- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates effective exploration in reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR), where policy optimization may progressively concentrate probability mass on a narrow set of reasoning trajectories, limiting exploration. To address this issue, the authors propose Exploration Prior (EP), which leverages the language model's natural-language conditioning capability to provide semantic guidance. Specifically, EP constructs an exploration prior using answer-free path-switching instructions. From a probabilistic inference perspective, task rewards tilt this prior toward high-reward reasoning trajectories, yielding a posterior distribution that is approximated through reverse-KL-regularized policy optimization. Experiments across multiple mathematical reasoning benchmarks and model backbones demonstrate improvements in reasoning performance, trajectory diversity, and successful-solution coverage.
Critical strengths
-
This paper addresses the challenge of insufficient exploration in RLVR training and explores natural-language conditioning as a new perspective for guiding reasoning exploration.
-
This paper demonstrates performance improvements across multiple mathematical reasoning benchmarks and model backbones, supported by exploration analyses, ablation studies, and hyperparameter sensitivity analyses.
Critical weaknesses
- This paper argues that existing RLVR exploration methods primarily rely on entropy, uncertainty, and trajectory diversity signals but lack explicit semantic guidance, thereby motivating the proposed Exploration Prior (EP). However, this motivation lacks sufficient theoretical justification and empirical support. First, the paper fails to clearly define effective exploration or clarify the relationship between trajectory diversity, reasoning path coverage, and exploration effectiveness. Second, the absence of explicit semantic guidance does not imply that existing methods cannot discover diverse, high-reward reasoning trajectories. The authors neither thoroughly analyze the specific failure modes of existing approaches nor demonstrate why semantic guidance would lead to more valuable exploration. Consequently, the paper fails to establish a convincing connection between the substantive limitations of existing methods and the design of EP, leaving its core motivation and necessity insufficiently justified.
- This paper constructs an exploration prior through natural-language interventions and uses the resulting token-level probability shifts to guide policy updates. However, the authors do not adequately explain how these probability shifts translate into effective reasoning exploration. Path-switching instructions may induce changes in textual expression, reasoning strategies, or error correction, but these behaviors do not necessarily provide the same exploration value. Although task rewards are incorporated into policy optimization, the paper lacks a direct analysis of the reasoning behaviors induced by different interventions and their associated reward improvements. Moreover, the existing textual diversity and Pass@K analyses are insufficient to demonstrate that EP discovers more valuable reasoning trajectories than existing exploration methods. Consequently, the effectiveness and distinctive contribution of the proposed path-switching mechanism remain insufficiently supported by empirical evidence.
Questions for authors
see Critical Weaknesses
2 comments
Response to W1: Motivation and Effective Exploration(Part 2/2)
| Method | Strategy diversity (problems with ≥2 correct trajectories) | Strategy diversity (all problems with correct trajectories) | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| step30 | step60 | step120 | step200 | step30 | step60 | step120 | step200 | |
| GRPO | 1.23 | 1.33 | 1.26 | 1.29 | 1.21 | 1.34 | 1.24 | 1.28 |
| GRPO+Entropy | 1.32 | 1.31 | 1.25 | 1.27 | 1.33 | 1.26 | 1.25 | 1.26 |
| Neutral General Instruction(Continue Reasoning.) | 1.35 | 1.24 | 1.28 | 1.28 | 1.28 | 1.24 | 1.26 | 1.28 |
| EP | 1.35 | 1.44 | 1.24 | 1.27 | 1.32 | 1.48 | 1.23 | 1.25 |
We observe a strategy coverage advantage at Step 60. Among problems with at least two correct trajectories, EP covers 1.44 distinct strategies per problem on average, compared with 1.33 for GRPO, 1.31 for GRPO+Entropy, and 1.24 for general instructions. The same ordering holds when including problems with at least one correct trajectory. Together with the higher benchmark Pass@16 at the selected checkpoint, these results provide complementary evidence that EP promotes strategy-level exploration during training and improves the effectiveness of the learned policy under a fixed inference sampling budget.
We will clarify these distinctions and incorporate the additional analyses in the revised manuscript.
Criteria for identifying distinct strategies. For each problem, the judge identifies and groups mathematically equivalent approaches across all correct trajectories. Following the criteria in [2], distinct strategies are identified based on three dimensions:
- Mathematical tools (e.g., calculus or geometry).
- Definitions or structures (e.g., explicit formulas or recurrence relations).
- Representational viewpoints (e.g., reasoning about a geometric locus or expressing constraints in vector form).
References
[1] Hu et al. Diversity-Incentivized Exploration for Versatile Reasoning. ICLR 2026.
[2] Lee et al. Are We Measuring Strategy or Phrasing? The Gap Between Surface- and Approach-Level Diversity in LLM Math Reasoning. EMNLP 2026.
Response to W2: Mechanism and Effectiveness of Path-Switching Guidance
Thank you for raising the possibility that a path-switching instruction can also prompt the model to check its work. We address this through the policy update and an additional instruction ablation.
1. How the prior enters the policy update. Each sampled token receives the trajectory's reward-based GRPO advantage. From the intervention position onward, EP adds a scaled, clipped log-probability ratio comparing the instruction-conditioned prior with the current policy on the same sampled token. The sum of the two terms enters the GRPO update. Because the probability of a continuation is the product of its conditional token probabilities, these updates can change which reasoning paths the policy samples in subsequent rollouts.
2. Removing explicit self-correction cues. Some of the original path-switching instructions also incorporate self-correction cues. We remove these cues and replace the original instruction set with the following twelve path-switching instructions.
Try a different approach.
Use another method to solve the problem.
Explore a different reasoning path.
Consider another solution strategy.
Switch to a different approach.
Solve the problem from a different perspective.
Adopt a different reasoning strategy.
Use a different mathematical approach.
Explore another way to solve the problem.
Proceed with a different solution method.
Reformulate the problem from a different perspective.
Pursue a different line of reasoning.
Across the five benchmarks in W1, removing explicit self-correction cues yields 52.3 Avg@16 and 71.3 Pass@16, close to the original EP scores of 51.9 and 71.5. These results suggest that the benefits of path-switching guidance do not depend on explicit self-correction cues.
3. Evidence of effective strategy-level exploration. Under the same sampling budget, EP improves mean Pass@16 from 67.8 to 71.5 and mean Avg@16 from 46.6 to 51.9 over GRPO. We agree that these metrics alone cannot distinguish broader strategy coverage from improved reliability within existing strategies.
To address this limitation, the additional strategy-level analysis at training step 60, reported in our response to W1, shows that EP covers more distinct mathematical strategies among correct rollouts than GRPO, GRPO+Entropy, and the general-instruction variant.
Together, these results provide complementary evidence that path-switching guidance improves exploration effectiveness and broadens strategy coverage among successful trajectories. A finer-grained analysis of different intervention-induced reasoning behaviors and their individual contributions to reward improvements is left for future work.
We will incorporate these clarifications and additional analyses into the revised manuscript.
Response to W1: Motivation and Effective Exploration(Part 1/2)
Thank you for your insightful suggestion, which helps us clarify our methodology and strengthen the empirical analysis. We agree that the lack of explicit semantic guidance does not imply that existing methods cannot discover diverse, high-reward trajectories. Our motivation is instead based on the limitations of their exploration signals.
1. Definition of effective exploration. We define effective exploration as the ability to discover high-reward reasoning trajectories under a limited sampling budget. Trajectory diversity measures differences between generated sequences, whereas strategy diversity captures differences in the underlying reasoning approaches. Exploring distinct reasoning strategies can facilitate the discovery of successful solutions. However, greater trajectory diversity does not necessarily imply broader strategy coverage, as diverse trajectories may still follow the same underlying reasoning approach [2].
2. Limitations of entropy-based exploration. Section 4.3 (“Relation to Entropy Regularization”) shows that, given a problem and a fixed prefix, an entropy bonus over a fixed finite set of reasoning continuations is equivalent, up to an additive constant, to a reverse-KL penalty toward a uniform prior over that set. It therefore does not explicitly distinguish between semantically different exploration directions, such as rephrasing an existing solution and attempting an alternative reasoning approach.
3. Limitations of diversity-based exploration. Methods such as DIVER [1] encourage exploration through textual and equational diversity rewards. However, these trajectory-level signals do not necessarily reflect differences in underlying reasoning strategies. A recent study [2] provides empirical evidence that DIVER primarily increases diversity within existing approaches rather than expanding the coverage of distinct reasoning strategies. These findings highlight a potential gap between trajectory-level diversity and strategy-level exploration.
4. Motivation of EP. These limitations motivate us to introduce an explicit semantic preference into the exploration prior. Rather than indiscriminately encouraging randomness or trajectory dissimilarity, EP uses path-switching instructions to bias the policy toward alternative reasoning continuations. Verifiable rewards complement this guidance by reinforcing successful trajectories. EP thus provides a directional exploration signal without requiring knowledge of the correct solution.
5. Additional empirical evidence. We examine how the choice of instruction affects Qwen3-4B performance and measure strategy coverage at four training checkpoints.
First, we replace path-switching instructions with general reasoning instructions (e.g., “Continue reasoning”), while keeping the remaining configuration unchanged. The table also includes a path-switching variant that removes explicit self-correction cues, discussed in W2. Each cell reports Avg@16 / Pass@16 (%). The mean gives equal weight to each benchmark.
The original EP instructions outperform general reasoning instructions by 4.2 percentage points in mean Avg@16 and 2.9 points in mean Pass@16.
Second, we analyze the evolution of strategy diversity throughout training. Following the strategy-identification criteria in [2], we distinguish mathematical strategies based on three dimensions: Mathematical Tools, Definitions/Structures, and Representational Viewpoints. We use DeepSeek Flash v4.1 as the judge model to identify and categorize distinct strategies. At each step, we sample 8 rollouts for each of the 64 problems. To reduce the confounding effect of differences in accuracy, we primarily report strategy diversity on problems with at least two correct trajectories, ensuring a sufficient number of successful samples for meaningful strategy comparison. We additionally report results across all problems with at least one correct trajectory. Importantly, our strategy identification allows multiple distinct strategies to be counted within a single trajectory, rather than restricting each trajectory to a single strategy.