- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes to progressively tilt discrete diffusion models, motivating their annealing framing as a way to extrapolate towards rewards that steer the model substantially away from the base model. The basic annealing framing aligns closely with Chen et al. 2026 and Wan et al 2026. In each annealing iteration, the authors learn an approximate conditional soft value from rollouts of the current model and then distill this approximation to a further tilted version of the denoiser. A critical part of the approach is the conditional soft value estimation analogously to any other steering technique. Empirical comparisons do not include the most similar methods.
Critical strengths
The approach seems technically clear and well-executed, a combination of ideas from the literature. The algorithms and steps are clearly described.
Critical weaknesses
Theoretical results are clarifying but do not support the annealing approach nor the extrapolation motivation. For example, the bounds blow up with additional annealing steps counter to the motivation that it is helpful to progressively approach the desired tilt. This seems like a consequence of the theoretical approach that relies on bounded errors of each fitting step. The extrapolation to "low density" regions is essentially assumed away by uniform bounds. That said, the method itself aligns well with the motivation even if it is not directly supported by the theory.
Proposition 3.1 is a direct restatement of (9) so perhaps worth restating it as a derivation of the denoising target rather than as a stand alone theoretical "result".
Perhaps the main deficiency of the paper is that there are no comparisons to the most similar approaches (DTM or DGM).
Questions for authors
In section 3, the distilling target is evaluated on re-noised samples from the current model. Since the current model is used to sample clean x_0 in any case, why not use the trajectories from the model also as points where to evaluate the loss? Aren't those exactly the x_t's where the additional tilt corrections would matter? I understand the argument for re-noising but not why the generated trajectories are discarded.
What is the rollout sample efficiency of learning the conditional soft value or the distillation step to any prescribed accuracy? These are the key recurring heavy steps. Theorem 5.1 also relies on these accuracies.
The reward bound directly controls the iteration blowup but appears appropriately as product delta_j B_r in theorem 5.1 suggesting that finer annealing steps might carry some benefit. Further analysis of this effect would be helpful.
4 comments
Q3: Effect of the tilting increments in Theorem 5.1
W1: Theoretical results are clarifying but do not support the annealing approach nor the extrapolation motivation. For example, the bounds blow up with additional annealing steps counter to the motivation that it is helpful to progressively approach the desired tilt. This seems like a consequence of the theoretical approach that relies on bounded errors of each fitting step. The extrapolation to "low density" regions is essentially assumed away by uniform bounds. That said, the method itself aligns well with the motivation even if it is not directly supported by the theory.
We thank the reviewer for this insightful observation. We agree that the annealing step size involves a trade-off between the error introduced by each tilt update and the accumulation of approximation errors over multiple iterations.
As indicated by Theorem 5.1, the reward-dependent contributions to the one-step error recursion involve factors such as , , and . Thus, reducing the annealing increments decreases these contributions, particularly the term proportional to .
On the other hand, finer annealing requires more iterations, and the model-fitting and critic-fitting errors accumulate across these iterations. Moreover, the multiplicative coefficient of the existing denoising error does not converge to one as decreases. Therefore, although smaller annealing increments reduce the reward-dependent error contributions at each step, they do not necessarily improve the overall theoretical bound when the accumulated approximation errors and error propagation are taken into account.
We will clarify this trade-off in the revised version. In particular, our theoretical result suggests that the annealing step size should balance the reward-induced approximation error against the computational and statistical costs of repeatedly fitting the critic and distilling the model.
We also note that a potentially more favorable characterization of the annealing effect may be obtained through an alternative analysis based on the total variation distance, under weaker distributional assumptions. Such an analysis could yield bounds whose dependence on the maximal annealing increment is more explicit and potentially better behaved as the schedule is refined. We have explored this direction, and would be happy to incorporate the corresponding results if the reviewer considers this additional theoretical analysis valuable for the paper. A sharper characterization of the optimal annealing schedule remains an interesting direction for future work.
Thank you for all the clarifications. The results appear a little mixed. I will keep my original slightly positive/borderline assessment.
Dear reviewer, thank you for your time and consideration. We would also like to highlight our additional large-vocabulary text generation experiment, included in the latest revision, in case you missed it.
Under comparable wall-clock training budgets, IVT outperforms DTM on both held-out sentiment and diversity of positive continuations:
| Method | Train reward ↑ | Held-out sentiment ↑ | Distinct positive ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pretrained | 0.385 | 0.190 | 3.55 |
| DTM | 0.650 | 0.298 | 7.91 |
| IVT | 0.919 | 0.622 | 21.19 |
We hope you can also take these additional results into account in your final assessment. Thank you again for your answer and constructive feedback.
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion and will restate Proposition 3.1 accordingly.
Regarding DGM, we have reproduced the exact algorithm under comparable computational budgets on DNA and protein, and report the corresponding results below.
To further the analysis, DGM is closely related to doing a single phase of IVT: it learns the same conditional soft value function but instead uses it for inference-time guidance, without distilling the correction into the model. This absence of distillation prevents DGM, in its current formulation, from performing successive tilting phases, an extension that the authors do not consider.
Our single-phase ablation (Fig. 2) therefore also provides a closely related, albeit not identical, proxy for DGM. It allows us to assess the benefits of progressive tilting over a single correction under matched compute budgets. This ablation provides complementary evidence for the benefit of our multi-phase approach, alongside our direct experimental comparison with DGM. We will make this connection between 1-phase IVT and DGM explicit in the main body in the revision.
Regarding DTM, we have reproduced this baseline under matched computational budgets on both DNA and protein benchmarks. We provide results below, along with computational budgets.
To ensure fair comparison, we have made sure to compare our method to the existing baselines in matched compute settings (matched total wall-clock time on both DNA and proteins benchmarks).
Notably, under these comparable wall-clock time compute budgets, IVT achieves the best results on several key metrics, including ATAC positivity and JASPAR correlation on DNA, as well as positive stability and joint success rate (main evaluation metric) on proteins.
We discard the intermediate states because we do not need to keep a particular trajectory to evaluate the loss. What matters is matching the student denoiser to the target at samples Xt∼pt. If the states visited during generation follow pt, they are equally valid points at which to evaluate the tilt correction. We already keep the rewarded X0’s and can cheaply draw a fresh Xt each time we reuse one, so we simply re-noise. Empirically, we found that discarding the trajectories / intermediate states did not degrade performance.
We thank the reviewer for raising this interesting question, which concerns the statistical sample complexity of learning the conditional soft value and the distillation steps. Our theoretical analysis instead focuses on the discretisation errors and how they accumulate across successive tilting phases, following a similar approach to early theoretical analyses of diffusion models. Establishing rollout sample-complexity guarantees for achieving prescribed learning and distillation accuracies is an interesting direction that we leave for future work.