W1. Insufficient Comparison with Prior Work
-
The related-work section misses several highly relevant recent studies [1-6]. For instance, DualVision (Majeedi et al., CVPR Findings, 2026) already builds an RGB–IR MLLM using aligned image pairs, cross-attention fusion, a large RGB–IR instruction dataset, and a benchmark for multimodal reasoning under visual degradations. Its 25K paired images and 204K QA annotations are directly comparable in purpose to the resources proposed here. The primary architectural distinction appears to be Thermo-VL’s additional prompt-conditioned attention and token-wise gate, but this difference is neither discussed nor evaluated experimentally.
-
The positioning of earlier infrared VLMs is also incomplete. Infrared-LLaVA directly trains an infrared-language model using infrared-specific supervision, while IRGPT introduces more than 260K real infrared-text samples and nine infrared-language tasks. Therefore, the statement that previous methods do not directly align thermal observations with language is too broad. Infrared-LLaVA (Jiang et al., Findings of EMNLP, 2024) and IRGPT (Cao et al., ICCV, 2025) should be discussed more accurately.
-
Overall, the methodological contribution currently appears to be an incremental variation of established cross-attention, residual adaptation, modality alignment, and gating mechanisms applied to an RGB–thermal VLM.
[1] DualVision: RGB-Infrared Multimodal Large Language Models for Robust Visual Reasoning, CVPR 26 Findings
[2] IRGPT: Understanding Real-world Infrared Image with Bi-cross-modal Curriculum on Large-scale Benchmark, ICCV 25
[3] Infrared-LLaVA: Enhancing Understanding of Infrared Images in Multi-Modal Large Language Models, EMNLP Findings 24
[4] Enhanced Vision-Language Models for Diverse Sensor Understanding: Cost-Efficient Optimization and Benchmarking, TIP 26
[5] IF-Bench: Benchmarking and Enhancing MLLMs for Infrared Images with Generative Visual Prompting, CVPR 26
[6] ThermEval: A Structured Benchmark for Evaluation of Vision-Language Models on Thermal Imagery, KDD 26
W2. Unfair Comparison Setting
- The main comparison in Table 2 is not sufficient to isolate the proposed architecture. Thermo-VL is trained on approximately 54K domain-specific QA pairs, whereas InternVL, Qwen2.5-VL, LLaVA-Next, and Molmo appear to be evaluated out of the box. Consequently, these results combine the effects of thermal instruction tuning, thermal encoder pretraining, additional trainable capacity, and the proposed fusion design.
W3. Benchmark Reliability & Diversity
- Thermo-VL-Bench is described as manually screened, but its questions and answers were generated by GPT-5.1 and approximately 80% were accepted verbatim. Only 100 of roughly 15K questions received independent overlapping annotation. Also, the benchmark contains only binary yes/no questions. This measures recognition and constrained verification more directly than open-ended thermal reasoning. Recent benchmarks such as IF-Bench and ThermEval provide broader task structures, while ThermEval explicitly includes quantitative temperature-grounded classification and regression. The paper should include human-authored questions, paraphrase/template-held-out evaluation, text-only and image-permutation controls, etc.
W4. Unsupported Selective-Gating Claim
- The paper claims that the model injects thermal evidence only where it is useful for the current question. However, the experiments mainly show that thermal information is used: zeroing or shuffling thermal tokens reduces accuracy, and removing text attention also reduces performance. These experiments do not demonstrate that the learned token gates are spatially selective or change appropriately with the question.