- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
MARC is introduced as an agent framework for generating articulated-object programs from images and text. Building upon Articraft, it incorporates socket-bound connections and a kinematic graph to represent closed loops and coupled motion. Numerical diagnostics inform a multi-stage correction workflow. Experiments on 20 objects demonstrate improvements over existing generators, with further backbone comparisons and ablations of reflection and graph-based support.
Critical strengths
1: The paper addresses a significant problem. Individually plausible parts and joints do not always constitute a functional mechanism, especially in the context of closed chains. Assessing the validity of connections throughout motion facilitates the generation of articulated objects.
2: Connecting geometry, attachment frames, and kinematic constraints through a shared representation is a reasonable design. Diagnostics tied to specific joints and sockets could make corrections more targeted than relying only on rendered images or generic execution errors.
3: The comparison with the initial Solver candidate provides some evidence that correction helps. With Kimi-K3, reflection improves valid motion coverage from 54.1% to 67.8% and overall success from 40% to 60%, while structural correctness remains unchanged.
Critical weaknesses
-
The accompanying figures in the article are highly likely AI-generated and have not been manually refined to ensure accuracy. The AI usage statement acknowledges assistance in preparing and modifying the figures, and Figure 1 explicitly shows the "mechanism generated using MARC." Which panels are direct procedural renders, and which are illustrations or generatively modified images? The authors should clearly label these and provide unmodified renders and motion sequences corresponding to the evaluation procedure.
-
The requirements for the final evaluation lack clear definition. While Table 8 provides solver tolerances, Appendix C does not specify numerical acceptance criteria for collisions, branch continuity, or follower phase and travel. The definitions of SC and CMC depend on meeting annotation requirements, yet the adjudication process for semantic cases and the resolution of disagreements remain unexplained. These details are essential, particularly given that MARC achieves 100% SC and 98.2% CMC.
-
The analysis of baseline results requires greater detail. Table 1 reports a 0% overall success rate for all six baseline models, with five models achieving 0% effective motion coverage. It is important to specify how many failures result from unsupported closed-loop representations, incorrect connection generation, execution adapters, or geometric interference. An object-by-object analysis of failure causes and the establishment of a baseline model with comparable solution-support mechanisms would clarify the comparative results.
Overall, focusing on closed-loop mechanisms is a valuable direction, and shared build and diagnostic interfaces offer potential practical benefits. However, the current experiments do not clearly distinguish the contributions of graph-guided corrections from those of additional mechanism support and inference-time computation. Clearer evaluation criteria, controlled comparisons, and traceable visualizations are necessary to substantiate the reported improvements.
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses.
Response to Reviewer S7RD
Table 4 includes a configuration that retains the kinematic graph and numerical execution while withholding graph-based connection localization and constraint associations during repair. Full MARC achieves 67.8% VMC and 60.0% OSR, compared with 56.3% VMC and 45.0% OSR without graph-guided repair. These gains of 11.5 and 15.0 percentage points establish the contribution of graph-associated repair feedback with mechanism support retained.
The reflection ablation starts from the same initial Solver candidates. Reflective correction increases VMC from 54.1% to 67.8% and OSR from 40.0% to 60.0%, while SC and CMC remain unchanged. This directly demonstrates improvement after numerical solving, particularly in completing valid motion.
The completed PartNet-Mobility evaluation provides complementary evidence on standard articulated objects. MARC and original Articraft both export valid geometry for 77/77 inputs, while graph accuracy increases from 49.35% to 79.81% and axis error decreases from 0.13881 to 0.06377 rad. The improvement extends to inputs for which the baseline already produces usable geometry.
The final evaluation is conducted independently of MARC's internal Judge. Appendix C defines the distinct acceptance criteria:
Table 8 specifies attachment tolerances of 0.0001 m and 0.001 rad. Requirement-level semantic and contact adjudications were recorded and applied before final aggregation; the completed record contains 35 decisions across 15 method-object pairs.
The reported values preserve the distinction between these criteria. MARC's 100% SC and 98.2% CMC coexist with 67.8% VMC and 60.0% OSR, with closure and interference failures retained. Table 1 also credits baseline capabilities separately: original Articraft achieves 100% ER and 24.6% CMC, while complete-mechanism success additionally requires the critical connections and valid prescribed traversal.
The standard benchmark further reports substantial nonzero baseline performance under both explicit denominator conventions. In the manuscript's manual-reference comparison, Table 2 also shows improvements across all six aggregate geometry measures, covering static geometry and approximately matched motion states.
Figure 1 provides an illustrative workshop overview. Figures 2–3 explain the representation, attachment frames, and motion constraints. Figure 4 presents native-control before/after states and explicitly retains stationary or unstable responses, including the MARC excavator's collision.
The manuscript discloses AI assistance in figure preparation. The quantitative conclusions are based on executable outputs and independent evaluation. The completed 77-object comparison provides additional quantitative evidence for articulation structure and joint parameters.