- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TabMaDo, a diffusion-based oversampling method for imbalanced binary tabular classification. Motivated by the observation that the extreme scarcity of minority samples can prevent a diffusion model from learning their distribution directly, TabMaDo learns the overall data distribution from all samples and steers the reverse process toward the minority class. It has two components: Tabulamba, a Mamba-based noise predictor, and a light Guider that combines a minority-class classifier.
Critical strengths
Generative oversampling under extreme imbalance is a practical and valuable problem.
Critical weaknesses
-
Both components of TabMaDo have close counterparts in prior work. The idea of learning the distribution from all data and then steering toward the minority class is also what class-conditional diffusion models such as TabDDPM already do. The paper does not clearly explain how TabMaDo fundamentally differs from these methods, nor does it compare against the most direct alternatives.
-
Many citations are misattributed: the references given for TabDiT, ACWGAN, random oversampling, and GBDT point to unrelated papers, while some important foundational works such as DDPM, Mamba, and SMOTE are not cited. The related work section also lacks a substantive comparison between existing tabular oversampling and generation methods and the proposed method.
-
The most critical issue is that in Table 4, the rows for wilt and vehicle0 are identical for all methods and all metrics. Given how different these two datasets are, this is not plausible.
Questions for authors
-
Could you please provide corrected and real Table 4 rows for wilt and vehicle0 results and confirm whether other tables are also affected?
-
What is the fundamental difference between the Guider and RelDDPM’s controller, or standard classifier guidance?