- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper audits how action responses to matched physical perturbations travel inside four frozen World Action Model (WAM) configurations, using activation patching to track their transmission. In Fast-WAM-Joint, with the decoder's future inputs fixed, the current observation accounts for under one-tenth of the full action change for the robot-displacement factor, so most of its effect travels through the predicted future. Reducing world-denoising steps from ten to five changes these responses while cutting cumulative policy-computation time by a median of 23.7%, with all 50 evaluated LIBERO continuations still completing.
Critical strengths
The response-level criterion complements task success: reducing world-denoising steps from ten to five keeps all 50 evaluated LIBERO continuations complete while changing the responses to the same physical changes, in ways a uniform rescaling does not explain.
The current/future source interventions separate the controlled direct effect of the current observation from the additional effect admitted by the recomputed future, isolating a direct pathway under one-tenth of the full effect for the robot-displacement factor.
Critical weaknesses
The source-attribution, layer-localization, and computation-budget findings all come from Fast-WAM-Joint, and three of the four audited configurations are variants of the same prior work. Breadth is narrow where the depth is claimed: the four-model interface audit rests on 544 cases per model drawn from 20 held-out states in two tasks, and the restoration cohort comes from two tasks. The interaction and budget analyses span five tasks, but all of these depth findings remain within Fast-WAM-Joint, so whether the central phenomena hold for WAMs generally is untested.
The headline ratio, the future-fixed current effect under one-tenth of the joint radial effect for the robot-displacement factor, is measured in a cell whose input combination need not occur during native inference; the ratio under the donor-future background is unreported, and the appendix magnitudes leave the one-tenth unguaranteed there. The practical import of the efficiency result is likewise open: the authors note that a response difference alone is not evidence of worse control.
Questions for authors
What is the headline ratio under the donor-future background? The four-cell outputs in Appendix C.1 should already contain it, and the reported magnitudes suggest an upper bound near a seventh of the joint effect. For F1, does the ratio change if the donor's proprioception is used in those cells?
Could you assemble the audited Fast-WAM-Joint architecture in one description, covering how the predicted-future inputs are produced, what the current-state node corresponds to, and how the command-state token and proprioception enter, so that a reader can judge whether the intervention sites are natural divisions of the model?
Could you document which checkpoint versions were audited and how they were obtained?
5 comments
Author Response to Reviewer 9nK5 (Part 1)
"The source-attribution, layer-localization, and computation-budget findings all come from Fast-WAM-Joint, and three of the four audited configurations are variants of the same prior work."
"Whether the central phenomena hold for WAMs generally is untested."
Cross-configuration evaluation. We acknowledge that Direct, Joint, and IDM belong to the same Fast-WAM family, rather than representing three independent model families. Our four-configuration evaluation is intended to compare distinct action-facing configurations, not to claim broad architectural diversity. It covers 7,318 valid discovery donors, 544 primary held-out donors per configuration across 20 shared states from two tasks, and 374 prospective cases per configuration. Transfer coefficients are consistently high across the four configurations (0.951–0.999), supporting action-response transmission through their respective interfaces.
Joint-specific causal analysis. We selected Fast-WAM-Joint for deeper attribution because its video and action experts expose identifiable current-origin and future-origin K/V inputs at the actual action-consumer interface. This enables controlled source replacement, downstream propagation analysis, and layer-specific restoration. The analysis includes 174 F1 records and 526 F3-G records across five tasks, 103 restoration donors from 20 source trajectories, and 200 computation-budget donors from 50 source trajectories.
We further observe the distinction between propagation-allowed node effects and future-fixed current effects on RoboTwin: their mean radial RMS magnitudes are 7.707 mm and 2.666 mm, respectively, with a matched signed radial difference of 3.304 mm (95% CI: [0.285, 6.933]).
Together, these results establish cross-configuration interface-level response transmission and provide deeper causal evidence for Fast-WAM-Joint on LIBERO and RoboTwin. We have clarified that the source-attribution and layer-localization findings are specific to the Joint configuration, rather than claiming that these mechanisms hold universally across WAM architectures.
Author Response to Reviewer 9nK5 (Part 2)
"What is the headline ratio under the donor-future background? The four-cell outputs in Appendix C.1 should already contain it, and the reported magnitudes suggest an upper bound near a seventh of the joint effect."
"For F1, does the ratio change if the donor's proprioception is used in those cells?"
Donor-future background. The small current-side effect persists under the donor-future background: the six dose-wise mean projection coefficients range from 0.04578 to 0.07330, all below one-seventh.
We recomputed these coefficients from all 174 valid F1 records, covering 35 registered states and five tasks, using the saved four-cell action arrays and original bootstrap weights. For each record, the conditional current-effect vector is projected onto the matched strict joint radial response and normalized by its squared norm.
| F1 dose | Recipient-future coefficient | Donor-future coefficient [95% CI] |
|---|---|---|
| −4 cm | 0.07040 | 0.06614 [0.04277, 0.11068] |
| −2 cm | 0.06226 | 0.05688 [0.02317, 0.10973] |
| −1 cm | 0.07399 | 0.07330 [0.03616, 0.11987] |
| +1 cm | 0.07305 | 0.06930 [0.04176, 0.10372] |
| +2 cm | 0.05245 | 0.05082 [0.03361, 0.07955] |
| +4 cm | 0.04503 | 0.04578 [0.03688, 0.05412] |
The donor-future range closely matches the recipient-future range of 0.04503–0.07399. All six paired background-difference intervals include zero, and all six pointwise 95% confidence intervals have upper bounds below one-seventh. Thus, the small current-side effect is observed under both future-input backgrounds.
Proprioception sensitivity. The original four-cell evaluation retained recipient action-side proprioception. We additionally conducted a matched intervention using donor proprioception. In the one fully completed paired case (task 0, state 00, −1 cm), the coefficient changes from 0.03786 to 0.04076, while changes from 0.03667 to 0.03852. Using the original recipient-proprioception joint radial response as the fixed reference vector, including its projection direction and squared-norm denominator, gives corresponding donor-proprioception coefficients of 0.04081 and 0.03859.
In this case, donor proprioception increases the two coefficients by 0.00290 and 0.00185, respectively, while both remain below 0.05. The pilot completed all four donor-proprioception conditions for one of five selected states; the remaining 16 outputs were unavailable following a GPU resource interruption.
Author Response to Reviewer 9nK5 (Summary)
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We organize our responses into three parts addressing configuration coverage, source-background attribution, and reproducibility.
Configuration coverage: The three Fast-WAM configurations provide a within-family comparison of prediction–action couplings, complemented by ImageWAM as a second model family. The four-configuration audit shows directional transfer coefficients of 0.951–0.999. We identify Joint as the configuration used for the detailed source-attribution, layer-restoration, and computation-budget analyses.
Donor-future attribution: Under the donor-future background, dose-wise mean current-effect projection coefficients range from 0.04578 to 0.07330, all below one-seventh. We also report the completed donor-proprioception intervention as a single-case paired check.
Architecture and checkpoint provenance: We explain future generation, current/future intervention boundaries, and instruction/state conditioning in one description. We report checkpoint download sources and file identities, together with the recorded parameter digests and code version.