- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This submission is a literature survey/review paper on policy gradient agentic reinforcement learning. There is no novel research contribution provided by this paper.
Critical strengths
Please see below.
Critical weaknesses
This submission is a literature survey/review paper on policy gradient agentic reinforcement learning. There is no novel research contribution provided by this paper.
This submission is not mostly readable. The writing is not clear, mostly disjoint and incoherent.
As far as I can tell, the writing is at a level that it is not even possible to extract what is being claimed as a novel scientific contribution. It is possible, this issue stems from the fact that this submission was mostly generated by AI.
Questions for authors
Please see above.
4 comments
2. Readability and coherence
Thank you for pointing out the difficulty in following the paper. We have revised the exposition around how a task POMDP is translated into an implemented training update, making the connections between motivation, method comparison, and theoretical analysis more direct.
Section 2 first introduces partial observability, multi-turn interaction, and delayed return, then explains how the four interfaces enter policy updates. The main text retains the central correspondence between the task gradient and its implemented estimate. Full notation and derivation conditions have been moved to Appendix A to reduce the notation burden on a first reading.
Section 3 organizes each interface’s research directions around the problem, solution approaches, and relationships between methods, with explicit comparison criteria. Section 4 introduces shared objects and compatibility conditions through dependencies in actual methods, moving detailed mathematical material such as the configuration expansion to the appendix. Section 5 connects the joint analysis of credit and sampling bias to the ALFWorld comparisons, focusing the experiments on whether the effect of the same collection change depends on the credit source.
These revisions retain the theoretical conditions and literature support while clarifying the argument. The POMDP interpretation and interface mappings are highlighted in blue on pages 2–3, and representative interface conclusions on pages 4–7. Section 4.1 on page 8 highlights the distinction between structural relationships and empirical interaction. Section 4.3 on page 8 highlights the key condition for update equivalence, and Section 5.1 on pages 9–10 highlights deviation from the task gradient and the scope of exact correction. Blue is used selectively for the passages directly addressing the reviews.
We welcome comments on specific claims or evidence so that we can examine and address them individually.
Thank you once again for your feedback and assessment! As the discussion phase is drawing to a close, we are reaching out to see whether our responses and the additional information provided have addressed your concerns. Should you have any further questions, we would be more than happy to provide additional clarification, and we look forward to your further consideration.
I thank the authors for their response. Unfortunately, my concerns have not been addressed. Thus, I will be keeping my score.
1. Research contribution
We recognize the demands of reviewing and take your readability concerns seriously. However, the review does not specifically assess the contribution of the proposed framework or identify technical issues supporting its soundness concerns. Below, we clarify the paper’s contributions and supporting evidence and address the readability concerns.
The paper’s core contribution is an explanatory framework connecting task interaction to implemented policy updates. As language-model training extends to long-horizon agent interaction, history, tool calls, delayed feedback, and behavior data undergo different transformations before entering the same policy update. Using a POMDP as a common task reference, the Belief, Granularity, Signal, and Rollout interfaces analyze how these transformations change the decision process and its gradient estimation, providing a theoretical basis for comparing research directions.
This perspective runs through the literature analysis. Belief compares history compression, external and parametric memory, and explicit uncertainty maintenance through preservation of task-relevant action distinctions. Granularity compares policy ownership, action units, cross-scale value learning, and hierarchical control, distinguishing changes in decision structure from improvements in credit resolution. Signal compares credit derived from task outcomes, learned evaluators, and teacher feedback, showing that terminal rewards can provide dense credit and that feedback density and credit quality should be examined separately. Rollout compares synchronous refresh, importance correction, robust updates, and asynchronous scheduling, analyzing how behavior-distribution changes affect updates under specific correction rules.
The framework also provides conditions for combining methods. For example, the additivity of token gradients on the same trajectory does not by itself imply update equivalence when different credit and correction weights are used. Decision segments spanning memory updates must preserve the context under which each action was generated. Six pairwise couplings connect these conditions through shared information, decision events, and sampling distributions.
The exact Signal × Rollout decomposition further shows that correction residuals affect the contributions of both task advantage and credit error. With context construction and decision units fixed, the ALFWorld comparisons show that the same collection change has different effects on task performance under different credit sources. The MC-dense control also shows that feedback density alone is insufficient to explain the difference between PRM and outcome-derived credit. These analyses provide concrete grounds for identifying the training components a method changes, assessing component compatibility, and comparing findings across studies.