acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Open-Ended Skill Speciation: Evolving New Abstractions for Agent Skills

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large language model agents use reusable skills to encode procedural knowledge, tool interactions, and control logic. Existing skill-evolution methods optimize skill content within fixed representations or reward diversity without identifying behaviorally meaningful changes in abstraction. We formulate open-ended skill abstraction discovery as the evolution of an expanding repertoire that introduces temporal abstractions and intermediate representations while retaining verifiable utility. We propose Open-Ended Skill Speciation (OESS), a species-aware evolutionary framework that preserves and develops structural innovations when they address previously uncovered failure cases. OESS represents each skill using its input-output signature, temporal abstraction level, tool-dependency graph, failure-repair profile, and execution traces. A structured distance metric distinguishes changes in behavioral organization from superficial textual variation. To enable transitions between abstraction levels, OESS applies macro-mutations that convert repeated procedures into parameterized routines, encapsulate coordinated subskills, extract planners and verifiers, and transform linear workflows into state-dependent controllers. Candidates compete on quality within each species, while inter-species novelty and a lineage archive preserve intermediate innovations for subsequent composition. We evaluate OESS on task families spanning primitive, macro, monitor, and meta-level skills under matched execution budgets. We further test transfer across unseen tasks, models, agent harnesses, and environment perturbations. The evaluation measures verified failure coverage, species survival, abstraction depth, reuse, composition, and lineage-level transitions, yielding a systematic protocol for distinguishing functional abstraction discovery from inconsequential structural diversity.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
skill speciation, open-ended evolution, LLM agents

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_u7ibOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

OESS proposes to evolve executable agent skills through LLM-generated macro-mutations, structured skill descriptors, species-aware selection, verified novelty, and lineage retention. A candidate can form a new species when it is structurally distant from existing representatives and reproducibly solves previously uncovered diagnostic failures. The five macro-mutations introduce procedural routines, encapsulated subskills, planners, monitors, and stateful controllers.

The method is evaluated on a custom benchmark with primitive, macro, monitor, and meta-level task families. The paper reports improvements in held-out success, species survival, cross-task reuse, hierarchy depth, composition, and transfer over several internally constructed baselines.

Critical strengths

I like that the paper tries to define abstraction discovery more carefully than simple textual novelty. It provides a clear high-level framework for structured descriptors, verified novelty, macro-mutations, species-aware selection, and lineage retention, although some operational details remain underspecified.

The evaluation design is also ambitious. The authors attempt to use matched search budgets, deterministic environment assertions, transfer tests, ablations, sensitivity studies, and multiple random seeds rather than relying only on free-form LLM judging.

Critical weaknesses

My main concern is that the reported main configuration is internally inconsistent. The implementation section gives one set of thresholds and archive capacity, while the main statistics exactly match different settings in the sensitivity tables. Without code, task instances, verifier implementations, or run logs, it is impossible to determine which configuration produced the reported results. The comparison is also limited to internal variants rather than published skill-evolution systems.

The paper also does not independently validate its central abstraction labels. Descriptor fields and abstraction levels are assigned by an LLM, with no agreement study, repeated extraction, or alternative model. Mutation selection is described both as uniform sampling and as an LLM decision. The results show that OESS finds useful skill artifacts, but they do not clearly establish that these artifacts represent genuinely new abstraction levels.

Questions for authors

Which thresholds and archive capacity produced the main results?

Can the authors release the code, tasks, verifiers, instantiated prompts, and per-seed traces and add a published-system baseline?

Which decisions are deterministic and which are produced by an LLM, and how stable are the abstraction labels across repeated extraction and alternative models?

Reviewer_SScMOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

OESS evolves agent skills through structural mutations, groups them into species, and preserves candidates that solve previously uncovered failures. Experiments across four task families report improvements in task success, reuse, composition, and transfer, supported by component ablations and lineage analysis.

Critical strengths

The author provides the deterministic verifiers, component ablations, and frozen-library transfer tests provide meaningful evidence that the evolved skills offer benefits beyond superficial structural diversity.

Critical weaknesses
  • The configuration behind the main results is unclear. Appendix B.3 specifies species and novelty thresholds of 0.35 and 0.02, but Table 5 reproduces the headline results at 0.30 and 0.04. B.3 also specifies an archive capacity of 256, while Table 9 associates the headline 60.4% success and 31.8 species with capacity 128; capacity 256 gives different results. These discrepancies make it difficult to reproduce the reported comparisons.

  • The novelty term appears to vanish during parent selection. Equation 5 counts tasks solved by a skill but unsolved by every archived skill. For a skill already in the archive, this set is empty because the archive includes that skill itself. Yet Equation 9 and Algorithm 1 use this quantity to rank archived parents. As written, the coverage bonus is therefore always zero for those parents. The paper needs to clarify whether the implementation excludes the evaluated skill or retains its novelty score from admission.

Questions for authors

See Weakness.

Reviewer_6BSPOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper asks how an LLM agent's skill library can evolve new kinds of abstraction (macros, monitors, controllers, meta-skills) rather than only rewriting skills within a fixed template. The proposed OESS adapts NEAT-style speciation: skills are compared through a five-part structural and behavioral descriptor, and a candidate may found a new species only if it is structurally distant from existing species and also solves verifiable failures that no archived skill solves. Five LLM-prompted macro-mutations supply structural variation, and selection combines within-species utility with species-level novelty and exploration terms. On a custom verifier-backed benchmark with four task families, using Qwen2.5-Coder-32B and five seeds, OESS improves over local mutation, best-of-N, novelty-only and embedding-based speciation by 14-17 points on the higher-level families. Ablations, transfer to unseen tasks and a second backbone, and a lineage analysis are also reported.

Critical strengths

The selection criterion is well motivated. Requiring a structurally novel candidate to also cover previously unsolved, verifiable failures addresses a real weakness of novelty-based archives, which tend to reward superficial rewrites. The ablation without behavioral verification supports this directly: it produces more nominal species, but invalid novelty rises from 7.8% to 43.5%.

The operators and metrics are useful. The five abstraction-changing mutations give a concrete account of how skill hierarchies could grow, and metrics such as verified species, survival, cross-task reuse and call-graph depth would help others working on skill libraries.

The experimental bookkeeping is careful. Five seeds, a paired bootstrap, per-seed values, budget and threshold sensitivity, and full baseline prompts make the internal comparisons easy to inspect.

Critical weaknesses

All results come from a single private, unreleased benchmark whose four task families mirror the method's own abstraction hierarchy. No public benchmark is used, and there is no comparison with DGM, SkillWeaver or ADAS.

The reported configuration is inconsistent. The appendix gives δsp = 0.35, νmin = 0.02 and archive capacity 256, while the sensitivity tables attribute the main result to 0.30, 0.04 and 128. Budgets are claimed to be identical, yet OESS has a normalized cost of 1.13, and it is unclear whether the extra LLM calls count toward the budget.

Several citations point to unrelated papers: novelty search is cited as a paper on hard disks on the hyperbolic plane, local competition as an OLAP database paper, Minimal Criterion Coevolution as a quasicrystals paper, and PAIRED as Prioritized Level Replay. Relevant work such as Lehman & Stanley, ADAS, Agent Workflow Memory and DreamCoder/LILO is missing.

The descriptor relies on the LLM's self-declared abstraction level, so its robustness is questionable.

Questions for authors

Which values of δsp, νmin and archive capacity produced Tables 1-3? Please reconcile App. B.3 with Tables 5 and 9.

How is the budget matched exactly? Do the three-instance reproduction checks and the descriptor, redundancy and mutation-selection LLM calls count toward the budget given to baselines? What does the 1.13 cost in Table 3 consist of?

Can you evaluate on at least one public benchmark (for example AppWorld or a SWE-bench subset) and include ADAS- or DGM-style archive search as a baseline? Will the benchmark generators be released?

How is ϕtemp determined, and how often does the validator in D.8.1 disagree with the LLM's declared abstraction level? How sensitive are the results to the distance weights in Eq. 3?

Please correct the mismatched citations (de Haro 2008, Szépkúti 2011, Gorham & Laughlin 2019, Jiang 2020) and explain how the bibliography was produced.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.