acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Layer-Informed Fine-Tuning in LLMs: Functional Segmentation and Bottleneck Identification

Abstract

In recent years, the performance of large language models (LLMs) on reasoning tasks has been remarkable, even surpassing human capabilities on various benchmarks. However, there remains a lack of clear understanding in the academic community regarding how the structure and internal parameters of LLMs progressively solve complex reasoning problems. In this study, we investigate the inference process of LLMs on cross-linguistic materials and propose the hypothesis that LLM layers exhibit a structured division of labor across conceptualization, reasoning, and textualization. Based on this hypothesis, we introduce a bottleneck identification mechanism using sensitivity analysis to pinpoint the most critical functional stage for a specific task. Leveraging this insight, we propose a novel approach, Layer-Informed Fine-Tuning (LIFT), which achieves efficient and effective fine-tuning by selectively updating only these functionally critical layers. We then conduct extensive experiments to show that the LIFT method not only accelerates the training process but also significantly improves model performance.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
large language models, selective fine-tuning, layer specialization, functional bottlenecks, reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_yijHOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a three-stage functional segmentation of LLM layers into conceptualization, reasoning, and textualization, with reasoning further divided into active and idle layers. It introduces LIFT, which selectively fine-tunes task-specific critical layers. Experiments on two LLMs and four reasoning benchmarks report competitive accuracy and reduced training time compared with LoRA-based baselines.

Critical strengths

1- The paper connects layer-wise representation analysis with selective fine-tuning, providing an intuitive framework for identifying task-specific critical layers. 2- LIFT achieves competitive or improved accuracy with shorter training times across several reasoning benchmarks, suggesting practical benefits from targeted layer adaptation.

Critical weaknesses

1- Cross-lingual cosine similarity and adjacent-layer similarity provide indirect evidence, but do not establish that the identified layers actually perform conceptualization, reasoning, or textualization (Sec 4). 2- The experiments cover only two 7–8B models and four benchmarks. Moreover, the reported training-time savings exclude the potentially substantial cost of functional segmentation and quantization-based bottleneck identification (Table 2).

Questions for authors

1- What evidence distinguishes the proposed functional stages from general patterns of representation similarity or layer redundancy? 2- What is the total computational overhead of segmentation and quantization sensitivity analysis, and how many fine-tuning runs are needed to amortize this cost? 3- Does LIFT outperform random or uniformly spaced layer selection under identical trainable-parameter budgets? 4- Why does LIFT underperform AdaLoRA and the original model on Qwen2 GSM8K (Table 2), despite identifying the active reasoning layers as critical?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer yijH (Part 1/2): Functional evidence and overhead

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback. We address the functional interpretation, total diagnostic cost, layer-selection controls and the Qwen2/GSM8K result below.

1. Functional stages and task-level evidence (Q1)

Figure 2 compares translations of the same question with different questions in the same language. Same-question representations converge in middle layers and separate near the output, while different questions show an approximately opposite pattern. This contrast appears across two models, five languages and four datasets, with 1,000 pairs per curve. PCA, t-SNE and UMAP show the same overall structure (Section 4.1).

This pattern suggests a progression from language-specific inputs to shared representations and then output language. Wendler et al. (ACL 2024) describe a related input-concept-output progression, while Lad et al. (NeurIPS 2025) find depth-dependent behavior through layer deletion and swapping.

Within reasoning, we identify an idle region as a consecutive block whose adjacent-layer cosine similarity exceeds β=0.94\beta=0.94 (Section 5.1). This follows layer-redundancy research: ShortGPT (Men et al., Findings of ACL 2025) tests cosine-based rankings through layer removal, and Gromov et al. (ICLR 2025) use similarity to select blocks for pruning.

We also examine task behavior through the Drop/Recovery interventions in submission Table 1. Drop quantizes a selected block to simulated INT4 while keeping the rest in BF16; Recovery preserves it in BF16 and quantizes the rest. For Llama-3, quantizing the active block causes greater damage than quantizing the idle block on all four tasks, and preserving it gives higher Recovery accuracy on the three logical tasks. These interventions, together with matched-budget fine-tuning results in Part 2, test the hypothesis beyond representational similarities alone.

2. Diagnostic overhead and amortization (Q2; weakness 2)

Submission Table 2 reports shorter training time in all eight settings, averaging an 11.4% reduction relative to all-layer LoRA (FullFT); for example, Llama-3/GSM8K takes 2,667 s instead of 3,347 s.

Fine-tuning processes the full training set for multiple epochs, while diagnosis is a one-time procedure using capped subsets: 1,000 similarity pairs per curve, 128 AWQ calibration examples and at most 1,000 ranking examples. Boundaries are computed from the collected curves. With a fixed model-task setup, this budget does not grow with the adaptation data size and the diagnosis can be reused over repeated runs.

Thus, diagnostic cost can be amortized over larger workloads or repeated adaptations. The 11.4% figure concerns measured training time only; we have not reported a measured end-to-end break-even number of runs.

References


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer yijH (Part 2/2): Layer selection and scope

3. Matched-budget layer selection (Q3)

We compare LIFT with Random-kk under identical trainable-parameter budgets and include Last-kk as a contiguous-layer control. All methods use the same adapted-layer count, LoRA configuration, optimizer, training data and epochs.

Table Y1. Matched-budget layer selection on the eight original settings.

ModelTaskkkLIFTLast-kkRandom-kk
Llama-3FOLIO1858.21 ± 2.3554.90 ± 1.3355.79 ± 0.87
Llama-3Logical2053.58 ± 2.4747.50 ± 1.0452.58 ± 0.73
Llama-3ProofWriter1857.67 ± 0.3648.17 ± 0.6251.37 ± 2.77
Llama-3GSM8K273.96 ± 0.9856.60 ± 0.3566.12 ± 1.27
Qwen2FOLIO2344.73 ± 1.9842.28 ± 1.2943.90 ± 0.74
Qwen2Logical2157.08 ± 3.2959.00 ± 1.8754.96 ± 0.73
Qwen2ProofWriter2353.46 ± 2.3646.62 ± 0.2847.67 ± 2.77
Qwen2GSM8K2375.78 ± 0.2475.53 ± 0.2975.32 ± 0.30
Macro average——59.3153.8355.96

Test accuracy (%), mean ± standard deviation over four fine-tuning seeds. Random-kk samples subsets; Last-kk selects the final contiguous block. Uniformly spaced selection was not evaluated. Logical = LogicalDeduction.

LIFT has higher mean accuracy than Random-kk in all eight settings and Last-kk in seven. On Llama-3/GSM8K, the two diagnosed early layers reach 73.96%, versus 66.12% for Random-2 and 56.60% for Last-2. These comparisons show that layer location matters even at the same parameter budget.

4. Accuracy variation on Qwen2/GSM8K (Q4)

Submission Table 2 reports means and standard deviations over four seeds. On Qwen2/GSM8K, LIFT reaches 75.78%, below the original model (78.85%) and AdaLoRA (77.50%), but above all-layer LoRA (74.53%), while reducing training time from 3,500 s to 3,208 s. We regard this as an improvement over all-layer adaptation, not a claim of universal superiority.

5. Model scale and diagnostic scope (weakness 2)

We agree that evaluation on substantially larger models would better establish the scope of LIFT. Our available computational resources did not allow us to add these experiments during the rebuttal period.

As discussed in Part 1, the 11.4% average training-time reduction excludes one-time segmentation and bottleneck diagnosis. The capped diagnostic budget can be reused in the same model-task setting and amortized over repeated adaptation runs. We therefore present the measured savings as training-stage efficiency, rather than an end-to-end speedup claim.

Dear Reviewer,

As the author–reviewer discussion deadline approaches, I would like to remind you to review the authors’ rebuttal and indicate whether your concerns have been adequately addressed.

If you have any remaining concerns or questions, please share them with the authors before the discussion period ends.

Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback.

Thank the authors for their responses. Based on the discussions, I would like to keep my rating.

Reviewer_jGnjOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Layer-Informed Fine-Tuning (LIFT), based on the hypothesis that LLM layers serve different functions: conceptualization, reasoning, and textualization. The authors use cross-lingual hidden-state similarity to identify functional boundaries and quantization sensitivity to locate task-specific bottlenecks. LoRA is then applied only to the selected layers. Experiments on Llama-3-8B-Instruct and Qwen2-7B-Instruct across four reasoning benchmarks show promising results in accuracy and training efficiency.

Critical strengths
  1. Interesting motivation. I like the idea of connecting layer-wise functional analysis with fine-tuning. Rather than simply studying hidden representations, the paper uses these observations to guide parameter updates.
  2. Reasonably comprehensive analysis. The authors examine two model families, five languages, and four reasoning datasets. The additional quantization experiments and layer-wise ablations provide useful evidence for the proposed approach.
  3. Promising empirical results. LIFT achieves noticeable improvements on some benchmarks. For example, on Llama-3 GSM8K, it improves accuracy from 67.76% to 73.96% compared with FullFT while reducing training time from 3347s to 2667s (Table 2).
Critical weaknesses
  1. The functional interpretation needs stronger evidence. The three-stage hypothesis is mainly supported by cosine similarity and visualization results (Section 4). However, these patterns do not necessarily establish that particular layers perform conceptualization, reasoning, or textualization. Similarly, high adjacent-layer similarity alone may not be sufficient to classify layers as idle.
  2. Layer group sizes may affect bottleneck identification. The functional blocks have substantially different numbers of layers. For example, Qwen2's active reasoning block contains 23 layers on ProofWriter, compared with only 3 conceptualization layers and 2 textualization layers (Table 5). Quantizing a much larger block could naturally produce a larger performance drop. A comparison with equally sized layer groups would make the bottleneck analysis more convincing.
  3. The overall efficiency gains are unclear. Table 2 reports fine-tuning time, but the cost of functional segmentation and quantization-based bottleneck identification is not included. Since the reported average training-time reduction is 11.4%, it is unclear whether LIFT remains more efficient when these additional steps are considered.
  4. The performance gains are not consistent. On Qwen2 GSM8K, LIFT achieves 75.78% accuracy, below both the original model (78.85%) and AdaLoRA (77.50%). Some other improvements over FullFT are also quite small, such as 53.46% versus 53.17% on Qwen2 ProofWriter (Table 2). This makes the claimed effectiveness less convincing across different tasks.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors compare LIFT with random layer selection, fixed contiguous layer selection, and sensitivity-only selection under the same trainable parameter budget? This would help clarify whether the improvement comes from the proposed functional segmentation rather than simply selecting fewer layers.
  2. How sensitive is LIFT to the layer partitioning strategy, particularly the threshold β = 0.94? It would be useful to evaluate different thresholds and examine whether the identified bottleneck layers consistently achieve better fine-tuning results.
  3. Could the authors provide an end-to-end efficiency comparison that includes the cost of functional segmentation and quantization-based sensitivity analysis? The current results mainly report fine-tuning time, making it difficult to assess the overall computational savings.
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer jGnj (Part 1/3): Functional interpretation and block size

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback. We address the functional interpretation, possible block-size confounding, and the requested matched-budget controls and efficiency accounting below.

1. Functional interpretation and the idle region (weakness 1)

Figure 2 compares translations of the same question with different questions in the same language. Same-question representations converge in middle layers and separate near the output, while different questions show an approximately opposite trend. This contrast appears across two models, five languages and four datasets, with 1,000 pairs per curve. PCA, t-SNE and UMAP show the same overall structure (Section 4.1).

The pattern suggests a progression from language-specific inputs to shared representations and then output language. Wendler et al. (ACL 2024) describe a related input-concept-output progression, while Lad et al. (NeurIPS 2025) find depth-dependent behavior through layer deletion and swapping.

Within the reasoning stage, we identify an idle region as a consecutive block whose adjacent-layer cosine similarity exceeds β=0.94\beta=0.94 (Section 5.1). This follows prior layer-redundancy research: ShortGPT (Men et al., Findings of ACL 2025) evaluates input-output cosine through layer-removal experiments, and Gromov et al. (ICLR 2025) use representation similarity to select blocks for pruning.

We also test this distinction through downstream behavior. In submission Table 1, Drop quantizes the selected block to simulated INT4 while keeping the rest in BF16, while Recovery preserves it in BF16 and quantizes the rest. For Llama-3, quantizing the active block causes greater damage than quantizing the idle block on all four tasks; preserving the active block yields higher Recovery accuracy on the three logical tasks. Together with the matched-budget fine-tuning results in Part 2, these interventions test the hypothesis beyond representation similarity alone.

2. Unequal block sizes and bottleneck identification (weakness 2)

Block size alone cannot explain the selected bottleneck. On Llama-3/GSM8K, the conceptualization block [0,2)[0,2) has only two layers, whereas the active reasoning block [2,22)[2,22) has twenty (submission Table 4). If the diagnostic were driven solely by block size, the twenty-layer block should rank above the two-layer block. The opposite occurs: the conceptualization block has a Recovery-minus-Drop score of 63.43−60.30=3.1363.43-60.30=3.13, compared with 60.94−58.95=1.9960.94-58.95=1.99 for active reasoning (submission Table 1). LIFT therefore selects the much smaller conceptualization block.

We additionally evaluate single-layer quantization sensitivity. Across four model-task settings, mean per-layer sensitivity is higher inside LIFT's selected block than outside. Part 2 then tests whether the selected layers are useful to adapt while holding the trainable-parameter budget fixed.

References


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer jGnj (Part 2/3): Matched-budget controls

3. Matched-budget and sensitivity-only controls (Q1)

We compare LIFT with Random-kk and Last-kk, matching the adapted-layer count, LoRA configuration, optimizer, training data and epochs. The trainable-parameter budget is fixed; only the chosen layer locations change.

Table J1. Matched-budget layer selection on all eight original settings.

ModelTaskkkLIFTLast-kkRandom-kk
Llama-3FOLIO1858.21 ± 2.3554.90 ± 1.3355.79 ± 0.87
Llama-3Logical2053.58 ± 2.4747.50 ± 1.0452.58 ± 0.73
Llama-3ProofWriter1857.67 ± 0.3648.17 ± 0.6251.37 ± 2.77
Llama-3GSM8K273.96 ± 0.9856.60 ± 0.3566.12 ± 1.27
Qwen2FOLIO2344.73 ± 1.9842.28 ± 1.2943.90 ± 0.74
Qwen2Logical2157.08 ± 3.2959.00 ± 1.8754.96 ± 0.73
Qwen2ProofWriter2353.46 ± 2.3646.62 ± 0.2847.67 ± 2.77
Qwen2GSM8K2375.78 ± 0.2475.53 ± 0.2975.32 ± 0.30
Macro average——59.3153.8355.96

Test accuracy (%), mean ± standard deviation over four fine-tuning seeds. Random-kk selects a subset; Last-kk selects the final contiguous block of kk layers. Logical = LogicalDeduction.

LIFT has higher mean accuracy than Random-kk in all eight settings and Last-kk in seven. On Llama-3/GSM8K, just two diagnosed early layers reach 73.96%, compared with 66.12% for Random-2 and 56.60% for Last-2.

For a sensitivity-only control, we rank each layer by its mean Recovery-minus-Drop score over four paired simulated-INT4 diagnostic seeds. Sensitivity Top-kk adapts the top kk layers with the same parameter budget and training configuration.

Table J2. Independent per-layer Sensitivity Top-kk versus LIFT.

ModelTaskkkSensitivity Top-kkLIFT
Llama-3ProofWriter1850.59 ± 1.4457.67 ± 0.36
Llama-3GSM8K258.82 ± 0.8073.96 ± 0.98
Qwen2ProofWriter2354.38 ± 1.4353.46 ± 2.36
Qwen2GSM8K2375.43 ± 0.2675.78 ± 0.24
Macro average——59.8065.22

Test accuracy (%), mean ± standard deviation over four fine-tuning seeds; layer scores use four paired diagnostic seeds. Adapter budgets and training configurations are matched.

LIFT has higher mean accuracy in three of four settings, with a macro average of 65.22% versus 59.80%. These controls support task-dependent block selection over the tested random, fixed-position and independent-sensitivity strategies. Uniformly spaced selection was not separately evaluated.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer jGnj (Part 3/3): Threshold, efficiency, and accuracy

4. Threshold choice and boundary stability (Q2)

We use β=0.94\beta=0.94 to identify the high-similarity plateau near 0.95 in Figure 3. Repeating boundary detection at 0.93 and 0.95 shifts the threshold-dependent boundaries by only 0.63 or 0.75 layers on average across the eight original settings.

Table J3. Threshold sensitivity and a complete boundary example.

β\betaMean shift (layers)ConceptualizationActiveIdleTextualization
0.930.63[0,2)[0,2)[2,19)[2,19)[19,30)[19,30)[30,32)[30,32)
0.940.00[0,2)[0,2)[2,20)[2,20)[20,30)[20,30)[30,32)[30,32)
0.950.75[0,2)[0,2)[2,21)[2,21)[21,30)[21,30)[30,32)[30,32)

Mean shift covers both threshold-dependent boundaries across eight settings; the displayed partitions are for Llama-3/FOLIO. In this example, only the active-idle boundary moves, by one layer. The procedure also allows no idle block when the plateau is absent, as in Qwen2/ProofWriter (Appendix E). The downstream results use β=0.94\beta=0.94.

5. Training efficiency and diagnostic overhead (Q3; weakness 3)

Submission Table 2 reports shorter training time in all eight settings, averaging an 11.4% reduction relative to all-layer LoRA (FullFT). For example, Llama-3/GSM8K takes 2,667 s instead of 3,347 s.

Fine-tuning processes the full training set over multiple epochs, whereas diagnosis runs once on capped subsets: 1,000 similarity pairs per curve, 128 AWQ calibration examples and at most 1,000 ranking examples. Boundary computation uses the collected curves. With a fixed model and diagnostic configuration, these budgets do not grow with training-set size, and diagnosis can be reused for multiple adaptations of the same model-task setup.

The one-time diagnostic cost can thus be amortized over larger workloads or repeated runs. The reported 11.4% improvement measures training time, not end-to-end time including diagnosis. We distinguish these quantities rather than treating them as interchangeable.

6. Accuracy variation and Qwen2/GSM8K (weakness 4)

Results can vary across fine-tuning seeds and stochastic generation. Submission Table 2 therefore reports mean accuracy and standard deviation over four seeds. Across eight settings, LIFT has higher mean accuracy than all-layer LoRA in seven and shorter training time in all eight.

On Qwen2/GSM8K, LIFT reaches 75.78%, below the original model (78.85%) and AdaLoRA (77.50%) as the reviewer notes, but above all-layer LoRA (74.53%) while reducing training time from 3,500 s to 3,208 s. We do not claim LIFT wins against every method in every setting. The evidence supports a more specific conclusion: task-dependent layer selection often improves the accuracy–training-time tradeoff compared with adapting all layers, while some tasks remain challenging.


Dear Reviewer,

As the author–reviewer discussion deadline approaches, I would like to remind you to review the authors’ rebuttal and indicate whether your concerns have been adequately addressed.

If you have any remaining concerns or questions, please share them with the authors before the discussion period ends.

Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback.

Reviewer_p3ySOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a Three-Stage Functional Segmentation hypothesis, according to which transformer layers can be grouped into conceptualization, reasoning, and textualization stages, with the reasoning stage further divided into active and idle layers. The authors estimate stage boundaries using hidden-state similarity patterns and identify a task-specific bottleneck through quantization-based sensitivity analysis. They then introduce Layer-Informed Fine-Tuning (LIFT), which selectively updates the layers associated with the identified bottleneck rather than fine-tuning the full model. The paper evaluates this approach on several tasks and compares it with parameter-efficient baselines, including a parameter-budget-matched AdaLoRA configuration. The central claim is that targeting functionally critical layers can improve both training efficiency and downstream performance.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important efficiency question. Selectively updating a subset of model layers could reduce adaptation cost and provide an alternative to uniformly distributed parameter-efficient updates.
  2. The method attempts to make layer selection task-dependent. Rather than assuming the same layers are always best, LIFT combines boundary detection with task-specific sensitivity analysis. This is potentially useful if the diagnostics are reliable.
  3. The paper connects interpretability analysis to an actionable fine-tuning procedure. The proposed segmentation is used to decide which parameters to update, giving the hypothesis a concrete experimental consequence.
  4. The parameter-budget-matched AdaLoRA baseline is helpful. Matching trainable-parameter budgets is important for determining whether gains arise from functional layer selection rather than simply allocating more parameters.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence for a three-stage functional segmentation is not sufficiently convincing. Hidden-state cosine similarity and logit-lens-style observations can reveal representational changes, but do not by themselves establish that contiguous layers have distinct causal roles corresponding to conceptualization, reasoning, and textualization. The illustrative examples appear insufficient to support the broad functional interpretation.
  2. The definition of “idle reasoning layers” is ambiguous. High adjacent-layer similarity does not necessarily mean a layer is idle or contributes little computation. A layer may preserve a representation while performing a necessary transformation not captured by cosine similarity. Causal interventions, such as ablating or bypassing identified layers, are needed to validate this label.
  3. Quantization sensitivity may be an imperfect proxy for a task's functional bottleneck. Sensitivity to quantization can reflect numerical scale, activation distribution, normalization, or parameter redundancy rather than semantic function. The paper needs stronger evidence that the sensitivity measure identifies layers whose adaptation is most useful.
  4. The causal link between segmentation and LIFT's gains remains unclear. Improved fine-tuning results do not necessarily validate the three-stage hypothesis. Gains could arise from the generic regularization effect of updating fewer layers or from favorable allocation of trainable parameters. Matched random-layer, contiguous-layer, top-gradient, and conventional PEFT controls would isolate the claimed mechanism.
  5. The methodology may be sensitive to architecture, task, and hyperparameters. Layer boundaries and active/idle proportions may vary with model depth, pretraining, language, and task complexity. The paper should report stability across seeds, prompts, datasets, and model families.
  6. Efficiency claims require a fuller accounting. The diagnostic pipeline—hidden-state extraction, similarity analysis, and quantization-sensitivity evaluation—has computational cost. The single-A40 setup is reproducible, but total pipeline time and memory should be compared with standard fine-tuning and PEFT, not just the final fine-tuning stage.
  7. Representational similarity is conflated with functional specialization. Cross-lingual inputs producing similar intermediate representations and different final outputs may be compatible with a shared latent representation, but do not uniquely imply the proposed stage boundaries. Alternative explanations should be considered.1. The evidence for a three-stage functional segmentation is not sufficiently convincing. Hidden-state cosine similarity and logit-lens-style observations can reveal representational changes, but do not by themselves establish that contiguous layers have distinct causal roles corresponding to conceptualization, reasoning, and textualization. The illustrative examples appear insufficient to support the broad functional interpretation.
  8. The definition of “idle reasoning layers” is ambiguous. High adjacent-layer similarity does not necessarily mean a layer is idle or contributes little computation. A layer may preserve a representation while performing a necessary transformation not captured by cosine similarity. Causal interventions, such as ablating or bypassing identified layers, are needed to validate this label.
  9. Quantization sensitivity may be an imperfect proxy for a task's functional bottleneck. Sensitivity to quantization can reflect numerical scale, activation distribution, normalization, or parameter redundancy rather than semantic function. The paper needs stronger evidence that the sensitivity measure identifies layers whose adaptation is most useful.
  10. The causal link between segmentation and LIFT's gains remains unclear. Improved fine-tuning results do not necessarily validate the three-stage hypothesis. Gains could arise from the generic regularization effect of updating fewer layers or from favorable allocation of trainable parameters. Matched random-layer, contiguous-layer, top-gradient, and conventional PEFT controls would isolate the claimed mechanism.
  11. The methodology may be sensitive to architecture, task, and hyperparameters. Layer boundaries and active/idle proportions may vary with model depth, pretraining, language, and task complexity. The paper should report stability across seeds, prompts, datasets, and model families.
  12. Efficiency claims require a fuller accounting. The diagnostic pipeline—hidden-state extraction, similarity analysis, and quantization-sensitivity evaluation—has computational cost. The single-A40 setup is reproducible, but total pipeline time and memory should be compared with standard fine-tuning and PEFT, not just the final fine-tuning stage.
  13. Representational similarity is conflated with functional specialization. Cross-lingual inputs producing similar intermediate representations and different final outputs may be compatible with a shared latent representation, but do not uniquely imply the proposed stage boundaries. Alternative explanations should be considered.
Questions for authors
  1. Can you validate the proposed boundaries using causal interventions or layer ablations, rather than similarity curves alone?
  2. What operational criterion defines an “idle” layer, and does removing or freezing such a layer preserve performance across tasks and model families?
  3. How robust are identified bottleneck layers to random seeds, prompt variation, dataset shifts, and changes in architecture?
  4. How does LIFT compare with matched random contiguous layers, top-gradient layers, last-k layers, and parameter-budget-matched LoRA/AdaLoRA under the same compute budget?
  5. Does quantization sensitivity correlate with the marginal performance gain from fine-tuning a layer? Can you provide a direct correlation or intervention study?
  6. What is the total overhead of locating boundaries and diagnosing the bottleneck, and how does end-to-end cost compare with ordinary PEFT?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer p3yS (Part 1/3): Functional stages and idle-region evidence

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback. We noticed that the seven concerns in the Critical Weaknesses section are repeated verbatim. We address each distinct concern once below and would appreciate it if the duplicated text could be corrected and the paper reassessed in light of our clarifications and additional evidence.

1. Evidence for the functional stages (Q1; weaknesses 1 and 7)

We supplement the similarity analysis with task interventions: Table 1 of the submission tests the effect of quantizing or preserving each identified region, while the matched-budget experiments in Part 2 test which regions are most useful to fine-tune.

Figure 2 compares translations of the same question with unrelated questions in the same language, across two models, five languages and four datasets (1,000 pairs per curve). Same-question representations converge in middle layers and separate near the output; unrelated questions show an approximately opposite trend. PCA, t-SNE and UMAP show the same overall structure (Section 4.1 and the appendix).

This contrast motivates a progression from language-specific inputs to shared representations and then output language. Wendler et al. (ACL 2024) describe a related input-concept-output structure, while Lad et al. (NeurIPS 2025) find depth-dependent behavior through layer deletion and swapping. Together, these analyses and our task interventions provide complementary evidence for the functional-segmentation hypothesis.

2. Evidence for the idle-region indicator (Q2)

We operationally define an idle region as a consecutive block of reasoning layers whose adjacent-layer cosine similarity exceeds β=0.94\beta=0.94 (Section 5.1). Figure 3 shows this plateau for Llama-3/GSM8K. When no plateau exceeds the threshold, we do not assign an idle block, as in Qwen2/ProofWriter (Appendix E). This criterion draws on layer-redundancy studies: ShortGPT (Men et al., Findings of ACL 2025) evaluates cosine-based rankings through layer removal, and Gromov et al. (ICLR 2025) use representation similarity to select contiguous blocks for pruning.

To test whether this distinction matters for downstream behavior, we apply two quantization interventions. Drop quantizes the selected block to simulated INT4 while keeping the rest in BF16; Recovery preserves the selected block in BF16 while quantizing the rest. Table P1 compares the active and idle blocks on all four tasks.

Table P1. Task-level Drop/Recovery comparison of active and idle blocks in Llama-3.

TaskDrop: activeDrop: idleRecovery: activeRecovery: idle
ProofWriter42.44 ± 1.7044.95 ± 1.5443.99 ± 1.5142.61 ± 1.82
FOLIO51.33 ± 0.8352.80 ± 1.3653.46 ± 0.9751.20 ± 0.68
Logical43.18 ± 1.4548.86 ± 1.4347.55 ± 0.7743.26 ± 1.41
GSM8K58.95 ± 2.4861.96 ± 1.0060.94 ± 1.5362.16 ± 2.57

Diagnostic-subset accuracy (%), mean ± standard deviation over eight seeds; submission Table 1. Lower Drop accuracy indicates greater damage; higher Recovery accuracy indicates greater restoration. These are whole-block comparisons.

Quantizing the active block causes more damage on all four tasks; preserving it yields higher Recovery accuracy on the three logical tasks. These interventions support using high similarity as an indicator of lower task sensitivity, without equating representational similarity with the absence of computation.

References


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer p3yS (Part 2/3): Robustness and matched-budget selection

3. Robustness of bottleneck identification (Q3)

Seed-averaged diagnosis. We average each candidate block's Recovery-minus-Drop score over eight diagnostic seeds and select the block with the largest mean. The four fine-tuning seeds used for downstream evaluation are separate (submission Table 1 and Appendix G).

Threshold stability. Changing β\beta from 0.94 to 0.93 or 0.95 moves the threshold-dependent boundaries by only 0.63 or 0.75 layers on average across the eight original settings.

Table P2. Threshold sensitivity and a complete boundary example.

β\betaMean shift (layers)ConceptualizationActiveIdleTextualization
0.930.63[0,2)[0,2)[2,19)[2,19)[19,30)[19,30)[30,32)[30,32)
0.940.00[0,2)[0,2)[2,20)[2,20)[20,30)[20,30)[30,32)[30,32)
0.950.75[0,2)[0,2)[2,21)[2,21)[21,30)[21,30)[30,32)[30,32)

Mean shift covers both threshold-dependent boundaries across eight settings. The displayed partitions are for Llama-3/FOLIO.

Model- and task-specific selection. We diagnose each model-task pair separately rather than assuming fixed bottleneck indices. On GSM8K, the method selects conceptualization layers [0,2)[0,2) in Llama-3 but active reasoning layers [3,26)[3,26) in Qwen2. This illustrates why task-specific selection is necessary. Prompt variation and distribution shifts were not separately tested.

4. Matched-budget layer selection and PEFT (Q4)

Random-kk and Last-kk match LIFT's adapted-layer count, LoRA rank, optimizer, training data and epochs. AdaLoRA matches LIFT's target trainable-parameter budget. Table P3 covers all eight original settings.

Table P3. Matched-budget layer-selection and AdaLoRA comparisons.

ModelTaskkkLIFTRandom-kkLast-kkAdaLoRA
Llama-3FOLIO1858.21 ± 2.3555.79 ± 0.8754.90 ± 1.3357.11 ± 2.21
Llama-3Logical2053.58 ± 2.4752.58 ± 0.7347.50 ± 1.0449.42 ± 2.27
Llama-3ProofWriter1857.67 ± 0.3651.37 ± 2.7748.17 ± 0.6247.83 ± 0.49
Llama-3GSM8K273.96 ± 0.9866.12 ± 1.2756.60 ± 0.3572.35 ± 1.07
Qwen2FOLIO2344.73 ± 1.9843.90 ± 0.7442.28 ± 1.2918.01 ± 1.57
Qwen2Logical2157.08 ± 3.2954.96 ± 0.7359.00 ± 1.8751.42 ± 1.17
Qwen2ProofWriter2353.46 ± 2.3647.67 ± 2.7746.62 ± 0.2848.25 ± 1.68
Qwen2GSM8K2375.78 ± 0.2475.32 ± 0.3075.53 ± 0.2977.50 ± 0.41
Macro average——59.3155.9653.8352.74

Test accuracy (%), mean ± standard deviation over four fine-tuning seeds. kk is the adapted-layer count. Random-kk samples a subset; Last-kk selects the final contiguous block; AdaLoRA matches the target parameter budget. Logical = LogicalDeduction.

LIFT has higher mean accuracy than Random-kk in all eight settings, Last-kk in seven and AdaLoRA in seven. On Llama-3/GSM8K, adapting the two diagnosed early layers reaches 73.96%, compared with 66.12% for Random-2 and 56.60% for Last-2. The location of updates therefore matters even when the parameter budget is fixed.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer p3yS (Part 3/3): Sensitivity and computational cost

5. Quantization sensitivity and adaptation (Q5)

Fine-tuning every individual layer separately was not feasible within the rebuttal period. We instead evaluated a parameter-budget-matched alternative: rank layers independently by quantization sensitivity, fine-tune the top kk, and compare downstream accuracy with LIFT.

We first quantized each layer separately with simulated INT4 and averaged its Recovery-minus-Drop score over four paired diagnostic seeds. Mean per-layer sensitivity is higher inside LIFT's selected block than outside in all four settings, and 50 of 66 Top-kk layer instances fall inside LIFT blocks.

Table P4. Overlap between independent sensitivity ranking and LIFT's block.

ModelTaskLIFT blockTop-kk layers inside
Llama-3ProofWriter[2,20)[2,20)12 / 18
Llama-3GSM8K[0,2)[0,2)0 / 2
Qwen2ProofWriter[3,26)[3,26)19 / 23
Qwen2GSM8K[3,26)[3,26)19 / 23

We then fine-tuned those top kk layers using the same adapted-layer count, LoRA configuration, optimizer and four fine-tuning seeds as LIFT.

Table P5. Sensitivity Top-kk versus LIFT.

ModelTaskkkSensitivity Top-kkLIFT
Llama-3ProofWriter1850.59 ± 1.4457.67 ± 0.36
Llama-3GSM8K258.82 ± 0.8073.96 ± 0.98
Qwen2ProofWriter2354.38 ± 1.4353.46 ± 2.36
Qwen2GSM8K2375.43 ± 0.2675.78 ± 0.24
Macro average——59.8065.22

Test accuracy (%), mean ± standard deviation over four fine-tuning seeds; layer scores use four paired diagnostic seeds. Adapter budgets and training configurations are matched.

LIFT achieves higher mean accuracy in three of four settings. In particular, on Llama-3/GSM8K, Top-kk selects layers 7 and 11 and reaches 58.82%, whereas LIFT selects layers 0 and 1 and reaches 73.96%. Thus, independently ranking layers by quantization sensitivity does not fully reproduce the value of the diagnosed functional block.

6. Training time and diagnostic cost (Q6)

Submission Table 2 reports shorter training time in all eight settings, averaging an 11.4% reduction relative to all-layer LoRA (FullFT). For instance, Llama-3/GSM8K takes 2,667 s rather than 3,347 s.

Fine-tuning processes the full training set over multiple epochs, whereas diagnosis runs once on capped subsets: 1,000 similarity pairs per curve, 128 AWQ calibration examples and at most 1,000 ranking examples. Boundaries are computed from the collected curves. For a fixed model-task diagnostic configuration, these costs do not grow with training-set size, and the diagnosis can be reused across repeated fine-tuning runs.

We therefore distinguish measured recurring training savings from one-time diagnostic overhead. The latter can be amortized over larger workloads or repeated runs; we do not claim that Table 2 directly measures end-to-end savings including diagnosis.


Dear Reviewer,

As the author–reviewer discussion deadline approaches, I would like to remind you to review the authors’ rebuttal and indicate whether your concerns have been adequately addressed.

If you have any remaining concerns or questions, please share them with the authors before the discussion period ends.

Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.