- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CCo-Patch, a time series forecasting framework that augments PatchTST with an auxiliary correction branch to address the claimed inter-patch continuity gap. The correction branch extracts a low-frequency temporal scaffold through FFT-based filtering and generates an auxiliary forecast using an MLP, which is combined with the backbone prediction through a learnable coefficient. The framework additionally incorporates patch-wise mean-centering and Huber loss, and is evaluated on seven long-term forecasting benchmarks.
Critical strengths
The paper is well writen and easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
The central contribution is not established.
The fundamental hypothesis is not validated. The paper assumes that patchification introduces an inter-patch continuity gap, but provides no direct evidence for this claim and whether it will damage forecasting. Patchification does not lead to any information loss, and a strong enough backbone (e.g. PatchTST) typically can restore the continuity structure that patchification may hurt. The authors neither demonstrate that such a continuity problem systematically exists nor establish that existing patch-based backbones fail to capture these relationships.
The methodological novelty is unclear. The proposed method primarily combines existing techniques, including frequency filtering followed by an MLP, Huber loss, and patch-wise mean-centering. More importantly, the so-called continuous correction pathway is entirely independent of the patch structure and contains no mechanism specifically designed to model or enforce inter-patch continuity. The two branches operate in parallel and interact only through additive fusion of their predictions. Consequently, the proposed architecture is essentially an ensemble of two forecasting pathways, rather than a method that explicitly addresses the claimed inter-patch continuity gap.
The empirical improvements are limited and do not substantiate the claimed contribution. Improvements over competitive baselines are often marginal or inconsistent. The improvement over PatchTST is still marginal.
Questions for authors
See Critical Weaknesses.
I sincerely appreciate the authors' thoughtful rebuttal and the additional efforts made to address my questions. While the new clarifications are helpful and resolve several of my minor points, I still have reservations regarding the marginal technical novelty of the proposed approach. Given the bar for ICLR conf, I feel the overall contribution to the community would benefit from further development before publication. Therefore, I will maintain my original score, though I encourage the authors to continue refining this promising direction.