- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Shared Hénon Neural Operator(SHNO), a compositional reduced order model (ROM) for reconstructing dynamics from given phase space observation. It construct a symplectic, one step push forward operator and learn a reusable patch block where repetition of blocks with some choice of graph connectivity of local low-dimensional patched phase space dynamics compose the predictive dynamics from high-dimensional phase state inputs.
Critical strengths
- The idea of symplectic push forward operator in compositional structure is convincing.
Critical weaknesses
-
The numerical validation scheme is not convincing. The time stepping is fixed step size (L294-295), with , and only trajectories with time steps are used (Table 3). It is very limited and non-flexible. It would be better if author can test longer horizon (more than time steps in evaluation per trajectory) and test different patch compositions. There is no numerical algorithm block for readability. There is no visual results in phase space reconstruction quality in KG, FPUT and Toda test cases as well. These would harm the readability for general readers. making it hard to understand what is the actual advantage of SHNO.
-
A minor issue is if the system is no longer symplectic or contain observational noise, symplecticity in ROM might not be helpful. At least it is not validated in this paper.
Questions for authors
- Have authors considered comparison with other symplectic operator learning scheme (e.g. SympGNNs , ENOs) as Shared residual nor FNO is specialized in this particular phase state space reconstruction task.
- In Figure 5, I can clearly see energy has a slowly diverging rate up to rollout step . What is the potential reason and can authors rollout longer to validate if energy error is going to be accumulated.
- What is the result regarding different time stepping size , different choice and different composition of ? Are results robust to different configuraions of tested system (i.e. would changing or stated in L793 affect the result, what about mix-up multiple cases or create in-distribution and out-of-distribution evaluation?).
- Would result in Table 2 considered as a negative result as transfer from to do lose salient accuracy?