- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Attention Entropy Routing (AER) for referring image segmentation. It extracts normalized attention entropy from four Swin Transformer stages, uses spatially aligned entropy to route language-generated channel modulations, and uses pooled entropy to condition scale fusion. A single-head proposition motivates entropy as information that an aggregated attention output need not retain. The evaluation covers three natural-image benchmarks and two remote-sensing benchmarks with synthetic haze. Within the proposed architecture, AER improves over visual routing by 2.44 mIoU points on hazy RefSegRS and 2.62 oIoU points on RefCOCO validation (Table 5a).
Critical strengths
1.The paper tests its central idea in several ways: a matched head with frozen encoder features (Table 4), local versus image-mean entropy routing (Table 5a), and a spatial permutation intervention (Table 5b). These controls provide more evidence than benchmark comparisons alone. The paper states the scope of its proposition carefully and reports cases where another method remains better on several RRSIS-D threshold metrics (Table 3).
Critical weaknesses
1.The experiments report one training seed (Appendix C.1) and use one fixed synthetic haze realization per source image (Appendix E.1). Several component gains are around one percentage point (Tables 4–5), with no run-to-run variation or evaluation on newly sampled haze. It is therefore difficult to judge their stability. 2.The gain attributed to global entropy fusion is not isolated from the added learned interaction parameters: AER adds U and VH when compared with the local-entropy configuration (Section 4.3; Appendix D). Also, the natural-image baseline scores come from separate publications rather than a shared retraining protocol (Section 5.1). Table 1 establishes a promising system-level comparison, but does not establish how much of its gap is caused by entropy.
Questions for authors
1.Can the authors report multiple-seed results, including variation for Tables 4–5, and evaluate the haze models on independently resampled haze? Were component and hyperparameter choices made without consulting RefSegRS test results? Can the authors add a parameter-matched global fusion control that replaces pooled entropy with a pooled visual descriptor? This would clarify whether the additional Table 5a gain comes from entropy rather than the larger scoring function.