1. Firstly, the authors have not identified a sufficiently specific research gap.
The Introduction begins by stating:
A small KKT residual may occur after a dll or correspond to the wrong active set or stationary branch.
Whilst this is a valid issue, the authors have not specifically demonstrated which existing methods are prone to this problem, nor why current approaches are unable to detect or address it.
In particular, both deadline and active-set tracking have a long history of research.
The authors must clarify which technical challenge, one not yet adequately addressed, they resolved.
2. The authors have organised many relatively straightforward conclusions into a complex theoretical framework.
For example:
- Theorem 8 proves that when the drift margin is sufficiently large, the residual can be reduced before the deadline.
- Theorem 9 proves that when both the deadline and identity certifications are passed simultaneously, the result satisfies both requirements.
- Proposition 10 proves that under strict certification rules, selecting candidate solutions that pass certification can maximise delivery availability.
Theorem 8 includes a practical dynamical analysis and cannot simply be regarded as a trivial conclusion.
However, the core logic of Theorem 9 and Proposition 10 is relatively straightforward. It is difficult for me to understand why these need to be elevated to the status of significant theoretical contributions of the paper.
3. There is another issue: is this a theoretical paper or an algorithmic paper?
This paper attempts to provide the following simultaneously:
- A new form of residual dynamics
- An active-set event certification method
- A non-convex branch identification method
- a theory of selective delivery
- A framework for global root verification....
Each of these involves a relatively independent field of research.
However, the main experiment consists of only one 6-variable separable QP, and the various theoretical sections have not been validated to the same extent.