- The experiments do not convincingly isolate a migration-specific phenomenon.
The primary benchmark uses memory records generated by an external generator rather than memories actually produced by the source agent (Section 3, PDF page 4).
The source model primarily determines which records pass safety screening, whereas the target model determines how those records are interpreted.
More importantly, target-model identity explains approximately 91.5% of the pair-level variance (Section 7, PDF page 8). The paper's bidirectional inversion hypothesis also fails to replicate (PDF page 9).
These findings suggest that the observed phenomenon may be largely explained by target-model susceptibility to instruction-bearing memory rather than a distinctive interaction between specific source and target models.
The supplementary source-authored experiment includes only 180 screened-in records (Appendix G.2, PDF page 39), which is insufficient to establish generalization to longitudinal, real-world agent memory.
- The proposed methods fail to establish a convincing incremental contribution.
The proposed memory compiler does not meaningfully reduce violations, while the pair-conditioned compatibility predictor improves AUROC over a target-aware baseline by only 0.009 (PDF page 9).
The selective migration gate achieves stronger safety results, but the reported comparison does not include a target-only baseline equipped with the same risk-calibration procedure.
Appendix Table 11 (PDF page 38) attributes the formal guarantee to conformal calibration rather than to the proposed pairwise compatibility features.
Consequently, it is unclear whether the improvement arises from a novel migration-aware mechanism or from applying an existing calibration procedure to a different score.
- The operational effectiveness of the defense is not convincingly established.
Appendix Table 12 (PDF page 39) reports that among 196 confirmed attack cases, 50 are both accepted by the full defense and still result in violations.
This result does not necessarily contradict the paper's theoretical guarantee, which depends on exchangeability assumptions. However, it exposes an important limitation when the defense is deployed against deliberately selected or adaptive attacks.
Furthermore, the runtime capability gate prevents unauthorized tool actions by construction (Appendix Tables 15–16). Although this is useful engineering, it does not establish the effectiveness of the proposed memory compiler or compatibility predictor.
- The model suite and memory evaluation are outdated and insufficiently representative.
All six evaluated model families originate from 2024. For an ICLR 2027 submission, the absence of models released in 2025 or 2026 substantially limits the relevance of the reported findings to contemporary agents.
More importantly, the benchmark relies predominantly on synthetic memory artifacts rather than memories accumulated during actual agent execution.
Real agent memory undergoes creation, summarization, retrieval, revision, and repeated reuse. These processes can alter both the content and interpretation of memory records.
The paper does not adequately establish that its conclusions generalize to such environments.
- The privacy claims are substantially broader than the measured evidence.
Although the title emphasizes both safety and privacy inversion, the measured privacy violation rate is approximately 0.002.
The overwhelming majority of observed violations are associated with authority escalation.
The paper therefore provides relatively little empirical evidence for privacy inversion as a substantial independent phenomenon.
- The main-paper presentation is inadequate for evaluating the empirical contribution.
The nine-page main paper contains only one plotted figure, and Figure 1 contains visibly overlapping text labels.
The most important comparisons supporting the claimed contributions are distributed across appendix tables rather than presented in the main paper.
This is particularly problematic because the paper introduces several mitigation mechanisms whose effectiveness is not consistently supported by the experiments.
A stronger presentation would explicitly summarize the central empirical findings, negative results, and relevant trade-offs in the main paper.
Dear Reviewers and Area Chairs,
We sincerely thank you for your time, thoughtful evaluations, and constructive feedback throughout the review process.
Your comments have helped us identify important limitations and opportunities to strengthen our work. We appreciate the careful consideration given to our submission.
We will take your suggestions into account, further improve the manuscript, and prepare a stronger version for submission to a future conference.
Thank you once again for your valuable feedback and contributions to improving our research.