- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work proposed a constrained-availability source-time finite impulse response model. Target Isolation is derived from it as a source-adjustment procedure. The simulation presents the performance without anticipatory computation.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- experimental issues.
- implementation issues.
Questions for authors
- The proposed correction is not validated against real signals.
- No identifiability analysis is presented.
- Implementation details are not given.
- No source code.
Response to Reviewer wbDq (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for a careful and constructive review. Every point led to new analyses, several of which make the paper more rigorous and complete; we report these analyses below. Figures R1–R11 are available at anonymous repository. The updated supplementary material (version 3) contains the code and numerical results for the new analyses.
W1. One-sided kernel: is Target Isolation biased toward the null?
Kernel recovery, and the temporal-generalization check the reviewer proposed (Table R1; full visualization in Figs. R1–R2). We ran the App. B.6 generator with the predictive signal switched off (R1) and on (R2), at ρ = 0 and .72, with and without response overlap. We fit both the one-sided CAST-FIR and a two-sided version in which each word can also contribute before its own onset. We also use a cleaner and stricter cross-validation scheme, in which no model that produces an isolated response has seen the held-out test data, so that TI is not biased toward zero.
Table R1 summarizes the condition in which both mechanisms are present (ρ = .72 with response overlap; bottom-right panels of R1–R2) as the mean r over the second and fourth quadrants within ±600 ms of onset (the span of the predictive kernel):
Fig. R1. App. B.6 generator, predictive signal off.
Fig. R2. App. B.6 generator, predictive signal on.
Systematic comparison of one- and two-sided fits (Figs. R3–R4). To test whether the difference between the two models in R1–R2 holds beyond a single simulated dataset, we added a statistical comparison over many ground truths. We repeated the fits on 3,600 simulated datasets: 600 ground-truth settings (6 fixed kernel shapes × 50 seeds, plus 300 randomly drawn pairs of predictive and causal kernels), each at ρ ∈ {0, .358, .72} and two noise levels. R3 shows 12 of the random kernels.
Fig. R3. Ground truth vs one- and two-sided fits for 12 random kernel pairs (ρ = .72, prediction on).
Fig. R4. Kernel error of the one- vs the two-sided fit on every simulated dataset.
We are grateful for this suggestion, which greatly inspired our revision: in this comparison, the two-sided CAST-FIR is clearly the more appropriate choice. We therefore use it instead of the one-sided model as the main model in the remaining analyses (R5–R11), and we will revise the corresponding parts of the paper accordingly.