- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates how device settings and simulated neural loss affect sound localization with bilateral cochlear implants. Hybrid-CINN combines natural sounds spatialized using behind-the-ear head-related transfer functions (HRTFs), a stochastic CI and auditory-nerve simulation, and a convolutional localization decoder. Baseline evaluation uses held-out sounds, simulated rooms, and HRTFs; factor experiments use reduced training data and one held-out HRTF. Without fitting human localization responses, the model exhibits lateral response compression, stronger reliance on interaural level differences than interaural time differences, and poorer low-frequency localization, while achieving lower error than the compared CI cohort. Separate decoders are trained from scratch for each device or neural condition. Within the tested configurations, unilateral insertion shifts increase localization error, linked automatic gain control provides a small improvement, and asymmetric or basal fiber loss is more detrimental than symmetric or apical loss, respectively. At matched nonzero nominal deletion fractions, silencing units across multiple decoder stages produces larger errors than deleting peripheral fibers.
Critical strengths
-
Controlled comparisons of peripheral loss patterns
The interaural-asymmetry experiment holds total fiber loss constant, and the basal-versus-apical experiment removes equal numbers of fibers (Fig. 4). These controls show that, within Hybrid-CINN, the distribution of surviving inputs across ears and cochlear regions matters beyond their total number. This is a useful contribution because it yields specific predictions about the loss patterns that impair localization, extending the analysis beyond overall neural survival. -
Qualitative behavioral agreement without fitting human responses
The model reproduces lateral response compression, ILD-dominant cue use, and poorer low-frequency localization without fitting human localization responses (Fig. 2). Baseline testing uses held-out sounds, rooms, and HRTFs. Although its overall localization error is lower than that of the compared CI cohort, agreement across these qualitative signatures provides a useful behavioral check before the framework is used to study controlled perturbations.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central versus peripheral interpretation depends on the lesion design
Figure 4B compares deletion of auditory-nerve fibers at the input with silencing channels and hidden units across multiple decoder stages, with inverted scaling of surviving units (Appendix A.8). Equal deletion fractions do not establish comparable losses of information or computational capacity. The authors acknowledge the information mismatch in Section 4.3, but the explanation that the decoder has less spare capacity remains dependent on this architecture and lesion topology. Appendix A.6 describes alternative architectures' intact performance without reporting corresponding lesion responses. The observed ranking is therefore supported for the tested interventions, while a broader capacity interpretation requires additional evidence. This distinction matters because the central versus peripheral comparison is a principal result; the conclusions should consistently reflect its operational scope. -
Generalization of the main factor effects across HRTFs is not established
The baseline evaluation uses five leave-one-HRTF-out folds, but the device and neural-factor experiments use reduced training data and a single held-out test HRTF, b_ci8 (Appendix A.5). Repeated runs quantify variation across training runs and, for neural lesions, lesion masks within this setting; they do not establish that effect sizes or condition rankings are stable across HRTFs. These comparisons provide much of the paper's added scientific contribution, so their robustness across HRTFs materially affects the strength of the conclusions. The results remain informative within the tested configuration. Selected key contrasts across the available folds would strengthen the evidence, with the reduced training regime retained as an explicit qualification.
Questions for authors
- Clarification of the central versus peripheral interpretation. Section 4.3 suggests that the decoder has less spare capacity, while acknowledging that lesions are matched by fraction rather than information. Is this interpretation intended to be limited to the current CNN and lesion design? If a broader claim is intended, what evidence supports it? Do the alternative-architecture evaluations include lesion responses beyond the intact results reported in Appendix A.6?
- Additional evidence for the main factor claims. Appendix A.5 states that a five-fold evaluation is planned. Can the authors provide selected central/peripheral, basal/apical, and asymmetric/symmetric contrasts across the available held-out HRTFs, expressed relative to each fold's own intact control? Consistency in the directions and magnitudes of these effects would materially affect my assessment; a full replication of every dose curve is not necessary.
I read the rebuttal made by the authors, including General Response and the other responses to all reviewers.
According to the authors' promises, most of my concerns (will) have been resolved. I am adjusting my rating from the original score 'Weak acceptance' to 'Clear acceptance'.