- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DanceOPD formulates multi-capability composition as on-policy distillation of compatible generative velocity fields into one flow-matching student. Each sample is routed to one frozen field, which supervises the student through velocity MSE at a single low-noise state from a detached student rollout. The formulation accommodates both learned expert fields and operator-defined fields such as classifier-free guidance. Validation covers generation/editing composition, local/global editing composition, realism absorption, and guidance absorption, with ablations of routing, query placement and count, objectives, and initialization.
Critical strengths
-
An insightful perspective on capability composition through velocity fields. The paper represents specialized generative capabilities as compatible velocity fields and organizes their composition around which field to query, where to query it, and how many states to supervise. This provides a coherent formulation encompassing both learned experts and operator-defined fields such as classifier-free guidance. Its conceptual value is the unified treatment of these capability sources; its practical value is distilling their behaviors into one deployable student.
-
Encouraging experimental results and informative ablations. Across both composition settings, the reported results show improved average editing performance while preserving text-to-image generation capability. Systematic ablations examine routing, query placement and count, objectives, rollout length, and initialization, supporting the main design choices and providing useful guidance for applying the method.
Critical weaknesses
The T2I off-policy baseline uses random-noise endpoints, limiting the evidence for the advantage of on-policy querying. Appendix B.4 constructs off-policy states as
For editing, is an encoded target image. For T2I, however, Equation 50 sets , with and independent standard Gaussian noise. Consequently,
\sim\mathcal{N}\left(0,(\alpha_t^2+\sigma_t^2)I\right).$$ At low noise, $\alpha_t\approx1$ and $\sigma_t\approx0$, so the query remains approximately random noise rather than a lightly noised image latent. The teacher still supplies a velocity target, but receives a query latent with no image-derived structure at a near-clean timestep. This may disadvantage the baseline precisely where the query distribution concentrates. The comparison therefore does not distinguish the benefit of current-student states from the benefit of replacing these random endpoints with image-derived endpoints. A control using prompt-matched teacher-generated images would materially strengthen the on-policy claim. This concern applies to the T2I bucket; the editing buckets already use image-derived endpoints.Questions for authors
-
Assessment-critical controlled comparison: Does the T2I/editing advantage over off-policy distillation persist when its T2I endpoint is , using teacher-generated images for the same prompts? Please keep the other training settings matched and account for endpoint-generation cost.
-
Clarification: Which checkpoint initializes each method in Table 2? Appendix B.5 identifies DanceOPD's diagnostic initialization, but the initialization used for its main composition results is unclear.
7 comments
Follow-Up to Your Review (Second Reminder)
Dear Reviewer dMkY,
Thank you again for the time and care you put into reviewing our work!
We know this is a busy period, so we wanted to follow up briefly on our point-by-point responses and the revised manuscript, where we highlighted the changes for easy reference.
If you have a chance to look over our responses, we would appreciate hearing whether they address your main concerns. If anything remains unclear, we would be happy to clarify it here.
Thanks again for your support!
Sincerely yours,
The Authors of Submission 4626
Follow-Up to Your Review (Third Reminder)
Dear Reviewer dMkY,
We are following up on our point-by-point responses and the revised manuscript, which we posted several days ago. We believe these materials further address your concerns and highlight the changes we made in response to your feedback.
As the end of the Author-Reviewer Discussion phase is fast approaching, please let us know whether our responses address your main concerns or if any points still need clarification. We are available to discuss them here.
Thank you again for your time and effort devoted in this review!
Best,
The Authors of Submission 4626
Follow-Up to Your Review
Dear Reviewer
dMkY,Thank you again for the time and effort you put into reviewing our work!
We understand that this might be a super busy period for you. We wanted to briefly let you know that we have posted point-by-point responses to your questions and concerns and uploaded a revised manuscript with the changes highlighted.
Whenever you have a chance, we would be grateful for your feedback on whether the responses address your concerns. We would be happy to clarify anything that remains open.
Thank you!
Best,
The Authors of Submission
4626