- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies whether post-training can improve the structural accuracy of table recognition, particularly for merged cells with complex row and column spans. Using PaddleOCR-VL 1.6 as the backbone, the paper proposes a three-stage pipeline consisting of supervised fine-tuning (SFT), direct preference optimization (DPO), and group relative policy optimization (GRPO). The method combines coverage-balanced training data, structurally filtered preference pairs, and rewards based on TEDS, TEDS-S, and exact merged-cell F1.
Critical strengths
The evaluation of exact merged-cell recovery is potentially useful.
Critical weaknesses
I have serious concerns about the integrity and preparation of this submission. The paper contains numerous basic errors that should have been caught by the authors:
- The OpenReview title does not match the PDF title.
- The submitted abstract claims GSPO, whereas the PDF describes GRPO.
- Multiple references contain incorrect author information or arXiv IDs. For example, the Dolphin reference (p. 11) points to an entirely unrelated paper.
- The mandatory AI Use Statement is missing.
- The reported improvements are based on test-set checkpoint selection, while several transfer datasets show regressions.
The number of elementary inconsistencies raises serious concerns that the manuscript may have been AI-generated or assembled without adequate human verification. Regardless of how it was produced, the submission appears not to have undergone even basic author-level fact-checking.
Questions for authors
The number of obvious errors in this paper is quite concerning. Several references are incorrect or point to unrelated papers. The submitted abstract describes GSPO, while the manuscript uses GRPO. The required AI Use Statement is also missing.
These are basic issues that should have been caught before submission. I strongly suspect that the manuscript was largely generated using AI without meaningful review by the authors.
Can the authors clarify how this paper was prepared, whether generative AI was used, and what steps were taken to verify the references, methodology, and experimental results before submission?