?

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Letter (1/2)

Dear reviewer ijdT,

We thank reviewer ijdT for the thorough and constructive review. We answer the questions below:

Notation: Unless otherwise stated, TpS is evaluated on five datasets: GPQA (science), GSM8K and MATH500 (math), and HumanEval and MBPP (coding), using EAGLE-3 for speculative decoding and GPTQ for quantization.

Q1-1: How sensitive is LoadMatch to dynamic changes in draft acceptance rates during a single long generation?

A1-1: Although accepted length fluctuates substantially across steps, LoadMatch stays close to the oracle token selection method.

Oracle method comparison. We compare LoadMatch against the oracle method that dynamically adjust draft token counts assuming we know how many tokens are accepted in advance.

γ schedulerMethodGPQAGSM8KMATH500HumanEvalMBPPAvg.
AdaptiveOracle8.15×8.15\times10.01×10.01\times9.04×9.04\times10.38×10.38\times10.76×10.76\times9.67×9.67\times
StaticLM (ours)7.77×7.77\times9.45×9.45\times8.70×8.70\times10.01×10.01\times10.34×10.34\times9.25×9.25\times

Reasons for the oracle's limited additional benefits. We explain this observation in three steps.

STEP 1. We observe substantial fluctuations in accepted length across generation steps, suggesting potential benefits from dynamic γ selection.

MetricGPQAGSM8KMATH500HumanEvalMBPPAvg.
Mean4.365.204.775.535.545.08
Std2.382.272.442.502.532.47

STEP 2. Despite these fluctuations, LoadMatch selects a larger γ than the oracle in 55.0% of steps.

γ schedulerMethodMatchedUnderOver
AdaptiveOracle100%0%0%
StaticLM (ours)15.3%29.7%55.0%

STEP 3. However, the benefits of oracle selection remain limited because (1) target verification latency stays nearly constant for up to 16 tokens, making over-selection relatively inexpensive, and (2) beyond 16 tokens, the latency increase outweighs the additional gains in accepted length. For example, increasing γ\gamma from 16 to 32 raises verification latency by 17.0%, while accepted length improves by only 8.3%.

γTargetOverheadAccepted lengthGain
812.29ms0%4.420%
1612.74ms4%5.0815%
3214.90ms21%5.5024%
6420.70ms68%5.7530%

Q1-2: Have you considered adapting the candidate token count (γ) dynamically at runtime based on recent acceptance feedback rather than relying strictly on an offline fixed γ?

A1-2: We evaluate three runtime-adaptive schedulers and find that dynamic γ\gamma adjustment provides only limited benefits.

We evaluate three adaptive γ scheduling methods based on recent acceptance feedback: accepted-length EMA, accepted-length mean, and drafter confidence. Adaptive methods achieve slightly higher oracle match rates but yield only marginal throughput gains.

[Candidate length selection evaluation.]

γ schedulerMethodMatchedUnderOver
AdaptiveOracle100%0%0%
AdaptiveAccepted length EMA14.9%29.3%55.8%
AdaptiveAccepted length mean22.7%30.0%47.3%
AdaptiveDrafter confidence15.3%29.9%54.8%
StaticLM (ours)15.3%29.7%55.0%

[Speedup evaluation]

γ schedulerMethodGPQAGSM8KMATH500HumanEvalMBPPAvg.
AdaptiveOracle8.15×8.15\times10.01×10.01\times9.04×9.04\times10.38×10.38\times10.76×10.76\times9.67×9.67\times
AdaptiveAccepted length EMA7.71×7.71\times9.38×9.38\times8.56×8.56\times9.86×9.86\times10.16×10.16\times9.13×9.13\times
AdaptiveAccepted length mean7.68×7.68\times9.45×9.45\times8.67×8.67\times9.88×9.88\times10.32×10.32\times9.20×9.20\times
AdaptiveDrafter confidence7.77×7.77\times9.45×9.45\times8.70×8.70\times10.01×10.01\times10.34×10.34\times9.25×9.25\times
StaticLM (ours)7.77×7.77\times9.45×9.45\times8.70×8.70\times10.01×10.01\times10.34×10.34\times9.25×9.25\times
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Letter (2/2)

Q2: Impact of vocabulary pruning on out-of-domain benchmarks.

A2: LoadMatch achieves higher throughput with vocabulary pruning on out-of-domain benchmarks containing more low-frequency tokens.

Although vocabulary pruning may reduce the acceptance rate, the reduction in per-step latency often outweighs this loss. Our experiments on four OOD benchmarks show that vocabulary pruning (w/ pruning) performs favorably against retaining the full vocabulary (w/o pruning), despite increased out-of-vocabulary (OOV) frequencies. This demonstrates that balancing acceptance rate and per-iteration latency is more important than maximizing acceptance rate alone for overall throughput. Specifically, to evaluate this trade-off, we consider two OOD settings: niche programming languages and underrepresented natural languages.

Niche programming languages. We use MultiPL-E [1], a multilingual benchmark covering 22 programming languages. We select two rarely used languages on GitHub, OCaml (0.15%) and Lua (0.32%), with Python (16.93%) as the reference. Our method works well against the full vocabulary baseline.

DatasetMethodOOV freqSpeedupτ\tau
OCamlLM (w/o pruning)0.00%5.11×5.11\times5.03
OCamlLM (w/ pruning)0.90%8.72×8.72\times4.87
LuaLM (w/o pruning)0.00%5.27×5.27\times5.19
LuaLM (w/ pruning)0.91%9.01×9.01\times5.01
PythonLM (w/o pruning)0.00%5.23×5.23\times5.14
PythonLM (w/ pruning)0.90%8.91×8.91\times4.97

Underrepresented natural languages. We use MGSM [2], a benchmark consisting of 250 grade-school math problems translated into 10 languages. We select two languages highly underrepresented in the pre-training corpus, Telugu (0.02%, India) and Swahili (0.005%, East Africa), with English as the reference. Our method performs favorably against the full vocabulary baseline.

DatasetMethodOOV freqSpeedupτ\tau
TeluguLM (w/o pruning)0.00%4.61×4.61\times4.54
TeluguLM (w/ pruning)8.64%6.94×6.94\times3.87
SwahiliLM (w/o pruning)0.00%5.85×5.85\times5.74
SwahiliLM (w/ pruning)12.77%7.48×7.48\times4.12
EnglishLM (w/o pruning)0.00%6.01×6.01\times5.84
EnglishLM (w/ pruning)1.22%10.32×10.32\times5.61

Closing.

We have revised the manuscript according to the reviewer's comments, as summarized in the table below.

CommentTextNo. of Tab or Fig
R3Q1-1L1142Tabs. 18-21
R3Q1-2L510Tab. 12
R3Q2L514Tab. 13

We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's valuable feedback and hope that our responses adequately address the concerns raised.

Sincerely,

The Authors


References:

[1]: MultiPL-E: A Scalable and Polyglot Approach to Benchmarking Neural Code Generation, Transactions on Software Engineering, 2023

[2]: Language Models are Multilingual Chain-of-Thought Reasoners, ICLR, 2023

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Gentle Remainder Letter

Dear reviewer ijdT,

We sincerely thank the reviewer for taking the time to carefully review our manuscript despite a busy schedule. We summarize our responses to the reviewer's questions below.

RefQuestionAnswer
R3Q1-1How sensitive is LoadMatch to dynamic changes in draft acceptance rates during a single long generation?Although accepted length fluctuates substantially across steps, LoadMatch stays close to the oracle token selection method.
R3Q1-2Have you considered adapting the candidate token count (γ) dynamically at runtime based on recent acceptance feedback rather than relying strictly on an offline fixed γ?We evaluate three runtime-adaptive schedulers and find that dynamic γ adjustment provides only limited benefits.
R3Q2Impact of vocabulary pruning on out-of-domain benchmarks.LoadMatch achieves higher throughput with vocabulary pruning on out-of-domain benchmarks containing more low-frequency tokens.

If the reviewer has any remaining questions or concerns, we would be more than happy to address them. If the reviewer finds that our responses have adequately addressed the concerns raised, we would sincerely appreciate the reviewer's consideration of updating the assessment of our manuscript.

Sincerely,

The Authors

Reviewer_8q8nOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies why directly combining low-bit quantization with speculative decoding yields limited additional acceleration. It attributes the problem to a shift of the load-match point toward smaller candidate-token counts after quantization, together with an increase in the relative cost of drafting. LoadMatch uses two-stage offline profiling to select the candidate-token count, compresses the drafter and its lm head, and evaluates the resulting pipeline with CUDA Graph capture enabled. The experiments cover multiple target models, drafters, tasks, temperatures, and batch sizes. In the greedy-decoding setting of Table 3, the method achieves an average 8.81× speedup over FP16 autoregressive decoding on Llama3-8B. The method preserves the output behavior of the quantized target model; quality changes introduced by target-model quantization remain.

Critical strengths
  1. The analysis identifies a useful performance interaction between quantization and speculative decoding. The candidate-token count, quantized verification cost, and drafting cost need to be optimized jointly; their speedups cannot simply be assumed to multiply. The latency breakdowns and candidate-token-count curves provide an actionable diagnostic approach for deployment.

  2. The engineering evaluation is substantial and includes controlled factor analysis. The paper covers EAGLE-3, DFlash, and DOMINO, and evaluates different quantization methods, concurrency levels, thinking modes, and devices. Table 9 separates drafter slimming from candidate-token-count calibration, providing evidence beyond the combined speedup. Comparisons against a CUDA Graph-enabled baseline also strengthen the evaluation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper does not yet establish that two-stage LoadMatch calibration offers an advantage over a simple, reasonable search over candidate-token counts. Table 9 demonstrates that retuning this count is useful, but does not answer whether a small search using the same slimmed drafter, CUDA Graph implementation, 80 calibration samples, and a comparable calibration budget could achieve the same throughput. Because this directly affects the necessity of the central algorithm, comparison against the default candidate-token count is insufficient to establish its independent value.

  2. Some performance claims extend beyond the scope of the evaluation. The main method primarily uses W4A16 on A5000 and RTX 3090 GPUs, which does not establish general conclusions about the compute-side benefits of all low-bit arithmetic. The 27B results in Table 8 use four GPUs for FP16 and two for INT4, so these ratios cannot directly be interpreted as same-hardware speedups. The energy metric integrates GPU power only and should not be equated with whole-laptop battery life. Although some of these limitations are disclosed in the appendix, the main claims should be narrowed accordingly.

Questions for authors
  1. Core comparison: With the same slimmed drafter and CUDA Graph implementation, how does a simple search over γ ∈ {4, 8, 16, 32, 64} on the same calibration set compare with LoadMatch in calibration time and final throughput?

  2. Calibration robustness: How far is the selected configuration from the optimum found by a full sweep when calibration measures only γ = 1 and a large γ, followed by the two neighboring tile boundaries? Does this gap increase when batch size or context length changes?

  3. Evaluation scope: Could you separately report the additional gains over autoregressive decoding with the same INT4 target on identical hardware, and explain how the different GPU counts in Table 8 are accounted for? Could the energy conclusions be explicitly restricted to a GPU energy budget?

9 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Letter (1/2)

Dear reviewer 8q8n,

We thank reviewer 8q8n for the careful and constructive review. We answer the questions below:

Notation: Unless otherwise stated, TpS is evaluated on five datasets: GPQA (science), GSM8K and MATH500 (math), and HumanEval and MBPP (coding), using EAGLE-3 for speculative decoding and GPTQ for quantization.

Q1: How does a simple search over γ ∈ {4, 8, 16, 32, 64} compare with LoadMatch in calibration time and final throughput?

A1: LM reduces calibration time by 2.8× against the simple search, while achieving the same throughput.

ModelMethodCalibration TimeγTpS
L3-8BSimple search23.0m16386
L3-8BLM (Ours)8.3m16386
DS-8BSimple search47.0m16385
DS-8BLM (Ours)16.5m16385

Q2: How far is the selected configuration from the full-sweep optimum, and does this gap increase with batch size or context length?

A2: Our LM stay close to optimum found by a full sweep across batch size or context length.

We compare LoadMatch against a full sweep over γ ∈ {2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64} across varying batch sizes (BS) and context lengths (CL).

Batch sizes. LoadMatch selects between two candidate lengths where BS×γ reaches the tile boundaries of 16 and 32. For example, at BS=2, it compares γ=8 and γ=16 and selects γ=8 for its higher throughput. As shown in the tables, LoadMatch matches the full-sweep optimum across all evaluated batch sizes.

[Method comparison across BS]

MetricMethodBS=1BS=2BS=4BS=8
γFull sweep16844
γLM (Ours)16844
TpSFull sweep3865878921246
TpSLM (Ours)3865878921246

[Full sweep results (TpS) across BS]

BSγ=2γ=4γ=8γ=16γ=32γ=64
1151249353386358269
248657358742421997
4698892878548319146
8103012461024732415192

Context lengths. We report average TpS across three LongBench datasets (HotpotQA, Qasper, and GovReport). Since context length does not affect the number of candidate tokens per verification step, LoadMatch consistently selects γ=16 across all CLs (128-1024). This matches the full-sweep optimum.

[Method comparison across CL]

MetricMethodCL=128CL=256CL=512CL=1024
γFull sweep16161616
γLM (Ours)16161616
TpSFull sweep326342330321
TpSLM (Ours)326342330321

[Full sweep results (TpS) across CL]

CLγ=2γ=4γ=8γ=16γ=32γ=64
128143219285326309241
256144225298342319247
512143221290330311240
1024141216282321300231
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Letter (2/2)

Q3-1: Could you separately report the additional gains over autoregressive decoding with the same INT4 target on identical hardware in table 8?

A3-1: LoadMatch achieves an additional 1.67-3.34× speedup over INT4 autoregressive decoding on identical hardware.

In Table 8, both INT4 autoregressive decoding and LoadMatch are already evaluated using the same two GPUs, ensuring a fair comparison. We report the additional speedup of LoadMatch over the INT4 baseline, as shown below.

CLHotpotQAQasperGovReport
0.5K2.36×1.75×1.77×
1K2.43×3.34×1.78×
2K2.18×2.43×1.70×
4K2.16×2.40×1.67×

Q3-2: How are the different GPU counts in Table 8 accounted for?

A3-2: The different GPU counts in Table 8 have negligible impact on the reported speedups, as verified by additional experiments with matched GPU configurations.

We employ identical hardware configurations for all methods except in Table 8, where the FP16 baseline uses 4 GPUs while INT4-based methods adopt 2 GPUs due to the memory limitation when loading Qwen3.5-27B. However, inter-GPU communication latency (0.05 ms) is negligible compared to computation latency (77.35 ms), suggesting that the difference in GPU counts has little impact on the measured speedups.

To verify this, we repeat the experiments, using the same number of GPUs for all methods. The results remain nearly identical, confirming that the GPU count difference has minimal impact on the reported speedups. In the table below, A → B denotes the original speedup from Table 8 (A) and the re-evaluated results with matched GPU counts (B).

ContextMethodHotpotQAQasperGovReport
0.5KINT43.85→3.854.73→4.724.72→4.71
0.5K+LM9.09→9.078.27→8.268.34→8.33
1KINT43.83→3.823.31→3.304.52→4.51
1K+LM9.30→9.2811.06→11.028.04→8.02
2KINT43.84→3.833.82→3.814.51→4.50
2K+LM8.36→8.349.27→9.247.66→7.64
4KINT43.73→3.723.97→3.964.46→4.45
4K+LM8.07→8.059.52→9.497.45→7.44

Q3-3: Could the energy conclusions be explicitly restricted to a GPU energy budget?

A3-3: Yes, we have revised Figure 7 and the main text to explicitly restrict our energy-related conclusions to GPU energy consumption.

Our energy measurements integrate GPU power consumption only, enabling a consistent comparison of GPU energy efficiency across methods. We clarify that these measurements reflect GPU-level energy consumption rather than whole-system energy usage or laptop battery life.

Closing.

We have revised the manuscript according to the reviewer's comments, as summarized in the table below.

CommentTextNo. of Tab or Fig
R2Q1L510Tab. 11
R2Q2L1132Tabs. 16, 17
R2Q3-2L472Tab. 9
R2Q3-3L453-

We thank the reviewer once again for the thorough and constructive feedback, and we hope our clarifications provide a clearer understanding of LoadMatch.

Sincerely,

The Authors

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Gentle Remainder Letter

Dear reviewer 8q8n,

We sincerely thank the reviewer for taking the time to carefully review our manuscript despite a busy schedule. We summarize our responses to the reviewer's questions below.

RefQuestionAnswer
R2Q1How does a simple search over γ ∈ {4, 8, 16, 32, 64} compare with LoadMatch in calibration time and final throughput?LM reduces calibration time by 2.8× against the simple search, while achieving the same throughput.
R2Q2How far is the selected configuration from the full-sweep optimum, and does this gap increase with batch size or context length?Our LM stay close to optimum found by a full sweep across batch size or context length.
R2Q3-1Could you separately report the additional gains over autoregressive decoding with the same INT4 target on identical hardware in table 8?LoadMatch achieves an additional 1.67-3.34× speedup over INT4 autoregressive decoding on identical hardware.
R2Q3-2How are the different GPU counts in Table 8 accounted for?The different GPU counts in Table 8 have negligible impact on the reported speedups, as verified by additional experiments with matched GPU configurations.
R2Q3-3Could the energy conclusions be explicitly restricted to a GPU energy budget?Yes, we have revised Figure 7 and the main text to explicitly restrict our energy-related conclusions to GPU energy consumption.

If the reviewer has any remaining questions or concerns, we would be more than happy to address them. If the reviewer finds that our responses have adequately addressed the concerns raised, we would sincerely appreciate the reviewer's consideration of updating the assessment of our manuscript.

Sincerely,

The Authors

Reviewer_qW8FOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper argues that decoding throughput is maximized when memory transfer and computation are balanced. To reach this balance in single-request inference, it proposes LoadMatch, which adjusts the candidate-token count of speculative decoding through two-stage latency and throughput profiling. Experiments on several drafters and 8B–27 B models report an average speed up of 8.8× over FP16 autoregressive decoding.

Critical strengths

The evaluation seems to be comprehensive. The method is evaluated across three drafters, five target models, eleven benchmarks, and multiple deployment settings (batching, thinking mode, long context, and energy efficiency).

Critical weaknesses
  1. The insight the author tried to sell in abstract is weak: it is common knowledge that the overhead of de-quantization, accumulation and other operation associated with quantization is significant. Also the "balancing compute and memory" idea is very basic in system research.
  2. Limited Novelty. It is basically just a configuration/parameter tuning approach for speculative decoding on quantized model, in order to achieve the balance that author tried to claim. The method of two-stage profling mechanism sounds very engineering. It is disappointing to me.
  3. No evaluation on actual edge devices. Although the paper is motivated by on-device and edge deployment, all experiments are conducted on an A5000 and an RTX 3090, and no actual edge hardware such as NVIDIA Jetson is evaluated. Considering this, I would encourage the authors to evaluate on at least one actual edge device, or otherwise to scope the claims accordingly.
Questions for authors
  1. what is the research novelty of this paper?
  2. what is the key insight of this paper?

I appreciate author's efforts, but I can barely find research novelty and insight in this submission.

11 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Letter (1/4)

Dear reviewer qW8F,

We thank reviewer qW8F for the thoughtful and constructive review. We answer the questions below:

Notation: Unless otherwise stated, TpS is evaluated on five datasets: GPQA (science), GSM8K and MATH500 (math), and HumanEval and MBPP (coding), using EAGLE-3 for speculative decoding and GPTQ for quantization.

W1: What is the key insight of this paper?

A1: The key insight is to exploit the overlooked potential of memory-compute balancing in quantized LLM through speculative decoding.

We agree that balancing memory and computation workloads underlying our work is a well-established principle in systems research, as exemplified by the roofline model [1]. However, while this principle is well understood in systems research, applying this principle to identify the optimal operating point for quantized LLM decoding has remained largely underexplored in the LLM quantization literature.

Limitations of prior work. Existing quantization studies [2,3,4] primarily focus on reducing memory traffic and improving the efficiency of low-precision computation. However, they do not explicitly adjust the decoding workload to identify the memory-compute balance point. Speculative decoding (SD) offers a natural opportunity to achieve this balance, as the number of candidate tokens verified in parallel provides a direct means of controlling the computational workload. Nevertheless, existing SD methods [5,6,7] typically determine candidate-token counts for full-precision targets and reuse them on quantized models without adjustment. Prior studies combining SD with quantization [8,9,10] have also explored their joint benefits, but do not explicitly optimize candidate-token counts to match the memory and compute loads of quantized verification. Meanwhile, hardware-aware SD methods such as Sequoia [11] and MagicDec [12] optimize speculation based on hardware characteristics or execution conditions, but do not specifically address the shifted memory-compute balance point caused by quantization. Thus, although memory-compute balancing is a fundamental systems principle, neither existing quantization approaches nor quantized SD methods have adequately explored how to exploit this balance to maximize decoding efficiency.

This work. LoadMatch addresses this overlooked optimization opportunity by explicitly identifying the memory-compute balance point of quantized verification and selecting the candidate-token count that maximizes end-to-end throughput. We further reduce drafting overhead through drafter slimming. Our key contribution is therefore not the memory-compute balancing principle itself, but recognizing its unexplored potential in quantized decoding and developing a practical method to exploit it through speculative decoding.


Reference

[1]: Roofline: an insightful visual performance model for multicore architectures, Communications of the ACM, 2009

[2]: Fast Matrix Multiplications for Lookup Table-Quantized LLMs, Findings of EMNLP, 2024

[3]: MARLIN: Mixed-Precision Auto-Regressive Parallel Inference on Large Language Models, PPoPP, 2025

[4]: QServe: W4A8KV4 Quantization and System Co-design for Efficient LLM Serving, MLSys, 2025

[5]: EAGLE-3: Scaling up Inference Acceleration of Large Language Models via Training-Time Test, NeurIPS, 2025

[6]: DFlash: Block Diffusion for Flash Speculative Decoding, ICML, 2026

[7]: Domino: Decoupling Causal Modeling from Autoregressive Drafting in Speculative Decoding, EMNLP, 2026

[8]: QSpec: Speculative Decoding with Complementary Quantization Schemes, EMNLP, 2025

[9]: Quantize the Target, Quantize the Drafter: Efficient Inference with Qwen3.5-4B, ICML Workshop, 2026

[10]: Speculative Decoding Meets Quantization: Compatibility Evaluation and Hierarchical Framework Design, arXiv, 2025

[11]: SEQUOIA: Scalable and Robust Speculative Decoding, NeurIPS, 2024

[12]: MagicDec: Breaking the Latency-Throughput Tradeoff for Long Context Generation with Speculative Decoding, ICLR, 2025

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Letter (2/4)

W2: What is the research novelty of this paper?

A2: LoadMatch is a simple, training-free, and theoretically grounded method that generalizes across diverse settings.

(Contribution 1) As noted by other reviewers (R3), LoadMatch is simple and training-free (R3S2), yet generalizes well across diverse settings (R3S3). We support this claim with three key results.

RESULT 1. We extensively evaluate LoadMatch across nine dimensions, demonstrating its generalizability. Such consistent performance across diverse settings suggests that LoadMatch goes beyond a simple parameter turning.

CategoryDimension# ConfigsConfigurationsReference
algorithmmodel4L3-8B/DS-8B/Q3-4B/Q3-8BTab. 4, 7
algorithmquantization2GPTQ/AWQTab. 5
algorithmspec. decoding3EAGLE-3/DFlash/DOMINOTab. 7
algorithmdecoding2greedy(T=0)/non-greedy(T=1)Tab. 4, 7
taskbenchmark12science(1)/math(2)/coding(2)/chat(2)/general NLP(2)/long-context(3)Tab. 4, 5, 9
taskcontext length40.5K/1K/2K/4KTab. 9
taskreasoning2thinking-on/offTab. 8
deploymentbatch size41/2/4/8Tab. 6
deploymentdevice4RTX 3090/RTX A5000/Jetson Orin/Jetson ThorFig. 8

RESULT 2. LoadMatch not only improves inference speed but also achieves strong overall performance across four key metrics.

MethodMemory↓Accuracy↑Speedup↑TpC↑
AR(FP16)15.0GB56.11.00x0.07M
SD(FP16)15.8GB56.13.48x0.27M
AR(INT4)5.3GB54.92.83x0.21M
SD(INT4)6.1GB54.93.59x0.28M
LM(INT4)5.6GB54.99.25x0.77M

RESULT 3. Our rebuttal experiments demonstrate that LoadMatch efficiently identifies the same optimal candidate length as a full sweep across varying configurations (R2Q2). Moreover, it achieves throughput close to that of an oracle approach with knowledge of accepted tokens in advance (R3Q1).

MethodγCalibration Time↓Speedup↑
Fixed640.0m6.02×6.02\times
Full sweep1623.0m9.25×9.25\times
One-stage LM270.0m8.58×8.58\times
Two-stage LM168.3m9.25×9.25\times
OracleadaptiveN/A9.67×9.67\times
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Letter (3/4)

(Contribution 2) We respectfully argue that LoadMatch is grounded in theoretical principles. We explain (STEP 1) our assumption and (STEP 2) why its selected candidate length achieves near-optimal throughput based on the assumption.

STEP 1. LoadMatch is grounded in the roofline analysis and an assumption about diminishing returns in expected acceptance length:

Analysis 1. According to the roofline model [1], verification latency remains nearly flat up to the load-match point and grows linearly beyond it. Below this point, latency is dominated by memory access, whereas beyond it, computation becomes the bottleneck. This behavior is confirmed empirically in Fig. 4.

Assumption 1. The acceptance length (τ) exhibits diminishing returns, reflecting the increasing difficulty of predicting future tokens. This assumption is empirically observed in existing literature [2,3], while reproduced in the table below:

γτ
21.83
43.05
84.42
165.08
325.50
645.75

STEP 2. Based on Analysis 1 and Assumption 1, we explain why throughput is unimodal and why its optimum is near the load-match point.

Unimodality. Before the load-match point, adding more draft tokens increases the expected acceptance length at almost no additional verification cost (Analysis 1). Thus, throughput increases as more tokens are added. Beyond this point, however, verification latency grows linearly, while the marginal gain in accepted tokens continues to diminish (Assumption 1). As a result, the benefit of adding more tokens eventually becomes smaller than the additional cost. Once throughput starts decreasing, it cannot increase again, giving rise to a single peak.

Optimality. Our Analysis 1 and Assumption 1 suggest that throughput is unimodal, with its optimum likely to lie near the load-match point. To understand why with more details, we consider the two cases where the optimum could lie elsewhere.

CASE 1. The optimum could shift before the load-match point if the acceptance length saturates unusually quickly, such that adding more tokens provides little benefit. However, verification latency remains nearly constant in this region. Since acceptance length is non-decreasing, selecting the load-match point instead of an earlier optimum incurs at most approximately 9% throughput loss under this latency bound.

CASE 2. The optimum could occur beyond the load-match point if additional candidate tokens provide sufficient acceptance gains to offset increased verification latency. However, prior work [4] suggests that expected accepted length grows at most logarithmically with the candidate count, leading to diminishing relative gains as γ increases. The table below compares the potential acceptance gains under a logarithmic growth model with the verification latency overhead.

γAcceptance gain (upper-bound)Acceptance gain (measured)Latency overhead
8→1633%14.9%3.7%
16→3225%8.3%17.0%
32→6420%4.5%38.9%

Notably, expanding γ from 32 to 64 yields less than a 20% acceptance gain under the logarithmic model, while verification latency increases by 39%, making larger candidate counts unlikely to improve throughput. In contrast, moving γ from 16 to 32 offers a potential acceptance gain of up to 25%, exceeding the 17% latency increase. Thus, the optimal choice between 16 and 32 cannot be determined analytically, motivating stage 2 to compare their end-to-end throughput directly.

Together, these cases explain why the load-match point provides a natural anchor for the search: moving substantially below it offers little latency benefit, while moving far beyond it incurs rapidly increasing cost for diminishing acceptance gains. LoadMatch exploits this structure by locating the load-match point in stage 1 using two latency measurements, then comparing the neighboring tile boundaries in stage 2.


Reference

[1]: Roofline: an insightful visual performance model for multicore architectures, Communications of the ACM, 2009

[2]: Medusa: Simple LLM Inference Acceleration Framework with Multiple Decoding Heads, ICML, 2024

[3]: EAGLE-3: Scaling up Inference Acceleration of Large Language Models via Training-Time Test, NeurIPS, 2025

[4]: SEQUOIA: Scalable and Robust Speculative Decoding, NeurIPS, 2024

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response Letter

Dear area chair and reviewers,

We thank the area chair (vL5G) and reviewers (R1: qW8F, R2: 8q8n, R3: ijdT) for their thoughtful and constructive feedback.

In our individual responses we have done our best to answer every question from all three reviewers. In this comment we group those questions into four categories, so that the answers relevant to each concern can be found in one place. For better readability, the tables pair a one-line question with a one-line answer. Each row is tagged with the reviewer and the label used in our per-reviewer responses (e.g., R2Q1), where W stands for a weakness and Q represent a question.

Q1: The key insight (R1W1) and the research novelty (R1W2) beyond the established memory-compute balancing principle are unclear.

A1: Our contribution is not the balancing principle itself but a training-free, roofline-grounded method that exploits it in quantized LLMs through speculative decoding.

RefQuestionAnswer
R1W1What is the key insight of this paper?The key insight is to exploit the overlooked potential of memory-compute balancing in quantized LLM through speculative decoding.
R1W2What is the research novelty of this paper?LoadMatch is a simple, training-free, and theoretically grounded method that generalizes across diverse settings.

Q2: It is unclear how close the point found by LoadMatch is to the optimum found by a full sweep (R2Q1, R2Q2) or by runtime adaptation (R3Q1-1, R3Q1-2).

A2: The point found by LoadMatch matches the optimum found by a full sweep at 2.8× less calibration time and stays close to the oracle dynamic token selection method that knows the accepted tokens in advance.

RefQuestionAnswer
R2Q1How does a simple search over γ ∈ {4, 8, 16, 32, 64} compare with LoadMatch in calibration time and final throughput?LM reduces calibration time by 2.8× against the simple search, while achieving the same throughput.
R2Q2How far is the selected configuration from the full-sweep optimum, and does this gap increase with batch size or context length?Our LM stay close to optimum found by a full sweep across batch size or context length.
R3Q1-1How sensitive is LoadMatch to dynamic changes in draft acceptance rates during a single long generation?Although accepted length fluctuates substantially across steps, LoadMatch stays close to the oracle token selection method.
R3Q1-2Have you considered adapting the candidate token count (γ) dynamically at runtime based on recent acceptance feedback rather than relying strictly on an offline fixed γ?We evaluate three runtime-adaptive schedulers and find that dynamic γ adjustment provides only limited benefits.

Q3: The evaluation does not cover actual edge devices (R1W3) or out-of-domain datasets under vocabulary pruning (R3Q2).

A3: LoadMatch performs favorably on NVIDIA Jetson Orin and Thor, and vocabulary pruning still improves throughput on out-of-domain datasets.

RefQuestionAnswer
R1W3Lack of evaluation on actual edge devices, such as NVIDIA Jetson.LoadMatch performs well on NVIDIA Jetson Orin and Thor.
R3Q2Impact of vocabulary pruning on out-of-domain benchmarks.LoadMatch achieves higher throughput with vocabulary pruning on out-of-domain benchmarks containing more low-frequency tokens.

Q4: Table 8 speedups should be separated from hardware differences (R2Q3-1, R2Q3-2), and the energy conclusions need an explicit scope (R2Q3-3).

A4: Table 8 speedups stay nearly same on identical hardware, and the energy claims are now GPU-only.

RefQuestionAnswer
R2Q3-1Could you separately report the additional gains over autoregressive decoding with the same INT4 target on identical hardware in table 8?LoadMatch achieves an additional 1.67-3.34× speedup over INT4 autoregressive decoding on identical hardware.
R2Q3-2How are the different GPU counts in Table 8 accounted for?The different GPU counts in Table 8 have negligible impact on the reported speedups, as verified by additional experiments with matched GPU configurations.
R2Q3-3Could the energy conclusions be explicitly restricted to a GPU energy budget?Yes, we have revised Figure 7 and the main text to explicitly restrict our energy-related conclusions to GPU energy consumption.

Closing.

We have revised the manuscript according to the reviewers' comments, as summarized in the table below.

CommentTextNo. of Tab or Fig
R1W1L064, L133-
R1W2-1L510Tab. 11
R1W2-2L195Tab. 2
R1W3L459Fig. 8
R2Q1L510Tab. 11
R2Q2L1132Tabs. 16, 17
R2Q3-2L472Tab. 9
R2Q3-3L453-
R3Q1-1L1142Tabs. 18-21
R3Q1-2L510Tab. 12
R3Q2L514Tab. 13

We believe this feedback has helped us improve the paper, and we are grateful to the reviewers for it. We remain glad to provide any further clarification during the discussion period.

Sincerely,

The Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.