- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript investigates the substantial performance degradation of voxel-indexed point cloud networks when the voxel resolution differs between training and inference. The authors attribute this degradation primarily to a mismatch in spatial indexing units rather than the loss of geometric information. To address this issue, they introduce a training-free relabelling method that recomputes voxel indices using the training resolution while retaining the points selected at the test resolution. Experiments across three network architectures and two benchmark datasets show that the method recovers 70–90% of the performance loss at three times the training voxel size. The results also demonstrate reduced memory consumption and inference time on dense indoor point clouds. Overall, the study offers a useful perspective on resolution sensitivity in voxel-based point cloud networks.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides a useful explanation for the performance degradation of voxel-indexed point cloud networks under mismatched training and inference resolutions. By separating voxel sampling from spatial indexing, it shows that much of the degradation arises from indexing-unit mismatch rather than geometric information loss alone. This finding improves our understanding of resolution sensitivity in voxel-based architectures.
- The proposed relabelling method is simple, requires no retraining, and achieves substantial performance recovery across three architectures and two datasets. The use of frozen checkpoints, negative controls, and operator-level ablations strengthens the experimental evidence and supports the practical relevance of the approach.
Critical weaknesses
- The proposed explanation does not fully disentangle indexing-unit mismatch from the changes in neighborhood connectivity, pooling structure, and serialization induced by relabelling. Although the ablation studies provide supporting evidence, the extent to which unit mismatch alone accounts for the observed performance degradation remains uncertain.
- The method's generalizability is not fully established. Table 15 shows a noticeable performance drop when voxel centroids replace sampled points, indicating sensitivity to the voxelization strategy. Moreover, the proposed relabelling operation is closely related to existing scale normalization concepts, leaving its methodological novelty and broader applicability insufficiently demonstrated.
Questions for authors
- To what extent can the performance recovery be attributed specifically to correcting the indexing-unit mismatch, rather than to the accompanying changes in neighborhood connectivity, pooling, and serialization? Do the existing ablations sufficiently distinguish these effects?
- Table 15 shows that replacing sampled points with voxel centroids reduces the relabelled mIoU from 62.21 to 56.76, while the stock performance remains unchanged. What accounts for this sensitivity, and how does it affect the claimed applicability of the method to different voxelization pipelines?
- Given the close relationship between relabelling and existing scale normalization approaches, what is the substantive methodological distinction beyond applying the training voxel size to recompute spatial indices at inference time?
2 comments
Thanks to the author for the reply. The revised manuscript added operator-level ablation experiments, explained the impact of different voxelization strategies on the results, and further clarified the difference from existing scale normalization methods. The new experiments and analysis addressed the previous questions well, and my main concerns about the paper have been resolved, so I’m keeping my original rating of Weak Acceptance (3 points).
Thank you for the review. The revised paper answers each question; the passages are in blue.
W1 / Q1. Unit mismatch, or the changes in neighbourhood, pooling and serialization. The ablations now separate them (Figure 6, Figure R3, Section 4.5).
The gain needs the training unit in the pooling and, on LitePT, in the rotary phase; it does not need the training neighbourhood or the relabelled window order. The operators act in series, so we report which ones are needed rather than a share for each.
W2 / Q2. Sensitivity to voxel centroids (Table 15). A centroid stays inside its coarse cell, so the stock index does not change. Relabelled, its fine index is what matters, and the centroid is pulled towards the middle of the coarse cell: it loses where the points were. The fix is to keep the centroid as the token but read the index on one of the cell's points, which recovers the score of the random-point voxelizer (Section 3.2, Appendix D.1). Appendix D.1 now counts this without a model, at 3τ: on ScanNet the centroid's fine index differs from the kept point's in three cells out of four, and a quarter of the centroids fall in the middle fine cell, against 3 % of the kept points. Outdoors the centroid costs nothing, because two thirds of the coarse cells of a nuScenes sweep hold a single point, which is its own centroid. A centroid pipeline must therefore also keep one point per cell and read the index on it. Table 15 shows it in an added row, 61.76, from a later evaluation run in which the random point also gives 61.76.
W2 / Q3. Difference from scale normalisation. Section 3.3 now spells out the two scale fixes and why they fail (Figure R1). Scene shrinking divides the coordinates by k, as Utonia does in pretraining, but then the index is exactly the stock one, so the unit is not repaired. Index rescaling multiplies the stock index by k: the step length is right, but every token sits on a multiple of k, so neighbours end up k cells apart. Relabelling gets both right. Measured, index rescaling stays 17 to 37 mIoU points below relabelling at 3τ on all six pairs, and scene shrinking scores within 0.17 mIoU point of stock on the three ScanNet backbones (Section 4.5, Table 16). The released Utonia model behaves the same way: dividing its input scale by k does not help, while relabelling recovers most of its drop (Table 4).