acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Backup Before You Regret: Measuring Backup Awareness and Automating Backup in Coding Agents

Abstract

Coding agents now complete tasks autonomously, modifying real-world state such as artifacts, software environments, and configurations along the way. Yet they show limited backup awareness: recognizing that an action will modify state that may later be needed, and preserving it beforehand. To evaluate backup awareness, we introduce RegretBench: 205 executable tasks grounded in regret moments reported on platforms such as X.com, GitHub, and Stack Overflow, where users regretted not preserving state they later needed. Across six frontier models, agents complete 86.1% of tasks on average yet back up before these moments in only 15.2%, showing that task completion does not imply backup awareness. Because it is hard to predict which changes will be regretted, we propose BackUpper, a harness plug-in backup layer that checks every tool call and preserves affected state before modification. It combines rule-based strategies for common destructive operations with a lightweight subagent for complex cases. BackUpper's restored state reaches 92.2% average similarity to the original, and every regret-moment action is covered. Achieving this costs only $0.014 per task, with 7× fewer tokens than main-agent self-backup. When users state backup preferences, BackUpper narrows the backup scope and achieves 84.5% F1. It can also add new rule-based strategies through self-improvement to reduce subagent calls over time. These results show that agents can keep actions reversible at low cost while respecting users' preferences.

Primary area:
alignment, fairness, safety, privacy, and societal considerations
Keywords:
Reversibility, Backup Awareness, Coding Agents, Agent Harness, Preference-Aware Backup, Self-Reflection

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 17%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.75 over 4 reviews, above 83% of the others.
Reviewer_fYECOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces RegretBench, 205 executable tasks testing whether coding agents preserve state before modifications that users may later regret. Across six models, task completion substantially exceeds backup coverage. The proposed BackUpper intercepts tool calls and combines command rewriting, backup commands, snapshots, and a lightweight subagent informed by tool-specific backup experiences. It reports 100% judge-assessed backup coverage and 92.2% character-level similarity after restoration, alongside efficiency and personalization results.

Critical strengths

The benchmark addresses a meaningful gap in agent evaluation. Successful task execution can still destroy state that users subsequently need. Grounding tasks in documented losses and covering five tool categories makes this a useful evaluation target. Its focus on preservation before modification complements BackBench’s evaluation of recovery from already-harmful states.

The system is practical and the evaluation is reasonably broad. The study includes six models, a crossed model/harness comparison, human validation of 700 actions, executed restoration tests, and evaluation on external tasks. Separating backup execution from the main agent is sensible, and the reported improvements in coverage and backup overhead suggest practical value.

Critical weaknesses

Backup coverage and successful recovery remain insufficiently distinguished. The 100% coverage result is based on an LLM judge; humans confirm 188/200 sampled BackUpper-positive cases. The actual restoration experiment is valuable, but character-level similarity between serialized states does not establish whether each documented recovery need is satisfied. Differences involving object IDs or SQL sequence values can affect references or subsequent operations, even when most content is recovered. The acknowledged restoration limitations should therefore be reflected more carefully in the paper’s reversibility claims.

The source and novelty of the improvement need sharper isolation. Removing tool-specific experiences reduces BackUpper’s backup rate to 77.6%, below Skill-Based prompting at 81.4%. It is unclear whether Skill-Based receives the same experiences, leaving uncertainty about the contribution of the architecture versus additional recovery knowledge. The positioning should also address proactive systems more directly: YoloFS preserves filesystem state through staging and snapshots, while Cordon mediates local mutations and stages external effects before commit. BackUpper’s contribution should be distinguished through its lightweight backup mechanism and heterogeneous tool coverage.

Questions for authors

From the existing restoration runs, can you distinguish tasks where the documented recovery need is fully satisfied from those with incomplete recovery? How many human--judge disagreements concern harmless metadata rather than necessary state?

Does Skill-Based receive the same tool-specific backup experiences as BackUpper? Please clarify its prompt and available recovery information.

What are the task pass rates with BackUpper on the existing 205-task RegretBench runs? The reported no-degradation comparison currently covers 40 external tasks.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer fYEC

We thank Reviewer fYEC for the thoughtful review and for recognizing the practical value of our benchmark and BackUpper.

W1/Q1: Judge-Based Evaluation

We will revise the claim to "100% judge-assessed coverage" and distinguish coverage from recovery as follows.

Coverage. To quantify the human–judge disagreements, we expanded the human evaluation to 300 judge-positive BackUpper actions. Annotators agree with the judge on 95.0% (285/300), and all 15 disagreements concern only additional metadata, such as read/unread flags, rather than necessary state (General Response W3). We then re-read all 205 regret-moment reports and found that no documented recovery need involves such metadata.

Recovery. To test directly whether each documented recovery need is satisfied, we constructed 468 functional tests on the 60-task subset, with at least one test per need (General Response W2). Restoring from BackUpper's backups passes 94.7% of the tests. None of the failures is caused by missing metadata: all come from state that the service itself cannot reproduce, such as a shared link that changes once a document is re-uploaded.

Together, these results demonstrate the quality of BackUpper's backups: the disagreements in coverage concern only metadata that no recovery need involves, and the failures in functional recovery come only from state that the service itself cannot reproduce.

W2/Q2: Skill-Based with Tool Experiences and Missing Related Work

In our main experiment, the Skill-Based prompt only instructs the main agent to back up every out-of-workspace action before executing it. To compare under equivalent information, we additionally give Skill-Based the same experiences as BackUpper's subagent and run it on Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol over the 60-task subset:

MetricSkill-Based + ExpBackUpper
RMBR (%)95.8100.0
OWBR (%)94.0100.0
Functional pass rate (%)91.594.7
Cost ($)0.4610.021

The experiences raise Skill-Based from 90.0% to 95.8% RMBR. Yet with equivalent information, BackUpper still achieves higher coverage (+4.2 RMBR, +6.0 OWBR) and a higher functional pass rate (94.7% vs. 91.5%), at 22× lower cost. BackUpper’s advantage therefore also comes from its architecture: each backup subagent applies the experiences in a fresh context rather than amid the main agent’s long task context. Experiment details can be found in General Response W1 and W2.

Related work. We thank the reviewer for pointing us to YoloFS [1] and Cordon [2], and we will discuss both in the related work. Both methods hold an agent's action until a check at commit time: YoloFS stages filesystem mutations for user review, and Cordon stages local mutations and external effects for policy validation. Such checks catch problems that are recognizable at that moment. However, regret moments are different: the user often requested the action or would approve it at commit time, and the regret comes only later when they still need something back. BackUpper therefore does not rely on a check at commit time. It lets the action run and preserves the affected state beforehand, so the state remains recoverable afterwards. BackUpper is also lightweight, requiring no kernel module or transactional runtime, and it covers state beyond the filesystem, such as cloud documents and databases. We see the approaches as complementary: YoloFS and Cordon block actions that should not happen, while BackUpper keeps the actions that do happen recoverable.

Q3: Task Pass Rate with BackUpper

We evaluate the pass rate on all 205 RegretBench tasks with and without BackUpper:

Opus-5Sonnet-5GPT 5.6-SolGPT 5.6-TerraDeepSeek V4-ProGemini 3.7-FlashAvg
w/o BackUpper92.282.090.785.981.584.486.1
w/ BackUpper92.280.092.787.881.582.086.0

The average pass rate is 86.0% with BackUpper and 86.1% without it, with small per-model differences in both directions. We manually inspected every task whose outcome changed and found none caused by BackUpper. This further confirms that BackUpper improves recoverability without degrading task performance. Experiment details can be found in General Response W4.

[1] Don’t Let AI Agents YOLO Your Files: Shifting Information and Control to Filesystems for Agent Safety and Autonomy, arXiv, 2026

[2] Cordon: Semantic Transactions for Tool-Using LLM Agents, arXiv, 2026

Dear Reviewer fYEC,

Thank you again for your detailed review. We have responded to each of your concerns above, including functional recovery tests, the comparison with Skill-Based under the same experiences, and a discussion of YoloFS and Cordon. As the discussion period is coming to an end, we would like to check whether anything remains unclear that we can address. If your concerns have been addressed, we would appreciate it if you could consider updating your assessment.

Thank you for your time.

I appreciate the time spent by the authors in preparing the rebuttal and addressing the concerns raised. I do not have further questions, my issues have been resolved. I will retain my original positive score of 3 for this work.

Thanks

Thank you for the follow-up and for your positive assessment. We will include all the additional experiments and clarifications in the next version of our manuscript.

Reviewer_B7gVOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary
  • The paper introduces RegretBench, 205 coding-agent tasks built from real online reports in which people lost data and wished they had made a backup
  • It aims to measure whether agents back up state outside their working folder, such as installed packages, databases, emails or cluster setups, before changing it
  • Six frontier models complete 86% of the tasks on average but back up before the risky step only 15% of the time, with Claude Opus-5 at 64% and the other five models at 11% or lower
  • A plugin called BackUpper is also proposed, which checks every tool call and saves the affected state before the call runs, using fixed rules for common commands and a helper model for everything else
  • Instead of predicting which changes will be regretted, BackUpper backs up every call that is not read-only, so its 100% coverage reflects this design rather than any awareness
Critical strengths
  • The benchmark is grounded in real incidents. The authors start from 557 reports, keep 205, and run the tasks against real systems: a PostgreSQL database, web apps such as GitLab and Reddit clones, an email server and a Kubernetes cluster
  • Backup behavior turns out to depend on the model rather than the harness. Opus-5 backs up in 68-73% of tasks in all three harnesses, GPT 5.6-Sol in only 5-8% and DeepSeek in no more than 2%. Overall, around 72% of runs finish the task without backing anything up
  • The authors actually restore from the backups rather than only checking that a backup exists, and the restored state is 92.2% similar to the original, against 14% without restoring
  • The baselines are informative. Simply instructing the main agent to back up reaches 81%, while a filter for destructive commands reaches only 8%, which suggests that regret often follows ordinary actions. A failure analysis shows that most failed attempts start a backup but save too little, such as an email export without the attachment contents
  • BackUpper is cheap, costing less than two cents per task against 34 cents for the instructed-agent approach, which also uses many more tokens
Critical weaknesses
  1. RegretBench contains only actions that should be backed up, so it cannot distinguish careful agents from agents that back up everything. Unnecessary backups, storage and delays are never penalized. BackUpper's 100% follows directly from treating "every state-modifying one as worth backing up by default" (§1). Every task also has the user explicitly ask for the risky action, and the paper gives no evidence of how often users want a backup before something they asked for

  2. The paper claims that "every regret-moment action is covered", but human annotators confirm only 188 of the 200 BackUpper backups that the judge accepted (Table 5). The paper explains the gap as "minor metadata", yet the judge's own rubric requires enough to "rebuild prior state without access to the original" and has no metadata exception, which seems inconsistent

  3. The restoration result measures character similarity between text exports, not whether recovery actually works. Terminal tasks already score 37.2% without any restoration. The paper never checks, for example, whether the tests that broke after the ipykernel upgrade pass again after restoring, and restoration is not measured for the baselines

  4. The comparison does not separate BackUpper's design from its extra knowledge. Without the tool experiences generated in advance by Claude Opus-5, BackUpper scores 77.6%, below the simple instructed agent at 81.4%. No baseline gives the main agent the same experiences. The experiences come from exploring each tool, and these are the benchmark's own five tools, so they may effectively be tuned to this particular test environment

  5. The results suggest that the gap is mostly about default behavior rather than awareness. Instructions alone raise backups to 81%, and with BackUpper's tagging instruction the main agent itself flags about 79% of the risky actions, since the checker catches only about 21% (App. D.4). This weakens the conclusion that improvement "requires either training the model or adding support outside the model"

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors add tasks where a backup is unnecessary or unwanted, such as deleting a temporary file the agent just created or a credential the user wants gone? Reporting how often agents and BackUpper back up anyway would show whether the benchmark measures awareness or just a back-up-everything habit

  2. How does the instructed-agent baseline perform when the main agent gets the same Opus-5 experiences as BackUpper's helper model? Running this on the 60-task subset with one or two models would separate the value of the plugin design from the value of the extra knowledge

  3. Were the experiences generated on the same database, mailbox, cluster and web-app instances used in RegretBench, and if so, how does BackUpper do with experiences from a different instance?

  4. Could a functional check be added on a sample of tasks, such as rerunning the tests that broke after restoring the old package version? This would show whether 92% similarity means the user actually gets their state back in full

  5. Why does the destructive-command filter score 8.1%, below the agents on their own at 15.2%, if it only adds backups on top of the agent's own behavior? It would help to know whether the agent's own backing up is switched off in that setup

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer B7gV (1/3)

We thank Reviewer B7gV for the detailed review and for recognizing our real-world benchmark and restoration-based evaluation.

W1/Q1: Measuring Awareness and Unnecessary Backups

The two metrics in our paper measure agents’ backup awareness. OWBR (Out-of-Workspace Backup Rate) measures how broadly an agent backs up its out-of-workspace modifications, while RMBR (Regret Moment Backup Rate) measures whether its backups cover the documented regret moments. An agent with strong awareness of what users may later need would thus show higher RMBR than OWBR. Among the models we evaluated, only Claude Opus-5 shows this pattern and has the highest RMBR (64.4%), yet it still misses 35.6% of regret moments. Such misses are difficult to avoid, as regret is hard to predict before the action. Every task in RegretBench comes from a real-world report where a user regretted losing state without a backup. If users had known in advance what they would need, they would have backed it up and the regret would not have happened. Therefore, BackUpper backs up every state-modifying action by default, so that no regret moment is missed.

Whether a backup is unwanted depends on the user, so we treat it as personalization (Table 8; main paper). There is no single correct answer to what should be backed up: the same backup can be essential for one user and unnecessary for another. BackUpper therefore backs up broadly by default and narrows its scope once the user’s preference is known, reducing unnecessary backups while still covering what that user needs. To measure this, we label each action in the trajectory as necessary or unnecessary to back up under a given user preference. From these labels, we compute F1 to penalize backing up everything. Both of the examples are covered by the modes: Human-Work skips files the agent itself created, and Beyond-Request skips actions the user explicitly requested, for example when the user asks to remove a credential. Our results show that BackUpper reaches 84.5% average F1, suggesting that it can adapt to various user preferences. We also report its overhead (Table 2a, Figure 9b; main paper): BackUpper costs 25× less than main-agent backup and uses 64% less storage than copying the affected files directly. Looking ahead, agents could learn each user’s preferences from history and become personalized, backing up what that user is likely to need while skipping the rest. We will include this discussion as future work in the paper.

W2: Judge-Based Evaluation

To better reflect our evaluation, we will revise the claim to “100% judge-assessed coverage.”

Evaluators differ in how strictly they treat metadata. We re-judged every run of all six agents with GLM 5.3-Flash (General Response W3). Under this judge, BackUpper reaches 98.9% RMBR and 98.3% OWBR. We also expanded the human evaluation to 300 judge-positive BackUpper actions, where annotators disagree with the judge on 15. In both cases, every disagreement concerns only additional metadata, such as read/unread flags. On the 15 actions that annotators reject, the three evaluators give three different verdicts: annotators reject all of them, GLM rejects 5, and Sonnet-5 rejects none. These disagreements therefore come from how strictly each evaluator reads the rubric, not from missing content.

This metadata does not affect documented recovery needs. We re-read all 205 regret-moment reports and found that no documented recovery need involves such metadata. For example, GLM rejected one BackUpper backup because the export captured the message contents but not their read/unread state, whereas the user in the original report [1] regretted only losing the emails themselves. Our functional tests confirm this: restoring from BackUpper’s backups passes 94.7% of the tests, and all failures come from state that the service itself cannot reproduce (General Response W2).

These disagreements therefore do not affect the quality of BackUpper’s backups, which preserve what users actually need. We will add these results to the paper, together with a discussion of how evaluators treat additional metadata.

[1] https://superuser.com/questions/1704289/how-to-recover-old-emails-in-a-thunderbird-local-folder

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer B7gV (2/3)

W3/Q4: Functional Recovery

To verify that the restored state also recovers its original function, we constructed 468 tests on the 60-task subset (General Response W2). Each documented recovery requirement is covered by at least one test. For example, when a user regrets upgrading a package that broke their code, the tests check whether the code runs again after restoration. As a sanity check, all tests pass before the regret-moment action, while only 5.8% pass after it without restoration. We evaluate four methods with the same tests. Restoring from BackUpper's backups passes 94.7% of tests, the highest among all methods:

BaselineSkill-BasedSkill-Based + ExpBackUpper
Functional test pass rate25.6%78.0%91.5%94.7%

All of BackUpper’s failures come from state that the service itself cannot reproduce, such as a share link that changes even when the same file is re-uploaded. Experiment details can be found in General Response W2.

These results show that restoring from BackUpper’s backups recovers the functionality users actually need, further confirming the quality of its backups.

W4/Q2: Skill-Based with Tool Experiences

We gave Skill-Based the same Opus-generated experiences as BackUpper's subagent and ran it on Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol over the 60-task subset:

MetricSkill-Based + ExpBackUpper
RMBR (%)95.8100.0
OWBR (%)94.0100.0
Tokens (1K)42486
Cost ($)0.4610.021
Latency (s)41.322.6

The experiences raise Skill-Based from 90.0% to 95.8% RMBR. Yet BackUpper still achieves higher coverage (+4.2 RMBR, +6.0 OWBR) and a higher functional pass rate (94.7% vs. 91.5%), while using 4.9× fewer tokens and costing 22× less. BackUpper’s advantage therefore does not come from the extra knowledge alone, but also from its design: each backup subagent starts with a fresh context instead of competing with the main agent’s long task context, so it can use the experiences more effectively. Experiment details can be found in General Response W1.

This also explains why BackUpper without experiences scores below Skill-Based (77.6% vs. 81.4%). With no tool knowledge on either side, the outcome depends on model capability, and Skill-Based backs up with the main agent, a much stronger model than BackUpper’s lightweight subagent.

Q3: Independence of Tool Experiences

The experiences are generated from tool documentation, without access to any RegretBench task. Following the ToolShield pipeline [2], the agent generates its own test cases and seed data, then executes them in a sandbox. To ensure that the generated tasks do not resemble RegretBench, we compare the 32 tasks used for experience generation with the 65 RegretBench Terminal tasks. As baselines, we randomly sample 32 tasks five times from each of two external benchmarks:

Task SetMean SimilarityMax Similarity
Ours (experience generation)0.1110.342
Terminal-Bench 40.144 ± 0.0080.460 ± 0.023
DeepSWE0.122 ± 0.0080.455 ± 0.011

Our generation tasks are less similar to RegretBench than unrelated external benchmarks on both metrics. Moreover, BackUpper with the same experiences reaches 100% OWBR on external Terminal-Bench 4 and DeepSWE tasks (Table 2b). These results show that the experiences used by BackUpper are generated independently of RegretBench and generalize beyond it.

Q5: Baseline + DCG

The 8.1% reports DCG’s coverage in isolation. We consider only the actions flagged by DCG and check whether the backups triggered for them are sufficient. Counting both the agent’s own backups and DCG-triggered backups in the same runs yields:

Baseline onlyDCG onlyBaseline + DCG
RMBR (%)15.28.118.7
OWBR (%)17.47.320.8

Even combined, Baseline + DCG reaches only 18.7% RMBR, far below Skill-Based (81.4%) and BackUpper w/o Experience (77.6%), so the ranking in our paper is unaffected. These results support two observations. First, DCG adds 3.5 points of RMBR and 3.4 points of OWBR over the baseline, which shows that agents sometimes skip backups even before explicitly destructive commands. Second, with these commands guarded, more than 80% of regret moments remain uncovered, which further demonstrates that regret extends beyond destructive actions.

[2] Unsafer in Many Turns: Benchmarking and Defending Multi-Turn Safety Risks in Tool-Using Agents. ICML, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer B7gV (3/3)

W5: Default Behavior versus Awareness

We agree that the gap mainly reflects agents' default behavior. This is what we mean by "backup awareness," and we will clarify it in the paper. This reading is consistent with our conclusion. The backup skill and BackUpper's tagging instruction are both support added outside the model. Without such support, agents back up before only 15.2% of regret moments. However, instructions alone are not sufficient. With the backup instruction, Skill-Based reaches 81.4% RMBR. Even with the same tool experiences as BackUpper, it reaches only 95.8% on Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol (W4/Q2). BackUpper, in contrast, achieves higher coverage at 22× lower cost, which makes it a more effective and practical form of such support. We will revise the conclusion to state this more precisely.

Reviewer_93YLOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies whether coding agents preserve sufficient recovery information before modifying state, a behavior termed backup awareness. RegretBench contains 205 executable, multi-turn tasks grounded in public reports of state loss and subsequent regret, covering Terminal, SQL, Browser, Email, and DevOps tools. The affected state is placed outside native harness backup coverage, and harness protection is standardized to workspace snapshots to evaluate agents' own backup behavior.

Across six models, the average task pass rate is 86.1%, while the regret-moment backup rate (RMBR) is 15.2%. The proposed BackUpper intercepts tool calls and preserves recovery information through command rewriting, paired backup commands, snapshots, and a backup subagent. The complete system achieves 100% coverage according to the LLM backup judge, with an average character-level similarity of 92.2% between original and restored affected state. Additional experiments examine cost, preference-based scope control, tool experience, rule self-improvement, and external tasks.

Critical strengths

1. The distinction between task completion and recovery preparedness is practically meaningful

Satisfying an immediate request does not guarantee that the user can later recover the previous state. Environments, databases, and remote services may fall outside workspace version control. The paper translates this gap into executable tasks and explicit evaluation criteria. Git does not eliminate the problem, and a useful benchmark or system contribution need not introduce a new low-level backup algorithm.

2. The benchmark and backup system form a coherent empirical study

The tasks are grounded in public cases and manually checked rather than derived solely from hypothetical risks. They cover several tools and modifications beyond local source files. Moving backup responsibility from discretionary main-agent behavior to a dedicated pre-execution mechanism has a clear engineering rationale.

3. Restoration experiments and ablations provide substantive evidence

The evaluation goes beyond checking whether backup files exist: it executes recovery and compares only the affected objects. Similarity rises from 14.3% without restoration to 92.2% after restoration, showing substantial preservation of otherwise lost content (Appendix D.5, Table 6). Human checks on 700 actions strengthen the automated evaluation. Removing tool experience reduces RMBR from 100% to 77.6%, indicating that backup failures involve not only omission but also insufficient knowledge of what recovery requires (Figure 8).

Critical weaknesses

1. The framing does not clearly distinguish backup policy from model capability

Low default RMBR establishes limited spontaneous backup behavior, not inability to back up: explicit Skill-Based instructions raise RMBR to 81.4%. Backup decisions also depend on user requirements, costs, and existing protection. BackUpper largely bypasses anticipation of future regret by backing up non-read-only operations. The evidence therefore supports an execution-layer protection policy more directly than broader claims about deficient model capability or its training origins.

2. The benchmark provides limited diagnosis of recovery failures and their bottlenecks

RMBR summarizes judge-assessed backup coverage, while the restoration experiment reports character-level similarity rather than satisfaction of each case's documented recovery need. These scores do not directly distinguish failures to initiate backup, identify affected state, preserve essential content, or execute restoration. Appendix D.6 usefully categorizes Skill-Based failures, but does not establish a comparable diagnosis across default agents and BackUpper. Need-specific recovery checks and a shared failure taxonomy would make the benchmark more informative about what actually limits recovery and whether the proposed intervention addresses that bottleneck. The restoration protocol should also specify who executes recovery and what additional information or adaptation is allowed.

3. The method's protection boundary and source of improvement remain unclear

Algorithm 1 executes a call after its first matching backup tier, leaving unclear how calls with both workspace and external effects are fully protected, or whether backup failure blocks execution. Separately, removing tool experience reduces BackUpper's RMBR from 100% to 77.6%, compared with Skill-Based's 81.4%, yet equivalent knowledge for Skill-Based is not established. The results therefore need both tests of compound-call protection and an information-matched comparison to distinguish architectural gains from additional tool knowledge. These are unresolved specification and comparison issues, not demonstrated implementation failures or evidence of leakage.

Questions for authors
  1. Backup behavior versus capability. Given that explicit Skill-Based instructions raise RMBR to 81.4%, what evidence distinguishes a backup-capability limitation from differences in default policy or tool knowledge?

  2. Benchmark diagnosis. Building on Appendix D.6, can you compare failure causes across default agents, Skill-Based, and BackUpper—backup omission, incomplete side-effect identification, insufficient capture, and restoration failure? Which bottlenecks dominate, and does BackUpper resolve them when evaluated against each case's documented recovery need?

  3. Protection boundaries. How does Algorithm 1 handle compound calls that modify both workspace and external state? What ensures that the first matching tier protects all effects, and does backup failure block the original operation?

  4. Baseline comparability. Does Skill-Based receive the same tool experience as BackUpper? With equivalent knowledge, how much improvement remains attributable to the tiered architecture?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 93YL (1/2)

We thank Reviewer 93YL for the thoughtful review and for recognizing the practical value of our benchmark and backup system.

W1/Q1: Backup Behavior versus Capability

By “limited backup awareness,” we refer to agents’ default backup behavior rather than their capability. We agree that the low RMBR reflects what agents do without being prompted, not an inability to back up. Our Skill-Based experiment separates default policy from capability: when instructed to back up every out-of-workspace action, RMBR rises to 81.4% and OWBR rises to 80.5%. Tool knowledge accounts for part of the remaining gap. On Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol, we give Skill-Based the same tool experiences as BackUpper's subagent:

MethodRMBR (%)OWBR (%)
Skill-Based90.087.5
Skill-Based + Exp95.894.0
BackUpper100.0100.0

The experiences raise Skill-Based's RMBR from 90.0% to 95.8%. The remaining 4.2 points are mostly insufficient backups, likely because the experiences get lost in the main agent's long context (full results in General Response W1). Default policy also varies across models of similar capability: Claude Opus-5 reaches 64.4% RMBR, while GPT 5.6-Sol, with a similar Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index score, reaches only 5.9%. This shows that default backup behavior does not emerge from general capability alone, and we hypothesize that it is acquired through additional alignment training.

We therefore agree that BackUpper is best understood as an execution-layer protection mechanism. Because default policy varies across models and regret is hard to predict, BackUpper enforces backup in the harness instead of relying on the model. This also makes backup much cheaper than instructing the main agent: with the same experiences, BackUpper uses 4.9× fewer tokens, costs 22× less, and reduces latency by 45% compared with Skill-Based, while achieving higher coverage (General Response W1). We will revise the paper to clarify that backup awareness refers to default behavior and to mark the training account explicitly as a hypothesis.

W2/Q2: Benchmark Diagnosis

We construct 468 functional tests on the 60-task subset, with at least one test for each documented recovery requirement. We classify each failed test into one of four categories: backup omission, incomplete side-effect identification, insufficient capture, and non-restorable state. This refines the “insufficient backup” category of Appendix D.6 into the second and third categories. Experiment details can be found in General Response W2.

CategoryBaselineSkill-BasedSkill-Based + ExpBackUpper
Pass25.6%78.0%91.5%94.7%
Backup omission50.9%2.1%0.6%0.0%
Incomplete side-effect identification13.2%10.7%4.1%0.0%
Insufficient capture7.1%5.6%0.0%0.0%
Non-restorable state3.2%3.6%3.8%5.3%

Incomplete side-effect identification dominates among backed-up actions. For Baseline, the dominant failure is backup omission (50.9%). Among backed-up actions, the dominant failure for both Baseline and Skill-Based is incomplete side-effect identification (56% and 54% of their failures). For example, before running DELETE FROM idx.term, an agent backed up the two tables it expected to cascade, but missed a second-level ON DELETE CASCADE that also deleted 1,683 indexing notes. Adding tool experiences to Skill-Based reduces this failure from 10.7% to 4.1%, suggesting that the bottleneck lies in knowledge of the tools’ transitive effects.

BackUpper resolves the bottleneck. BackUpper achieves the highest pass rate of 94.7% and eliminates the backup-stage failures. It checks every tool call, so no backup is omitted, and each subagent starts with a fresh context, which avoids the long-context loss discussed in W1/Q1. Its remaining failures are all non-restorable states, such as a regenerated share link. This demonstrates that BackUpper both supplies the tool knowledge agents lack and applies it reliably.

Restoration protocol. BackUpper is restored by executing the recovery commands in its backup log, with GPT 5.6-Luna as the subagent (Sec. 5.1). The backups of Baseline, Skill-Based, and Skill-Based with experiences record no recovery commands, so the same subagent restores them directly from the backed-up content. We will add the protocol and this analysis to the appendix.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 93YL (2/2)

W3/Q3: Protection Boundaries

Compound calls. BackUpper splits a compound call into simple commands and applies tier selection to each one separately. For example, in rm data.csv && curl -X DELETE <api>/records, the two commands are handled separately, so both the workspace effect and the external effect are backed up before the call executes.

First-match coverage. A rule-based tier contains only commands whose effects we have fully characterized, so its strategy covers every effect of a command it matches. Any command outside these rules is passed to the backup subagent, which decides what to back up for that command.

Backup failure. A backup failure does not block the original call, because BackUpper's core design principle is not to interfere with task execution. The failure is recorded in the backup log, so users can see which actions were not protected.

We will revise Algorithm 1 to better reflect the workflow of BackUpper:

b ← HASBACKUPTAG(a)
for each simple command s ∈ SPLIT(a) do
    ⋮  (read-only and preference checks, unchanged)
    try
        ⋮  (Tiers 1–4 applied to s, first match, unchanged)
    catch failure
        LOG(s, failure)
end for
return EXECUTE(a)

Procedure SPLIT(a):
    split a shell command into simple commands at separators such as &&, ||, ;, |, and newlines;
    a non-shell call is returned as a single command

Q4: Baseline Comparability

To further verify the contribution of the architecture, we give Skill-Based the same experiences as BackUpper’s subagent and compare the two on Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol over the 60-task subset :

MetricSkill-Based + ExpBackUpper
RMBR (%)95.8100.0
OWBR (%)94.0100.0
Functional pass rate (%)91.594.7
Tokens (1K)42486
Cost ($)0.4610.021
Latency (s)41.322.6

With equivalent knowledge, BackUpper still achieves higher coverage (+4.2 RMBR, +6.0 OWBR) and a higher functional pass rate (94.7% vs. 91.5%). The remaining failures of Skill-Based with experiences are likely caused by the experiences getting lost in the main agent’s long context. BackUpper’s tiered design avoids this problem: each backup subagent starts with a fresh context, and the rule-based tiers do not rely on any agent. The architecture also brings substantially lower overhead. Skill-Based with experiences consumes and extends the main agent’s context, so its cost grows with the main model’s price and context length (Sec. 4). BackUpper instead offloads backup to a lightweight subagent and handles common operations with rule-based tiers, using 4.9× fewer tokens, costing 22× less, and reducing latency by 45%. Experiment details can be found in General Response W1 and W2.

These results show that BackUpper’s tiered architecture contributes to both its higher coverage and its lower overhead, beyond the tool knowledge itself.

Dear Reviewer 93YL,

Thank you again for your detailed review. We have responded to each of your concerns above, including a failure diagnosis across methods, the revised Algorithm 1, and an information-matched comparison with Skill-Based. As the discussion period is coming to an end, we would like to check whether anything remains unclear that we can address. If your concerns have been addressed, we would appreciate it if you could consider updating your assessment.

Thank you for your time.

Reviewer_yn6jOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether coding agents back up the state they modify before acting. It introduces RegretBench, 205 executable multi-turn tasks built from publicly reported "regret moments" across five tool types. Over six frontier models across three harnesses, agents pass 86.1% of tasks but back up the relevant state in only 15.2% of tasks. The authors then propose BackUpper, a training-free pre-tool-call hook that rewrites commands, takes snapshots, or calls a backup subagent. They report that it backs up every regret-moment action, restores state to 92.2% similarity at $0.014 per task, and maintains pass rates.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper targets a concrete and rarely measured gap, whether agents preserve state outside the workspace before changing it, and shows that none of five mainstream harnesses backs up external state.
  2. The central finding is clear and well supported. Agents complete 86.1% of tasks but back up only 15.2%, the gap depends on the model rather than the harness, and breakdowns reconcile exactly.
  3. BackUpper is training-free and harness-agnostic. It reaches 100% RMBR and OWBR on all six models at $0.014 per task and is compared with three baselines, several ablations and external tasks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Evaluated model families appear througout the pipeline, assembling tasks, judging and generating backup experiences. Possible bias toward them is not analyzed, and human validation is not broken down by model.
  2. The claim that every regret-moment action is covered relies on the LLM judge, yet human annotators confirmed only 188 of the 200 sampled positives, wich is 94.0%.
  3. Restoration fidelity is measured by character-level similarity between serialized snapshots. This does not test functional recovery, for example whether the restored environment or service actually works again.
  4. The no-degradation claim rests on only 40 external tasks, and the RegretBench pass rate with BackUpper is missing. Side effects of Full mode, like keeping data users meant to delete, are unmeasured.
  5. Reproducibility is limited. Only 20 of the 205 tasks are released, the checker and personalization prompts are missing, one figure is duplicated, and two rule-based coverage numbers, 14.9% and 30.8%, disagree.
  6. Minor typo: "why agents backup or not" should be "why agents back up or not".
Questions for authors
  1. How do RMBR and OWBR change when a subset is re-scored by a judge outside the evaluated model families, and when Claude Opus-5 is excluded from task assembly and backup-experience generation?
  2. What is the RegretBench pass rate with BackUpper enabled? How often does Full mode trigger unnecessary backups or change task behavior, for example when rm is rewritten into mv?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer yn6j (1/2)

We thank Reviewer yn6j for recognizing the concrete gap we target and the clarity of our central finding.

W1/Q1: Cross-Family Judge and Experience Generation

Judge. To avoid model-family bias, we re-judged all runs of the six agents with GLM 5.3-Flash (General Response W3). BackUpper still achieves the highest score among methods under this judge, reaching 98.9% RMBR and 98.3% OWBR, while Skill-Based achieves only 78.6% RMBR and 78.4% OWBR. Compared with the original judge, BackUpper changes by −1.1 and −1.7 points, Skill-Based by −2.8 and −2.1, and Baseline by +0.6 and −1.1. We manually checked every BackUpper action that GLM 5.3-Flash judged as not backed up and found that all of them involve only additional metadata, such as read/unread flags. This suggests that the two judges may differ in how strictly they treat such metadata. Since BackUpper remains the best method under both judges, our conclusions are not affected by potential model-family bias.

Experience generation. We regenerated the tool experiences with GLM 5.3-Flash and reran both BackUpper and Skill-Based on Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol over the 60-task subset:

MethodExperience sourceRMBR (%)OWBR (%)
Skill-BasedOpus-595.894.0
Skill-BasedGLM 5.3-Flash93.392.5
BackUpperOpus-5100.0100.0
BackUpperGLM 5.3-Flash96.797.3

Both methods drop slightly. We attribute this to stronger models exploring tools more comprehensively and producing higher-quality experiences, as also observed in ToolShield [1]. Even with GLM-generated experiences, BackUpper (96.7%) still outperforms Skill-Based with Opus-generated experiences (95.8%), showing that our method generalizes beyond a particular experience generator.

W2: Judge-Based Evaluation

We will revise the claim to “100% judge-assessed coverage.” To quantify the gap between the judge and human annotators, we expanded the human evaluation to 300 judge-positive BackUpper actions. Annotators agree with the LLM judge on 95.0% (285/300) of these actions, and agreement is similar across methods:

MethodHuman agreement on judge-positive actions
BackUpper95.0% (285/300)
Skill-Based94.3% (283/300)
Baseline92.0% (138/150)

We examined the 15 disagreements on BackUpper and found that every one involves only additional metadata, such as read/unread flags. This metadata does not affect documented recovery needs. No documented recovery need among the 205 regret-moment reports involves it, and our functional tests confirm that restoring from BackUpper's backups recovers the original functionality (see W3 below). The gap therefore comes only from additional metadata, while BackUpper's backups preserve the state users need. Experiment details and full results can be found in General Response W3.

W3: Functional Recovery

To test whether the restored environment or service actually works again, we constructed 468 functional tests on the 60-task subset, with at least one test for each recovery requirement documented in a task’s regret moment. Restoring from BackUpper's backups passes 94.7% of tests, the highest among all methods:

BaselineSkill-BasedSkill-Based + ExpBackUpper
Functional test pass rate25.6%78.0%91.5%94.7%

All of BackUpper’s failures come from state that the service itself cannot reproduce, such as regenerated identifiers, as discussed in Sec. 5.2. This demonstrates that BackUpper’s backups cover the functionality users need, further confirming their quality. Experiment details and full results can be found in General Response W2.

[1] Unsafer in Many Turns: Benchmarking and Defending Multi-Turn Safety Risks in Tool-Using Agents. ICML, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer yn6j (2/2)

W4/Q2: Task Performance and Full-Mode Side Effects

Task performance. We compare the pass rate on all 205 RegretBench tasks with and without BackUpper:

Opus-5Sonnet-5GPT 5.6-SolGPT 5.6-TerraDeepSeek V4-ProGemini 3.7-FlashAvg
w/o BackUpper92.282.090.785.981.584.486.1
w/ BackUpper92.280.092.787.881.582.086.0

Enabling BackUpper changes the average pass rate by only −0.1 points, with differences in both directions. We manually inspected every task whose outcome changed and found none affected by BackUpper. This is expected from its design. Tiers 2–4 only add backup operations before the original call runs. Tier 1 rewrites a command only into an alternative with the same effect: for example, rm x becomes mv x .trash/, which removes x from its original location and keeps a copy outside the workspace only for recovery. Experiment details and full results can be found in General Response W4.

Full-mode side effects. Full mode’s side effects are limited in two ways. First, the overhead is low (Table 2a, Figure 9b; main paper): BackUpper costs 25× less than main-agent backup and uses 64% less storage than copying the affected files directly. Second, users can control what is kept by configuring backups to be released after a given number of steps. They can also use the personalization modes to narrow the scope. For example, Beyond-Request mode skips backups for actions the user explicitly requested, such as deleting a credential.

W5/W6: Reproducibility and Presentation

Released resources The attached code included only 20 tasks for demonstration due to the size limit of the environments’ seed data. We have put all 205 tasks, together with the read-only checker and personalization prompts, at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Back_up_before_you_regret_supp-5FB8/. We will also release the full benchmark and code publicly upon publication.

Rule-based coverage The two numbers come from different settings: 14.9% (Figure 9a; main paper) is for GPT 5.6-Sol alone, while 30.8% (Appendix D.2) is the average across six models. Since rule-based tiers match specific command patterns, their coverage depends on how each model tends to phrase its commands. This is also why we propose self-improvement: by distilling subagent backups into new rules, BackUpper adapts to a model’s own command habits, doubling rule-based coverage for GPT 5.6-Sol from 14.9% to 31.2% after 30 Terminal-Bench 4 tasks (Sec. 5.3; main paper). We will clarify this in the paper.

Presentation. We thank the reviewer for catching this. The duplicated figure was a mistake made when copying figures into the manuscript. We will replace the duplicated Figure 13 with the correct self-reflection pipeline figure, fix the typo, and proofread the manuscript again.

Dear Reviewer yn6j,

Thank you again for your detailed review. We have responded to each of your concerns above, including new functional recovery tests, a cross-family judge, and task pass rates on all 205 tasks. As the discussion period is coming to an end, we would like to check whether anything remains unclear that we can address. If your concerns have been addressed, we would appreciate it if you could consider updating your assessment.

Thank you for your time.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (1/2)

We thank all reviewers for their careful reading and constructive feedback. Several concerns were shared across reviews, and we address them together here: a comparison with Skill-Based under the same tool experiences (W1), functional recovery (W2), the reliability of judge-based evaluation (W3), and task performance with BackUpper (W4). Reviewer-specific questions are answered in the individual responses.

W1: Skill-Based with Tool Experiences

We ran the Skill-Based method on Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol on the 60-task subset with the same tool experiences that are injected into the BackUpper subagent.

MetricSkill-Based + ExpBackUpperΔ
RMBR (%)95.8100.0+4.2
OWBR (%)94.0100.0+6.0
Tokens (1K)42486−338
Cost ($)0.4610.021−0.440
Latency (s)41.322.6−18.7

With the same experiences, BackUpper still achieves a higher backup rate while using 4.9× fewer tokens, costing 22× less, and reducing latency by 45%. Comparing Skill-Based with and without experiences on these two agents, we find that experiences raise RMBR from 90.0% to 95.8% and OWBR from 87.5% to 94.0%. The majority of remaining failures are insufficient backups, likely because the experiences get lost in the main agent’s long context.

These results further demonstrate the benefit of BackUpper’s tiered design. The backup rate is higher because each backup subagent starts with a fresh context and keeps the experiences in focus. The cost is lower because the subagent does not consume the main agent’s long context, and the rule-based tiers handle common operations without LLM calls.

W2: Functional Recovery

To verify functional recovery, we constructed 468 functional test cases on the 60-task subset. Each recovery requirement documented in a task’s regret moment is covered by at least one test. For example, if a user regrets upgrading a package that broke their code, the tests will check if the code runs again after restoration. These tests were drafted with GLM 5.3-Flash to avoid bias and manually verified for validity. As a sanity check, all tests pass before the regret-moment action, while only 5.8% pass after it without restoration.

We run these tests under four backup methods. For BackUpper, we restore from its backups by executing the recovery commands recorded in its backup log (Sec. 5.1). The backups of Baseline, Skill-Based, and Skill-Based with experiences record no recovery commands, so a subagent performs the restoration from their backed-up content directly. We evaluate all four methods with Claude Opus-5 and GPT 5.6-Sol as the main agent, and use GPT 5.6-Luna as the subagent.

CategoryBaselineSkill-BasedSkill-Based + ExpBackUpper
Pass25.6%78.0%91.5%94.7%
Backup omission50.9%2.1%0.6%0.0%
Incomplete side-effect identification13.2%10.7%4.1%0.0%
Insufficient capture7.1%5.6%0.0%0.0%
Non-restorable state3.2%3.6%3.8%5.3%

As the table above shows, BackUpper achieves the highest pass rate of 94.7%, compared with 91.5% for Skill-Based with experiences, 78.0% for Skill-Based, and 25.6% for Baseline. To understand where the remaining tests fail, we classify each failure into one of four categories: backup omission, where no backup is made; incomplete side-effect identification, where the backup misses affected state beyond the named target; insufficient capture, where the right state is targeted but not fully preserved; and non-restorable state, where the backup is sufficient but the state cannot be reproduced.

All of BackUpper’s failures fall into the non-restorable state category. This means BackUpper preserves sufficient information for functional restoration and only fails when the service prevents the restoration. For example, in one regret moment, a user deletes a cloud document whose link had already been shared with others [1]. BackUpper preserves the document, but the restored copy receives a new identifier and the shared link no longer works. This aligns with the character-level similarity analysis in Sec. 5.2, and such limits apply to any backup approach. Together, these results show that restoring from BackUpper’s backups recovers nearly all of the functionality users need, further verifying the sufficiency of its backed-up artifacts. We analyze these bottlenecks further in our response to Reviewer 93YL (W2/Q2).

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/googledocs/comments/1ne5ddt/is_it_possible_for_me_to_recover_a_deleted_docs/

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (2/2)

W3: Judge-Based Evaluation

We will revise the claim to “100% judge-assessed coverage” to reflect our evaluation more accurately. Nevertheless, our conclusion that BackUpper outperforms the other methods still holds under human evaluation and under a cross-family judge, as shown below.

Human evaluation.

MethodJudged backed upJudged not backed up
BackUpper95.0% (285/300)–
Skill-Based94.3% (283/300)98.7% (148/150)
Baseline92.0% (138/150)97.4% (341/350)
Overall94.1% (706/750)97.8% (489/500)

Cross-family judge.

MethodRMBR (Sonnet-5)RMBR (GLM 5.3-Flash)OWBR (Sonnet-5)OWBR (GLM 5.3-Flash)
Baseline15.215.817.416.3
Skill-Based81.478.680.578.4
BackUpper100.098.9100.098.3

BackUpper outperforms other methods under every evaluator. Human agreement on judge-positive actions is similar across methods (92.0–95.0%), so the judge does not favor BackUpper. Under GLM 5.3-Flash, scores shift by at most 2.8 points, far less than the gap of about 20 points between BackUpper and Skill-Based.

All disagreements on BackUpper involve only additional metadata. We reviewed all 15 human disagreements and every BackUpper action that GLM 5.3-Flash judged as not backed up. In every case, the backup captures the content but omits fields such as read/unread flags. The evaluators also differ on how strictly to treat such metadata: among the 15 cases where humans disagree, GLM accepts 10 and rejects 5, while Sonnet-5 accepts all 15. This suggests that the disagreements may reflect how strictly each evaluator treats metadata, rather than missing recovery needs in BackUpper’s backups.

This metadata does not affect documented recovery needs. We re-read all 205 regret-moment reports and found that no documented recovery need involves additional metadata. Our functional tests (W2) further confirm this: restoring from BackUpper’s backups passes 94.7% of tests, and all of its failures come from state that the service itself cannot reproduce.

Together, these findings suggest that evaluators may differ in how strictly they treat additional metadata, while BackUpper’s backups sufficiently capture what users actually need for recovery.

W4: Task Performance with BackUpper

We evaluate the task pass rate on all 205 RegretBench tasks with BackUpper enabled:

Opus-5Sonnet-5GPT 5.6-SolGPT 5.6-TerraDeepSeek V4-ProGemini 3.7-FlashAvg
w/o BackUpper92.282.090.785.981.584.486.1
w/ BackUpper92.280.092.787.881.582.086.0
Δ0.0−2.0+2.0+1.90.0−2.4−0.1

The average change is only −0.1 points, with the differences across models going in both directions and consistent with run-to-run variance in agentic tasks. We manually inspected every task whose outcome differed and found no evidence that BackUpper caused the change. This further supports our finding in Sec. 5.3 that BackUpper improves recoverability without degrading task performance.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.