- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents Kine2Go, a simulated state–action dataset for low-level quadrupedal locomotion. The proposed pipeline retargets heterogeneous quadruped motions to the Unitree Go2, trains RL tracking policies, and collects trajectories with corresponding motor commands. The dataset contains 40 motion families and 800 rollouts. Its utility is demonstrated through motion tracking and zero-shot reward-conditioned control with a Behavioral Foundation Model (BFM).
Critical strengths
- Providing motor actions alongside kinematic trajectories makes the dataset useful for learning control policies, beyond using motion references alone.
- The pipeline brings together several motion sources in a common Go2 representation. The BFM experiments and motion-family ablation provide an initial demonstration of its utility.
Critical weaknesses
- The released state–action trajectories are generated entirely in simulation on flat terrain, and neither the tracking policies nor the BFM are evaluated on hardware. Although this limitation is acknowledged, the dataset’s practical value for real-world locomotion remains unverified.
- The contribution is more convincing as a reusable data-generation pipeline than as a broadly applicable dataset. The dataset targets a single robot morphology, and its 800 trajectories are repeated executions of 40 motion families. It is unclear whether this provides sufficient coverage for the broader locomotion-learning applications discussed. Extending the pipeline to another target robot would also require retargeting and controller training; the claim that this needs only “minor modifications” is not demonstrated.
- The BFM experiments establish one use case, but provide limited evidence of the dataset’s broader value. The motion-family ablation is useful, yet motion tracking and reward-conditioned control within the same simulation setup do not establish how well the data supports learning beyond the collected behaviors. The broader claims about enabling general locomotion policies should be qualified accordingly.
Questions for authors
- What changes and retraining would be needed to use the Go2 motions to construct a dataset for another quadruped? Can the authors clarify which components are reusable and which are specific to Go2?
- How much additional state–action coverage do the 20 rollouts per family provide after accounting for randomized heading? Section 5 distinguishes execution diversity from behavioral diversity, but the planar visualization alone does not quantify this. Could the authors provide a coverage or redundancy analysis?
- Beyond the BFM demonstration, what evidence would establish the value of the released state–action pairs for the other stated uses, such as behavioral cloning or offline control?
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful review and concrete questions. Numbers refer to the revised manuscript.
Real-world validation
We agree that the dataset's real-world value is not verified. We now state explicitly that all experiments are in simulation; hardware validation was not feasible within the discussion period.
Pipeline vs. dataset; other morphologies (Question 1)
We agree that the claim about "minor modifications" was not supported. We removed it and added Appendix J with Table 14. It describes which components are reusable and which are specific to the Go2:
For a quadruped with a rigid trunk and three actuated joints per leg, we estimate a moderate engineering effort. A different joint count or topology would require more substantial changes. We state explicitly that we have not ported the pipeline to another robot.
Coverage of the 20 rollouts per family (Question 2)
Appendix G quantifies within-family execution diversity. It removes each trajectory's initial position and heading before computing pairwise differences in joints, actions, feet, root position and heading, so the reported diversity is not an artifact of the random initial heading. To measure what these executions add for learning, we use the new behavioral cloning experiment (Appendix I, Table 13). We train reference-conditioned BC on one family from each source, using either 1 or all 20 rollouts, with the same update budget. With 1 rollout, BC fails within about 0.8 s in nearly all episodes (success 0.012). With 20 rollouts, survival rises to 4.0 s and success to 0.313. Since the policy observation contains the absolute root pose, part of this gain could come from heading coverage alone. We therefore attempted a control that rotates and translates the single rollout to the same 20 initial placements as the 20-rollout data, which gives the same heading coverage and amount of data but only one execution. With this augmentation, BC reaches an average survival of 2.1 s and a success fraction of 0.137, between the 1-rollout (0.8 s, 0.012) and the 20-rollout policies (4.0 s, 0.313). For the circle walk, augmentation gives almost no improvement over a single rollout (0.78 vs. 0.67 s, compared with 4.26 s for 20 rollouts). However, the transformed observations are not fully consistent with the expert: the expert's actions on them differ from the recorded labels by 0.2 to 1.9 normalized units on average, depending on the family. This suggests that the absolute-pose policies are not exactly invariant to re-placement, so the augmented labels are partly inconsistent. We therefore consider this control preliminary and have not included it in the paper. It suggests that heading coverage explains part, but not all, of the gain from additional rollouts.
Value beyond the BFM use case (Question 3)
The revision adds three pieces of evidence for the usefulness of our work beyond the original BFM experiments:
We also qualified the broader claims: we added a contribution list, replaced the AMASS/MoCapAct comparison and the "comprehensive" wording, qualified the statements on scalability, hardware and general locomotion policies, and added a limitation on behavioral coverage and within-source generalization.