- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes IACCL for semi-supervised oriented object detection, introduces Balanced Pseudo-Label (BPL) to adaptively suppress pseudo-labels from dominant classes using classification confidence and localization quality, and Cross Consistency Constraint (CCC) to supervise teacher and student heads using shared pseudo-labels. Experimental studies on DOTA v1.0 and v1.5 evaluate different labeling ratios, component ablations, and sensitivity to key parameters.
Critical strengths
BPL addresses class imbalance using both classification confidence and localization quality, with category-wise analyses supporting its effectiveness. Also, experiments cover two standard benchmarks, multiple annotation budgets, and ablations of the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
Applying shared pseudo-label supervision through two detection heads but does not explicitly minimize a discrepancy between their predictions. Its distinction from auxiliary-head supervision could be clarified. Besides, tHow does CCC differ from standard shared-target auxiliary-head supervision, and what evidence supports the claimed cross-consistency mechanism?
Which competing methods were reproduced under the same detector architecture and evaluation protocol?he main comparisons include different detector architectures and results reported by previous studies. The main tables also do not report variability across random seeds, limiting the assessment of relatively small improvements over competing methods.
Questions for authors
How does CCC differ from standard shared-target auxiliary-head supervision, and what evidence supports the claimed cross-consistency mechanism? Which competing methods were reproduced under the same detector architecture and evaluation protocol?