- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses the problem of learning cross-channel dependencies in generative probabilistic time-series forecasters. The authors illustrate the importance of modeling cross-channel coupling through conceptual examples and data analysis of two correlated time series from the multivariate ETTh1 dataset.
The proposed method, named Generative Noise Coupling (GeNCoup), draws channel-wise noise using a cross-channel symmetric and positive semi-definite covariance matrix R, instead of drawing channel-wise noise values independently. To have R preserve the original noise distribution of each channel, the authors show that R must have a unit diagonal. By the definition of the original channel-independent sampling and the coupled seed, this method also preserves the temporal dependence within each channel. The authors propose two variants that differ in how R is set: (1) GeNCoup-CORR which sets R based on a linear interpolation between global and local cross-channel correlations and (2) GeNCoup-DYN which learns the coupling directly, while keeping the probabilistic forecaster frozen. Rather than sampling the noise directly from a gaussian distribution with a covariance matrix R, GeNCoup-DYN multiplies the original noise trajectory with a learnable matrix A, which is equivalent to sampling with . This is shown to guarantee symmetry, positive semidefinitenes and a unit diagonal of R by construction.
GeNCoup is different from post-hoc methods, which operate on generated forecast ensembles and from quantile methods which predict intervals per time point. Compared to dependence-reconstruction methods, which recover joint information and preserve marginals, GeNCoup also preserves temporal dependence and is integrated into the forecaster. GeNCoup-DYN is also E2E minimizable.
The authors evaluate GeNCoup on eight standard time series forecasting datasets and compare it to six representative generative probabilistic time series forecasters from four generative families (including recent baselines from 2025-2026) and five post-hoc methods. GeNCoup achieves the best variogram score on seven of eight datasets and the best cross-channel energy score on six of eight datasets, while better preserving CRPS/NMAE and temporal dynamics compared to post-hoc baselines. Main evaluation results are reported across three seeds. The authors further perform ablations and analyses related to key design choices in GeNCoup-CORR. They show that using a validation-optimized alpha value to blend local and global cross-correlations (a*) is better than using global only (a=0) or local only (a=1) alternatives, on average. In addition, to evaluate the choice of setting R to the empirical cross-channel correlation matrix of the observed data the authors evaluate the cross-channel correlation of the recovered source noise and compare it against the empirical correlation matrix.
Critical strengths
- A novel method that offers conceptual advantages over existing baselines, addressing a well-motivated problem.
- State-of-the-art results in terms of cross-channel performance compared to contemporary representative generative baselines and post-thoc methods, on multiple standard time series benchmarks. Results are reported across three seeds, method coverage appears sufficient, and the detailed tables underlying the aggregations presented in the main text are provided in the appendix. The authors provide ablations and empirical analyses to evaluate key design choices.
Critical weaknesses
The authors aim to preserve marginal behavior while injecting cross-channel dependence. However, for generative forecasters such as COBASE, the differences in CRPS and N-MAE (which measure marginal performance) are 0.000 on average, while for GeNCoup they are 0.012. While the authors interpret this as preserving the marginals, the practical implications of a difference of this magnitude are unclear and should be discussed. This is an important aspect since the authors set it as one the requirements of their method.
Questions for authors
Could the authors clarify their criterion for "marginal preservation" and discuss how their results compare to generative baselines that achieve lower marginal degradation (e.g., COBASE)?
3 comments
I thank the authors for addressing my initial concerns and appreciate their effort in revising the paper and re-running experiments. Given the identified leakage risk and potential fidelity issues with the COBASE implementation, could the authors elaborate on their claim that "the updated results generally preserve the relative rankings across the tables"? Comparing the red and blue numbers across the tables is hard to parse and summarize into new conclusions, so a summary of the main trends and specific discrepancies (especially where they may impact the original conclusions) would strengthen confidence in the updated result and the submitted revision.
Response to Reviewer 9Cvp
We thank the reviewer for their follow-up. By stating that the updated results generally preserve the relative rankings across the tables, we were primarily referring to the "1st count" row in Table 2, which counts the number of datasets on which each method achieves the best score among all compared methods. Before the corrections, the two GeNCoup variants achieved the best VS on 7/8 datasets and the best ES-Chan on 6/8 datasets. Following the corrections, the VS count remains unchanged at 7/8, while the ES-Chan count decreases to 5/8. This difference is driven by ETTh2, where Schaake now achieves the best ES-Chan score.
Regarding the quantitative changes, GeNCoup-Corr is only marginally affected. Averaged across the 8 datasets, its VS improvement over the frozen forecaster changed from −10.71% to −10.43%, while its ES-Chan improvement changed from −1.57% to −1.49%. These correspond to reductions of only 0.28 and 0.07 percentage points, respectively, in the average improvements over the frozen forecaster. The largest changes are concentrated in ETTh2 and ETTm2, while the remaining datasets exhibit generally smaller differences. GeNCoup-Dyn remains entirely unaffected. For COBASE, the average improvements over the frozen forecaster decreased by 0.50 and 0.23 percentage points in VS and ES-Chan, respectively.
Overall, the main experimental conclusions remain unchanged, with GeNCoup continuing to achieve the strongest overall cross-channel performance among the compared methods.
To facilitate comparison, we provide below the full per-dataset breakdown of GeNCoup-Corr and COBASE before and after the corrections, corresponding to Table 2 of the main paper. Values represent percentage changes relative to the uncoupled frozen forecaster (negative is better), while differences are expressed in percentage points.
| Method, metric | ETTh1 | ETTh2 | ETTm1 | ETTm2 | Weather | ECL | Traffic | Solar | Mean |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Corr VS prev | −11.994 | −4.395 | −11.750 | −3.722 | −7.723 | −0.878 | −1.597 | −43.582 | −10.705 |
| Corr VS now | −11.905 | −3.524 | −11.741 | −2.958 | −7.647 | −0.844 | −1.559 | −43.236 | −10.427 |
| Corr VS diff | +0.089 | +0.871 | +0.009 | +0.764 | +0.076 | +0.034 | +0.038 | +0.346 | +0.278 |
| Corr ES-Chan prev | −1.404 | −0.937 | −1.436 | −0.841 | −1.561 | −0.509 | +0.141 | −5.970 | −1.565 |
| Corr ES-Chan now | −1.358 | −0.741 | −1.351 | −0.707 | −1.465 | −0.481 | +0.095 | −5.944 | −1.494 |
| Corr ES-Chan diff | +0.046 | +0.196 | +0.085 | +0.134 | +0.096 | +0.028 | −0.046 | +0.026 | +0.071 |
| COBASE VS prev | −11.057 | −3.837 | −10.844 | −4.069 | −6.033 | −1.459 | −1.468 | −31.215 | −8.748 |
| COBASE VS now | −10.255 | −4.340 | −9.860 | −4.030 | −4.799 | −1.026 | −1.113 | −30.575 | −8.250 |
| COBASE VS diff | +0.802 | −0.503 | +0.984 | +0.039 | +1.234 | +0.433 | +0.355 | +0.640 | +0.498 |
| COBASE ES-Chan prev | −1.337 | −0.848 | −1.378 | −0.970 | −1.160 | −0.446 | −0.848 | −5.356 | −1.543 |
| COBASE ES-Chan now | −1.267 | −0.768 | −1.234 | −0.792 | −0.781 | −0.225 | −0.540 | −4.862 | −1.309 |
| COBASE ES-Chan diff | +0.070 | +0.080 | +0.144 | +0.178 | +0.379 | +0.221 | +0.308 | +0.494 | +0.234 |
We also reran the affected analyses where necessary, and their conclusions remain unchanged. All additional rebuttal experiments used the corrected GeNCoup-Corr implementation.
Response
We thank the reviewer for their thoughtful and valuable feedback.
Q:
A:
To assess whether the observed marginal differences are practically meaningful, we introduce an empirical preservation criterion based on the uncoupled forecaster's sampling noise across random seeds. This allows us to assess marginal preservation by comparing the observed changes against the expected sampling variability, rather than relying solely on their absolute magnitude. We have formalized this criterion in the Experiments section of the revised manuscript.
Preservation criterion. For each metric, we first average the uncoupled forecaster's scores across experimental settings for each seed, then compute the standard deviation across seeds. Since our results report relative percentage changes rather than absolute scores, we express the standard deviation as a percentage of the mean across seeds, yielding a directly comparable noise threshold. Changes within this threshold are treated as consistent with empirical preservation. These thresholds are reported in the Noise row of the results tables and apply to both marginal (CRPS, NMAE) and temporal (ES-Time) metrics.
Comparison with post-hoc baselines. The zero CRPS and NMAE changes reported for post-hoc reordering methods such as COBASE are guaranteed by construction. These methods use exactly the same generated values, changing only their assignment across scenarios. Since CRPS and NMAE are computed marginally for each channel and time step, they are invariant to scenario ordering. Consequently, their marginal score differences are exactly zero. In contrast, GeNCoup modifies the sampling process itself, generating new trajectories rather than reordering existing ones. Therefore, we expect marginal score changes to remain within the uncoupled forecaster's sampling noise threshold, rather than being exactly zero.
Results. Both GeNCoup variants satisfy our empirical preservation criterion, with aggregate CRPS, NMAE, and ES-Time changes all falling within their respective noise thresholds (approximately 0.02%). Notably, GeNCoup is the only method whose aggregate ES-Time changes remain within the 0.025% noise threshold, compared with 0.076–3.047% for post-hoc baselines. Thus, GeNCoup improves cross-channel dependence while empirically preserving both marginal accuracy and temporal dynamics.
In addition, we would like to note that, following Reviewer 3xqd's observations, we revised two aspects of our experimental setup. First, to address a potential information leakage risk, we revised the estimation of R_local to use each window's observed lookback independently, rather than pooling observations across evaluation minibatches. This eliminates the identified leakage risk and ensures that predictions are independent of batch size. Second, in response to the reviewer's concerns about the fidelity of our COBASE implementation, we revised it to best match the original method. We reran all experiments and analyses and updated the manuscript accordingly ( previous results are marked in red, while the updated results are marked in blue). The updated results generally preserve the relative rankings across the tables.