- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
My comments are outlined below.
-
Overall, the paper is likely to be AI-generated and is more like an experimental report, without a contribution to ML frameworks or practical implementation.
-
The experiment focuses on simulation/simulator. Even if the conclusion is right, it will face a challenging Sim2Real gap. This has been a significant effort to make RL safe for real physical systems, with the capability of tolerating learning faults, Sim2Real gaps, and distribution shift. The paper lacks such comparisons.
-
The 9-page formal content does not include formal statistical results.
-
What is the formal definition of fault? Is it the same as a safety violation in the studies of safe RL?
Critical strengths
The paper is likely to be an AI-generated experimental report. I did not find any innovations from the perspective of ML frameworks or practical implementation in real physical engineering systems.
Critical weaknesses
-
Overall, the paper is likely to be an AI-generated experimental report, without a contribution to ML frameworks or practical implementation.
-
The experiment focuses on simulation/simulator. Even if the conclusion is right, it will face a challenging Sim2Real gap. This has been a significant effort to make RL safe for real physical systems, with the capability of tolerating learning faults, Sim2Real gaps, and distribution shift. The paper lacks such comparisons.
-
The 9-page formal content does not include formal statistical results.
-
What is the formal definition of fault? Is it the same as a safety violation in the studies of safe RL?
Questions for authors
See Critical Weaknesses.