- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper authors introduced using head similarity to compare the person with the head appearance instead of just face appearace for recognizing a person. Authors argue that there area cases where the face images are occluded or even invisible, also there are some area where the difference are captured at different state, which make the comparison on face not 100% feasible. Authors in this paper introduced 1) a dataset and benchmark for comparing the whole head instead of just face for a new head-level recognition task, and 2) a head level comparison for comparing the head-level losses and patch-level losses for reconstruction and identify the identity in the image. Authors showed that for the head-level identification it is able
Critical strengths
-
The overall method and proposal is simple and easy to follow. Authors introduced a new benchmark/problem, a new dataset and a new method to address the limitation in face recogntion for person (re)identification, which includes other information from hair and other area information to provide supplementary information for recognizing who the person is.
-
Authors have conducted experiments on both the face-based re-id sets as well as the newly-introduced head-level dataset. Authors shown that with more information than jsut the face, along with the new model, they are able to boost the perofmrance of the recognition.
Critical weaknesses
-
We need to numerically distinguish the head-level similarity along with the clothes level info used in the person-(re)identification. From Figure 8, w/ same backgorund, we can clearly see the similar clothes patterns for the same background setting. Authors have provided some good visualization for background changing on the right half of the figure, but such experiment config is not reflected in the numerical results. Instead of just viusalizations and to understand how much improvement it indeed comes from the head recognition instead of the clothes, authors can include 1) heatmap for where the model is looking at, and 2) results comparison for same and different background across the face-centered model and head-centered model to reveal the real gain of the method.
-
The results are pretty interesting as it indeed shows having the whole head as recogntion is able to provide better TAR@FAR x when x is small. The major difference might come from the hair style/color, ability to recognize the person head (or face) better from different view point, etc. Wonder if it is possible for authors to conduct some further ablation to analyze which part has actually contributed to this improvement (since there are mutliple factors taht can contribute to the final performance, as what authors shown in Figure 2).
-
[Minor and discussion] Based on the experiment setting and visualization results (please correct me if it is not correct) it seems the hair color is proviing a strong hint for TAR@FAR x when x is small. In the face recognition scenario, where the face shape are of least changes usually, hair style, color or even the length of the hair can change on a daily base. For such a in-the-wild recognition cases, I am a little bit concern how much we can gain from face recognition.
-
[Minor] For Head Similarity Survey, even being told to ignore the background and clothing, such information is still a strong hint for recognize the two person for area beyond head. It would be great if authors provide these survey with their "different background" setting, or even make the whole background to a same color for conducting such survey comparison.
Questions for authors
Please see above. The overall results are interesting but please provide more analyze for understanding where these improvmeent come from. Also please include more details and description of the dataset (whether their hair style etc changes, how many are of pose difference etc).