- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper shows how to implement multivector operations from Geometric Algebra using jax primitives, so they are compatible with automatic differentiation. They demonstrate their approach on four examples from manifold learning, physics, and optimization.
Critical strengths
The chosen examples in Section 4 are interesting.
Critical weaknesses
- I am not sure what the novel contribution is, and how the author's work differs from other approaches to computational geometric algebra. Please see the "Questions For Authors" section.
- There does not appear to be any comparison to other approaches, either within the realm of geometric algebra or other more "conventional" approaches to the examples in Section 4. Why should a researcher reach for this method over everything else?
Questions for authors
- How does your approach differ from existing geometric algebra libraries?
- What precisely are the new results in Section 3?
- Why are there no comparisons to other libraries in Section 4? Are you doing something fundamentally different that those libraries can not handle?
I wish to emphasize that, at the moment, I am mostly just confused as to what is the claimed novelty for this submission. I have never worked with geometric algebra in a professional sense, my experience is limited to a few leisurely hours in a cafe spent with "Geometric Algebra for Computer Science" by Dorst, Fontijne, and Mann. Nonetheless, I am aware of a community of enthusiasts who don't really need to be sold on the beauty and utility of ga. What does this paper do for them?
My "Rating" is entirely preliminary. I will consider the author's responses to these questions in good-faith and update my review as appropriate.
2 comments
Thank you for the response and clarifying the nature of the contributions. I am raising my score to a 2. I respectfully suggest this paper may find it's audience in a computational geometric algebra venue. I am not sure there will be enthusiastic interest among general machine learners.
Response to Reviewer Giqw
Thank you for your review and we especially appreciate your willingness to hear about why the GA enthusiasts would be excited about this work, as we also hoped this would be effectively communicated in the paper.
Difference from GA libraries. As stated in the general comment above, existing libraries only implement geometric algebra operations, with no way of computing the multivector derivative and any of the downstream primitives. The experiments in Section 4 all require some of these primitives, and thus to re-implement them you would either have to i) write bespoke code which is specific to a certain choice of algebra, dimension, manifold, etc., or ii) re-implement our library of primitives on top of an existing GA library.
Novelty in Section 3. Section 3.1 and 3.2 are standard definitions (our favorite reference is Hestenes and Sobczyk, 1984), where we have slightly modified the definition to explicitly include the input and output blade indexing set I and O to connect it to the computational aspect that is Lemma 2 of Section 3.3. This is the only new contribution of Section 3, and formalizes the idea that one can combine geometric algebra with
jvp/vjpto compute the multivector derivative. Section 3.4 and 3.5 are also standard definitions, but now are computable through compositions of the multivector derivative and the projection operators.Novelty of Experiments. See the "Novelty of Experiments" in the general comment above.
Broader implications for the GA community Many GA enthusiasts are physicists or differential geometers who primarily use it as a tool for doing symbolic calculations to derive more compact expressions for geometric quantities (e.g. Maxwell's equation). This work bridges the gap between theory and computation and allows you to explicitly compute things like covariant derivatives of fields, curvatures on manifolds, trivialized differentials of rotor groups, and more with very few lines of code. Just as the enthusiasts leverage GA to store as much information in as few equations as possible, our implementation allows for much more compact code representations of complex geometric computations common to many AI for Science applications, among others.