- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the problem of adapting tabular foundation model for any task using boosting. I would categorize this work as empirical and experimental. No novel approach has been presented - this is actually what the Tabular foundation model community is usually doing to reach better quality models and results. The approach is basically stacking boosting to the tabular foundation model - nothing new here - this is the foundation to make these models working better.
Sorry no surprising effect using this approach, which is altogether is not new, even applied to tabular foundation model.
Critical strengths
- simple, cheap and practical but not new - and well known in the community for these models and problems. Results are trivial.
Critical weaknesses
- limited datasets - but even a larger dataset won't help the paper - given no novelty is presented. Nice application, in-use paper. Fall short for ICLR.
- key baselines are missing
- scope is too narrow
- readability: this starts from the Abstract - I have not asked but ask an LLM to assess the presentation - sure plenty of good practice will be shared. Specially on the numbers reported with no context.
Questions for authors
- limited datasets: why?
- key baselines are missing: why?
- scope is too narrow: why?