acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Intrinsic Memory Agents: Heterogeneous Multi-Agent LLM Systems through Structured Contextual Memory

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Multi-agent systems built on Large Language Models (LLMs) show exceptional promise for complex collaborative problem-solving, yet they face fundamental challenges stemming from context window limitations that impair memory consistency, role adherence, and procedural integrity. This paper introduces Intrinsic Memory Agents, a framework that addresses these limitations through agent-specific memories that evolve intrinsically with agent outputs, maintaining role-aligned memory that preserves specialised perspectives while focusing on task-relevant information. Our approach utilises a generic memory template applicable to new problems without the need to hand-craft specific memory prompts. We evaluate it against six published memory designs and a no-memory control on seven benchmarks datasets spanning knowledge reasoning (FEVER, HotpotQA), embodied action (ALFWorld, SciWorld, BabyAI) and planning (PDDL), with ten seeds per condition. Intrinsic memory is strongest on knowledge reasoning, taking the top three places on both FEVER and HotpotQA. An additional evaluation is performed on a complex data pipeline design task, and we demonstrate that our approach produces higher quality designs across 5 metrics: scalability, reliability, usability, cost-effectiveness, and documentation, plus additional qualitative evidence of the improvements. Our findings suggest that addressing memory limitations through intrinsic approaches can improve the capabilities of multi-agent LLM systems on structured planning tasks.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
large language models, memory, multi-agent systems

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 4 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_rWprOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Intrinsic Memory Agents, where each agent maintains structured memory updated from its own outputs through an additional LLM call. Subsequent contexts prioritize the task description, personal memory, and recent dialogue. Evaluation covers seven benchmarks using gpt-oss-120b with ten seeds, alongside a collaborative pipeline design case study using Llama-3.2-3B. Results vary across tasks, with higher judged quality in the case study and additional token costs.

Critical strengths
  1. Preserving relevant information and responsibilities during extended multi-agent collaboration is a practically meaningful problem.
  2. The evaluation covers diverse tasks, reruns multiple baselines with the same backbone, and reports results across ten seeds.
  3. The paper reports negative results, including degradation on some action tasks and limited benefits from carrying memory across tasks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The novelty argument relies on an inaccurate characterization of prior work. Section 2 suggests that shared memory gives all agents the same retrieved context. However, G-Memory explicitly conditions memory selection on the agent’s role and current query (its Eq. 8), while Generative Agents already maintains individual agents’ experiences. The paper should clarify its specific advance in updating private structured memory during a task and establish its value relative to these existing mechanisms.

  2. The engineering contribution is insufficiently isolated and validated. The evaluation does not directly establish whether important role-specific constraints survive context truncation or outdated decisions are corrected. The template and reset/carry comparisons do not isolate private memory from shared summaries or dynamic updates from static guidance. Moreover, the manual template in Figure 4 includes planning knowledge, confounding memory structure with task guidance. Focused controls and an audit of existing trajectories would better support the central claims about role consistency.

  3. The most relevant collaborative evaluation provides limited evidence. The pipeline design study uses one task, ten runs, and Llama-3.2-3B, without adequately motivating this backbone or testing whether gains persist with a stronger model. This matters because the case study most directly matches the paper’s motivation. The judge model and configuration are also unclear, and the evaluation does not adequately control for output length or independently verify engineering quality. Higher scores could therefore partly reflect more detailed descriptions.

  4. The practical benefit relative to computational cost remains unclear. On HotpotQA, the manual template scores 0.480 versus 0.469 for the strongest existing baseline, while consuming approximately 4.8 times the completion tokens of the no-memory control (Tables 2 and 5). Performance is weaker on several action tasks. These results call for clearer comparisons against the strongest baselines, including statistical uncertainty and comparable computational budgets, to establish when the additional memory maintenance is worthwhile.

Questions for authors
  1. After correcting the discussion of G-Memory and Generative Agents, what is the principal technical or empirical contribution, and which experiment directly supports it?
  2. What inputs does each memory updater actually receive: the agent’s own output, observations, or the task trajectory? Could existing trajectories demonstrate constraint retention and correction of outdated decisions?
  3. Do the benefits survive controls for shared versus private memory and static task guidance versus dynamic updates, under comparable computational budgets?
  4. How robust are the case study gains to backbone strength, output length, and independent assessment of design quality? Please also identify the judge model and configuration.
Reviewer_cucEOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Intrinsic Memory Agents, where each agent maintains a separate, role-aligned memory updated through a prompted LLM call after it speaks. Context construction prioritizes the task, agent memory, and recent conversation. The paper compares handwritten, generic, and LLM-generated templates, with either per-task resets or memory carried across tasks.

The evaluation compares six memory designs and a no-memory control on seven benchmarks with gpt-oss-120b and ten seeds per condition. Intrinsic variants lead on FEVER and HotpotQA, and the handwritten reset variant ties Voyager in the aggregate ranking, while baselines lead on ALFWorld, SciWorld, and BabyAI. Carrying memory across tasks usually hurts. An eight-agent pipeline-design case study reports higher LLM-judge scores with roughly a third more tokens.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper proposes a simple, practical mechanism for preserving each agent's working context. Separate memories, role conditioning, and an explicit context-priority rule are straightforward to implement without a retrieval index. This is useful for extended discussions where agents need to retain distinct responsibilities and decisions.

  2. Comparison with informative negative results is extensive. The common-backbone evaluation covers seven benchmarks and ten seeds per condition. Baselines remain stronger on several environments, reset memory wins in nearly all reset/carry comparisons, and the handwritten-versus-generated comparison uses paired, Holm-corrected tests. These findings provide empirical value despite mixed performance.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The novelty argument overstates the distinction from prior work, and the experiments do not isolate the proposed mechanism. The paper argues that prior systems retrieve the same context regardless of role (Section 2). However, G-Memory explicitly filters memories by agent role and task (its Section 4.2 and Equation 8), while Generative Agents maintains individual memory streams (its Section 4.1). The more specific contribution appears to be updating local structured memory after each turn from the agent's own output. This could be useful, but there is no controlled comparison against shared or role-conditioned summaries, nor a direct measurement of role adherence or retention. The handwritten PDDL template also supplies strategies, action patterns, and common mistakes, rather than just a schema (Figure 4). Its advantage may therefore reflect additional domain knowledge. These confounds prevent clear attribution of the gains to the proposed memory design.

  2. The benefits remain uncertain relative to computation and evaluation limitations. The aggregate ranking discards effect sizes and uncertainty. Margins over the best baseline on FEVER and HotpotQA are marginal, at roughly one percentage point. Standard errors across seeds describe repeatability on fixed task sets, so paired task-level intervals would clarify how robust these differences are across benchmark items. Computational costs are also substantial.

Questions for authors
  1. Did the G-Memory rerun preserve its role-conditioned filtering? Can you compare private and shared memory with the same roles, update calls, context budget, and template knowledge? Does the handwritten-template advantage remain when its supplied strategies are removed or given to the controls?

  2. How do the results change under matched total inference budgets? Please clarify "n/i" and account consistently for memory calls and input and completion tokens.

Reviewer_Vz8dOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper maintains a separate structured memory for each agent in a multi-agent discussion. After an agent responds, a prompted LLM update revises its memory, which is prioritized alongside the task and recent conversation in subsequent contexts. The evaluation compares handcrafted, LLM-generated, and generic schemas, with either per-task reset or cross-task carry-forward, against six memory baselines and a no-memory control. Seven benchmarks use ten seeds per condition. A separate data-pipeline design case study is evaluated by an LLM judge.

Critical strengths

The seven-benchmark evaluation is a substantial strength. Using the same backbone and rerunning the baselines is more informative than comparing published numbers from different models. The supplied archive also includes result rows and table-generation scripts. The schema and carry-forward comparisons are useful findings in their own right. Handwritten structure sometimes outperforms automatically generated schemas, and carrying memory forward hurts in most comparisons. Reporting these failures gives a more realistic picture of the method. The task-dependent pattern is worth understanding: the approach is competitive on knowledge reasoning, while shared environment-oriented memory appears more useful on embodied tasks. The conclusion acknowledges this distinction.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The central heterogeneity claim is not isolated. The experiments vary memory schemas and persistence, but do not compare per-agent memories against one shared memory using the same schema, update frequency, and aggregate token budget. A role-agnostic private-memory control would also help. Without these comparisons, additional summarization or handcrafted task guidance could account for the gains. Role adherence and perspective diversity are asserted but not directly measured.
  2. The 'intrinsic' framing is confusing. Section 3.2 explicitly implements memory updating as a separate prompted LLM operation. This is still LLM-based summarization, even if it conditions on an agent's own output and previous memory. The paper needs to specify what information is available to the updater in each experiment. In the supplied benchmark implementation, intrinsicmemory.py formats the update using task_trajectory and current_memory, so the relationship to the output-only formulation in Equation 3 is not transparent.
  3. The strongest overall claim rests on ranks that ignore uncertainty and cost. Table 3 puts the handcrafted variant level with Voyager, but many reward differences are small. Table 5 shows 2.6K task completion tokens plus 10.4K memory tokens on HotpotQA, and 42.0K plus 149.0K on Jericho. Baseline memory-update costs are not separately instrumented. The league table cannot establish an attractive quality–cost tradeoff, especially when the proposed method loses on ALFWorld and SciWorld.
  4. The design case study measures judged descriptions rather than implemented pipelines. Its examples differ noticeably in detail, so verbosity may influence the quality scores. The judge model and a human or executable validation would help. There is also a reporting inconsistency: Table 4 calls usability nonsignificant despite listing p = 0.0093; the text reports its baseline mean as 3.32 while the table gives 3.25.
Questions for authors
  1. What happens when all agents share a memory with the same total capacity and the same updater, or when private memories use a common role-agnostic schema?
  2. Does the updater receive only the speaking agent's output, or the full task trajectory? Please reconcile Equation 3, Figure 7, and the supplied benchmark implementation.
  3. Can you report significance-aware comparisons and complete input/output token costs, identify the case-study judge, and correct the usability statistics?
Reviewer_K41dOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper targets an important problem: memory management in multi-agent LLM systems. With the development of agent swarms and increasing collaboration among agents under strong harness systems, effectively managing memory across agents within a project is becoming increasingly important.

The paper proposes Intrinsic Memory Agents, a straightforward design that combines a shared conversation history with per-agent private memory. Each agent maintains its own structured memory, which is updated based on its outputs and, by default, reset at each task. The authors evaluate the approach on seven benchmarks and a collaborative data pipeline design task, showing improvements in knowledge reasoning and the design case study.

Critical strengths
  • Important and timely problem. As multi-agent collaboration becomes more common, managing shared context while preserving agent-specific information is increasingly important. This paper addresses a practical problem with a clear and intuitive design.

  • Evaluation across multiple settings. The authors evaluate their approach across seven benchmarks and a practical multi-agent design task, covering different types of reasoning and planning workloads.

Critical weaknesses
  • Lack of ablation studies to justify the design choices. The proposed solution is straightforward, but the evaluation treats the entire system as a whole, without isolating the effectiveness of individual components. In particular, there is no direct evidence showing why per-agent private memory is better than a single large shared memory. This makes it difficult to understand which part of the design actually contributes to the improvements.

  • Unclear advantage over existing approaches. The league table in Table 3 does not demonstrate a clear win over existing methods. Although the proposed approach ranks joint first in total points, it can fall significantly behind other methods on individual benchmarks. The aggregate ranking does not necessarily reflect a consistent improvement. In addition, maintaining separate memories introduces extra overhead, and it is unclear whether the performance gains justify this cost.

Questions for authors
  • Is there any evidence showing that, under the same setup and memory budget, a single large shared memory performs worse than the proposed per-agent memory design? This would help justify the main architectural choice.

  • What is the overhead of maintaining and updating per-agent memories? Is there a trade-off between memory quality, update frequency, and overall system latency?

  • How does Intrinsic Memory Agents scale with the number of agents?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.