- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
SLES reads text cross-attention to locate a subject region, doubles the flow-matching loss weight there, and applies localized overshooting and re-noising during sampling. The text signal selects where to intervene; the ground-truth training target is unchanged. The main paper and appendix report identity-recovery and temporal-stability gains under the stated full-context bidirectional protocol, including a 345-scene evaluation and transfer to LTX-2.5.
Critical strengths
- The appendix strengthens the controlled recovery evidence. On all 345 held-out scenes, training raises SC from 0.8078 to 0.8206 and reappearance from 96.7% to 98.3% (Table D6). Together with the GT-mask and scrambled-support controls, this supports useful spatially focused supervision without per-sample target masks after calibration. 2.The additional analyses make the contribution easier to assess. Appendix B documents retrieval shifts and unsuccessful direct attention steering; A.3 and Fig. D2 clarify the complementary identity and temporal evidence. The sampling dose-response analysis in E.1 supports a trade-off between temporal-stability gains and full-frame perceptual change, rather than a claim that localization always maximizes TCM.
Critical weaknesses
- Causal training is needed to establish the method's practical value for autoregressive world models. I did not find a causally trained SLES comparison in the supplied main paper or appendix. A matched causal baseline and SLES, trained and rolled out with exit and re-entry in different generation blocks, would test this practical memory claim. Applying a causal mask only at inference would introduce a training-inference mismatch. 2.The appendix documents missed support near re-entry. Fig. C1 shows misses around leaving and returning transitions; across 94 validation scenes, only 31% of frames with 1-5-token subjects receive support, versus 93% for subjects larger than 40 tokens. Unsupported tokens receive no extra loss weight or local sampling correction. These diagnostics are useful, but aggregate recovery scores do not show how much SLES helps small returning subjects or the first post-entry frames.
Questions for authors
- Could you compare a baseline and SLES both trained with the same frame- or block-causal mask, then run multiple generation blocks with earlier outputs fixed and exit/re-entry spanning different blocks?
- How much of the recovery gain remains for small returning subjects and the first few post-entry frames?