- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Some of the current methods for learning DAGs over clustered groups of variables need the variable clusters to be specified a priori. This partition must be admissible, meaning no cycles should exist between the variable groups. Specifying such a partition can be quite challenging; for instance, in the context of gene regulatory networks, feedback loops are common between genes.
The authors present GO4CD, a method for obtaining partitions over genes that (a) is based on biological knowledge, namely Gene Ontology Biological Processes, and (b) shold in principle lead to partition that are likely to be admissible.
The authors couple GO4CD with the causal discovery algorithm CLOC, which can provably reconstruct the DAG over clustered variables under specific assumptions. Quantitative analysis on simulated gene expression data provide evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
The GO4CD algorithm is a straigthfoward solution for the complex problem of identifying functional modules in gene regulatory networks. This type of modelling is useful and relevant, as it can lead to more intepretable models for the biological machinery underlying the cell operation.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern relates to the actual interpretability of the produced partitions. Table 1 indicates that most of the genes congregates in a single giant cluster, while the remaining genes mostly remain as singletons. A second concern is the absence of evaluation on actual gene expression data. The authors retrieve E coli known regulatory structures from Regulon DB, however no transcriptomics data from E. coli experiments are used. Thus, it is not really possible to evaluate how GO4CD would perform in a real study.
Questions for authors
I would like the author to answer my concerns described above. In particular:
- Can they elaborate on how a useful biological interpretation can be obtained when most of the genes are grouped in a single cluster? It would be interesting if the authors could apply GO4CD to Human Gene Ontology Biological Processes, and characterize the clusters obtained at different resolutions. Would you obtain a more or less balanced partition depending on the chosen resolution? Under which conditions Biological Processes grouped in the same cluster would actually form a meaningful regulatory module?
- While I realize that time constraints might be tight, I nevertheless trongly encourage the author to retrieve and analyze E coli actual gene expression data for their analysis on the E coli regulatory network