W1. Section A.6 states that factor-set F1 uses the same correspondences as ground-truth recovery, with P = M/N and R = M/K. Under this definition, the default dSprites configuration, which Table 2 reports as 5/5 (5), should give F1 = 1.0. Table 2 instead reports 0.60 for the default Qwen3-VL-32B / Qwen3-14B row. Likewise, the default 3D-Shapes row in the robustness block, 6/6 (12), implies F1 ≈ 0.67, but the model-dependence block of the same table reports 0.56. An F1 of 0.60 on dSprites corresponds to only about three of five factors being matched. This directly contradicts the claim that dSprites is recovered completely in every run. The authors need to explain this discrepancy. If the model-dependent runs differ from the main runs, they should state why the default configuration recovers fewer factors there, because this bears on how reliable the headline recovery numbers are.
W2. A ground-truth factor counts as recovered when any discovered factor reaches |Spearman| (or Cramér's V / η) ≥ 0.4 with it. It is not clear from the paper whether this bar is strict enough to exclude correlated or proxy properties. The paper does not report the actual per-factor correspondence values or how recovery changes as the threshold is raised (e.g., from 0.4 to 0.8). These analyses would show whether the headline recovery holds under stricter matching. A related question is how recall-style recovery accounts for over-segmentation. 3D-Shapes yields 9.6 ± 1.8 factors for 6 ground-truth factors, and MPI3D-C yields 18.2 ± 3.0 (up to 37 with 5×5 sheets) for 7. Could the authors clarify how these additional factors relate to the ground truth? I would also ask the authors to reconcile the default MPI3D-C F1 of 0.15 with the coverage claim, since under the stated definition, that F1 would correspond to roughly two of the seven simulator variables being matched. For the coverage argument itself (Table 9), a quantitative measure across all seeds would make it more convincing than the current qualitative mapping for one seed. One option would be to report how well the full discovered vector predicts each ground-truth factor.
W3. In Table 13, several alternative Factor Reasoners outperform the default Qwen3-14B on most datasets. Llama3.1-8B, for example, reaches 1.00 / .89 / .57 / .46 versus .89 / .60 / .56 / .15 for the default. In Table 11, Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B beat Qwen3-14B on 3D-Shapes and MPI3D-C. Because each model configuration is run once, it is unclear whether these differences reflect the models or run-to-run noise. Either reading is problematic: either the default is suboptimal, or the pipeline's variance is large enough to swamp model effects. We need multi-seed results for the model sweeps.
W4. Each component ablation is a single run, while dictionary size on 3D-Shapes varies between 8 and 12 across seeds under the full procedure. Several ablation outcomes are hard to interpret. Removing final minimality yields fewer factors (7) than the full procedure (9). Removing semantic independence alone drops recovery to 3/6 because wall and floor color stay merged. Yet removing all checks, including semantic independence, recovers 6/6. This last result suggests that whether wall and floor color are merged is largely stochastic rather than controlled by the semantic-independence step. More broadly, the full validation pipeline does not improve recovery over the "all checks removed" setting on any dataset; its demonstrated benefit is compactness. The paper should run ablations across multiple seeds and state the validation stage's main contribution accordingly. The paper should also state which seed the ablations and robustness runs use: the "full" 3D-Shapes rows give (9) in Tables 3 and 15 but (12) in Table 2.
W5. dSprites, 3D-Shapes, and MPI3D are widely reproduced in the ML literature, together with descriptions of their generative factors. Withholding the dataset name does not by itself rule out that a large VLM recognizes these images and recalls their documented factors. Could the authors explain how they ensure that the discovered factors reflect visual comparison rather than such prior exposure? Does the paper include an experiment that controls for this possibility? A related question concerns the fixed vocabulary. It explicitly lists TranslateX, TranslateY, rotation, scale, and hue, which overlap closely with the XYCS and dSprites ground truth. The free-form ablation partially addresses this, but it recovers only 4/6 factors on 3D-Shapes. Have the authors considered evaluating on data the models are unlikely to have seen with documented factors? Options include a newly rendered dataset with known generative factors, less common benchmarks (e.g., Falcor3D, Isaac3D), or a real-image dataset with annotated attributes. Such an evaluation would also connect to the introduction's motivation for scientific and proprietary data, which we do not currently test. Results of this kind would help separate the contribution of semantic inductive bias from possible recall of benchmark conventions.
W6. The proposed representation is a VLM's direct reading of named, human-aligned attributes. The baselines are unsupervised generative models, and the 300-image variants trained for 2,000 epochs are close to strawmen. A more informative comparison would include methods that also exploit pretrained vision-language knowledge. Examples are CLIP or VLM zero-shot scoring of attributes (including an oracle variant given the ground-truth factor names, as an upper bound), concept-bottleneck-style extraction, and weakly supervised disentanglement methods. Stronger unsupervised baselines such as FactorVAE and β-TCVAE are also absent. The dimensionality differs as well: baselines use K latents, whereas the proposed representation uses m ≥ K, sometimes 20 or more. The paper does not explain how categorical factors are encoded for DCI, SAP, and the intervention metrics. Finally, the abstract states that the representations "remain competitive with baselines trained using all images." Table 4 shows that on dSprites the full-data baselines win five of six metrics, and on 3D-Shapes DAE (all) wins on DCI-D, MIG, and z-min-var. The claim should be tempered.
W7. Sufficiency, minimality, and semantic independence are stated in prose only, without a formal definition or any analysis of when the procedure would converge to them. The pipeline involves roughly twenty hyperparameters (Tables 5 and 6). Some, such as the association thresholds 0.40 / 0.32, 0.36 / 0.26 and 0.52 / 0.37, are oddly specific. The authors should explain how these were chosen and confirm that ground-truth labels of the evaluation benchmarks were not used to tune them, because that would leak evaluation information into the method.
W8. The dictionary includes topology (linear or circular) and factor type, but neither is evaluated, even though dSprites and 3D-Shapes contain circular orientation factors. The paper also does not report measurement accuracy directly; for example, the correlation between each matched factor's VLM reading and its ground-truth value. Either for the computational cost.