- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
LocoWM studies stable transportation of unsecured payloads by a wheeled-legged robot while tracking velocity commands. The method first learns a base locomotion policy and a short-term task-state predictor, then freezes both and trains a residual adapter to correct actions using the predictions. Go2-W simulation experiments report improvements in payload retention and tray stability, complemented by Go2-W real-robot demonstrations and a simulation extension to the G1 humanoid.
Critical strengths
- A coherent framework addressing a practically meaningful problem. LocoWM addresses payload stabilization during locomotion through a clear separation between locomotion acquisition and precision adaptation. Using physically interpretable task substates to connect the precision objective, prediction target, and residual-controller input provides a well-motivated design.
- Substantial experimental coverage within the target application. The evaluation covers four terrain types, acceleration compensation, push recovery, physical Go2-W demonstrations, and an additional humanoid simulation study. Comparisons with end-to-end and reactive residual baselines show meaningful improvements: relative to Recon, payload-retention success increases from 61.5% to 91.1% on slopes and from 67.7% to 87.5% on bumps.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty over predictive residual control is insufficiently established. Conditioning residual corrections on predicted consequences of base actions already appears in KORR (Gong et al., 2025), including an MLP-based dynamics variant. Frozen-base residual adaptation is also established in ReST-RL. LocoWM introduces meaningful differences through task-specific physical substates, multi-step prediction, and staged training, but neither discusses KORR nor sufficiently isolates the benefits of these differences. Consequently, the methodological advance over existing designs remains unclear.
- Task breadth and hardware generalization remain limited. The three main tasks are useful but primarily examine different disturbances within the same payload-stabilization objective. Go2-W hardware results are primarily qualitative, while the G1 extension remains simulation-only. Its success-rate improvements over ReST-RL are modest—1.9–3.1 percentage points—and lack uncertainty estimates. These results provide preliminary evidence, but do not yet establish reliable generalization to humanoid hardware or broader precision-control tasks.
Questions for authors
- Novelty clarification: How does LocoWM differ technically from KORR and its MLP-based predictive residual variant? Which results establish the additional benefits of the task-substate interface, multi-step prediction, and staged training?
- Mechanism analysis: Can the authors report prediction accuracy under both the base and adapted policies, together with horizon and action-conditioning ablations, to clarify whether accurate future forecasts drive the gains?
- Evaluation clarification: How many independent training seeds and evaluation trials support the results? Could confidence intervals be provided, particularly for the relatively small G1 improvements over ReST-RL?
- Additional hardware validation: Could the authors provide repeated quantitative hardware comparisons against the residual baselines? A physical G1 evaluation would be particularly valuable for assessing whether the simulated humanoid gains transfer to real bipedal locomotion.
ResponsesA1: Thank you for pointing out KORR. We have added it to (Sec. 2, L112–118, P3). In our view, LocoWM differs mainly in what the residual is conditioned on and how that conditioning is trained; we do not claim frozen-base residual adaptation as a contribution (as in ReST-RL, React, and Recon).
Design Differences: KORR is evaluated on simulated manipulation, whereas LocoWM targets legged locomotion with unsecured payloads and is validated on hardware. Transferring KORR to this setting exposes limitations that the staged training, task substates, and multi-step prediction you mention address (Appendix C.3–C.4, Tables 9 & 11, P26–27):
Matched Comparison: From the same base checkpoint and budget, LocoWM reaches 93.63% SR vs. 71.16% (KORR-MLP) and 76.48% (KORR-Koopman), both below Recon (80.23%). KORR-Koopman is close to the jointly trained variant (77.30%), consistent with the analysis above. (Appendix C.3, Table 10, L1374, P26)
A2:
Accuracy under Both Policies: By design, the WM predicts the future under the base policy, which the adapter then corrects. The R2 drop from 0.88 to 0.70 under the adapted policy (A1.1) is thus expected: the executed future already contains the residual's correction. (Appendix C.3, Table 9a, L1356, P26)
Horizon & Action Conditioning: (Appendix C.4, Table 11, L1404, P27)
Accurate Forecasts Drive the Gains:
A3:
Seeds & Trials: In Go2-W simulation, each method uses 5 independent training seeds, each evaluated per terrain with 4096 parallel environments (one trial each). Standard deviations are computed across trials and 95% CIs across seeds (Appendix C.1.1, Tables 6–7, L1080–1107, P21); G1 CIs are in (Appendix D.2, Table 14, L1470, P28).
G1 vs. ReST-RL: 95% CIs of the SR difference:
The CI excludes zero on Command Track and Push Object. On Push Robot, its lower bound touches zero, so we do not claim a significant improvement there. The G1 study tests transfer to another embodiment; the main evidence remains on Go2-W.
A4:
Go2-W Hardware Comparison: Each of five methods was run 10 times on three hardware terrains (150 trials). LocoWM retains the payload in 28/30 trials vs. 23/30 for Recon, the strongest baseline, with the lowest pitch (5.06° vs. 7.92°) and roll (3.69° vs. 8.57°) errors. (Appendix C.2, Table 8, L1252, P24)
Physical G1 & Task Breadth: We agree that the G1 study is simulation-only and all tasks concern payload stabilization. Our Limitations now note that other precision objectives (e.g., end-effector stabilization) remain to be validated (Sec. 5, L470–475, P9).
SummaryThank you for recognizing our coherent framework and substantial experimental coverage. If our responses address your concerns, we would sincerely appreciate your consideration for raising the score.