- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an AI-generated video detector that jointly optimizes a VAE reconstructor and a classifier to learn discriminative reconstruction errors, and uses 3D convolutions to extract spatiotemporal evidence motivated by relative second-order temporal differences (RSTD). Experiments across multiple video-generation benchmarks report strong detection performance, with ablations examining adaptive reconstruction and temporal modeling.
Critical strengths
S1 - The problem is important, and the motivation for combining reconstruction residuals with second-order features is logical.
S2 - The comparative experiments are comprehensive and effectively demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed approach.
Critical weaknesses
W1 - The writing is not good. The discussions of related work and preliminaries are lengthy. The main text lacks a conclusion section (It should not be placed in the appendix), and the analysis in main text refers to a table in the appendix (line 376).
W2 - The proposed method is limited in novelty. VAE reconstruction and 3D convolutions are common techniques, and the explanation that 3D convolutions can implicitly represent RSTD is not fully convincing.
Questions for authors
Q1 - In Section 5.3, introducing RSTD reduces performance, which conflicts with the claim that 3D convolutions implicitly learn RSTD. The authors should provide additional experiments or theoretical analysis to clarify this relationship. ( The proof in Appendix A only shows that adding RSTD does not enlarge the local 3D convolution's function class, not that it uses RSTD patterns for classification. )
Q2 - No robustness experiments (e.g., video compression) are found. Since reconstruction residuals may involve noise features, robustness to post-processing is important.
-
Minor Question
-
Q3 - Some baselines (e.g., D3) appear to perform differently from their original papers. Could the authors explain this (for example, whether the evaluation datasets differ)?
Dear reviewers,
The discussion phase is nearing its end. If you haven't already, could you please read the author's rebuttal and respond?
Thank you & kind regards,
Your AC