- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the Video Reversal Curse, where VLMs struggle with backward temporal reasoning and often ignore frame order. It proposes ReVID, which combines temporally symmetric reinforcement learning and contrastive decoding for diffusion VLMs, along with a new benchmark called RevVideo.
Critical strengths
- The paper demonstrates the effect of the Video Reversal Curse and proposes ReVID, which combines Temporal-Symmetric GRPO and Temporal Visual Contrastive Decoding to alleviate this effect.
- The paper introduces RevVideo benchmark, which provides paired forward/backward questions and a Temporal Symmetry Score (TSS) to evaluate bidirectional temporal reasoning.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient evidence for the advantage of diffusion VLMs. The proposed SFT, temporal rewards, and contrastive decoding can also be applied to autoregressive VLMs. Although Appendix G evaluates TVCD on an AR model, a fair comparison using the complete ReVID pipeline is missing. It remains unclear whether the improvements mainly come from the diffusion architecture or the proposed training and decoding strategies.
- Missing strong baselines and fair comparisons. Relevant temporal reasoning methods, such as Video-R1, Time-R1, and SEASON, are discussed but not directly compared in the experiments. Including these baselines under comparable settings (e.g., trained with the same data) would better demonstrate the effectiveness of ReVID.
Questions for authors
- Questionable reward design (Eqs. 3–5). The Temporal Reliance Reward can be positive even when ordered and shuffled videos achieve the same accuracy ((\mu=0.8)). Moreover, the group-level symmetry reward may cancel out under standard GRPO advantage normalization. It is unclear how these rewards effectively encourage temporal reasoning.
- Insufficient analysis of the Video Reversal Curse. The discussion is mostly high-level and lacks quantitative evidence to support the proposed explanations. In particular, it remains unclear how severely this problem affects dVLMs and whether their architectural properties actually provide an advantage over AR-VLMs.
- Insufficient details on benchmark construction. The RevVideo construction pipeline lacks important implementation details, particularly regarding how temporal reversibility filtering is performed.
- SFT + TS-GRPO without TVCD performs worse than the original backbone (47.65% vs. 50.57% in Table 8), raising concerns about the effectiveness of the proposed training strategy independently of TVCD.
- Unclear temporal symmetry in qualitative examples. Some forward/backward QA pairs appear not to correspond to exactly symmetric temporal transitions or supporting frames. The authors should clarify how temporal symmetry is defined and verified in these examples.