- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents e3j, an open-source JAX library for E(3)-equivariant operations, with three sets of kernels:
deterministic CUDA kernels; Pallas GPU kernels, which are faster but non-deterministic on the backward pass and do not support fewer than 128 channels; Pallas TPU kernels.
Critical strengths
An open-source library that fills a gap, especially on TPU. At present, fast equivariant kernels on GPU depend largely on a closed-source library (cuEquivariance), and on TPU only unoptimized pure-JAX implementations exist. An open, JAX-native backend that covers both GPU and TPU is useful to practitioners. Careful benchmarking. Throughput is reported as a fraction of the hardware's peak memory bandwidth. The paper also distinguishes clearly between deterministic and non-deterministic kernels and discusses why determinism matters for NPT simulations.
Critical weaknesses
The submission violates the double-blind review policy Acknowledgments with identifying details. The paper keeps an Acknowledgments section (L500–505) that names a specific funding programme and thanks individuals by name.
Under ICLR's double-blind policy, I consider these violations sufficient grounds for rejection on their own, independent of the technical assessment below. I have notified the AC.
Questions for authors
None. The anonymity violation is decisive for my recommendation.