- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CL‑QECM, an evidential clustering method that combines complex‑valued evidential assignment, distance‑induced phase mapping, and instance‑subset‑barycenter contrastive loss to tackle uncertainty and cluster overlap in clustering tasks.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses the representation of ambiguous samples and overlapping clusters, which is a practically meaningful research problem.
-
Experiments cover multiple types of datasets, report a variety of clustering metrics, and present ablation studies for both the contrastive‑loss module and the phase module.
Critical weaknesses
-
Concerns remain regarding the incremental contribution of the proposed method. Evidential clustering assignments and prototype-based contrastive objectives have been explored in prior work, such as NN-EVCLUS: Neural Network-Based Evidential Clustering and Prototypical Cross-Domain Self-Supervised Learning for Few-Shot Unsupervised Domain Adaptation. While phase mapping could constitute the unique contribution of this paper, its current definition is still a deterministic function of distance. The paper fails to illustrate what geometric information it provides that cannot already be captured by distance alone.
-
There appears to be an inconsistency between the phase formula and its core geometric interpretation. According to Equation (12), a shared normalization denominator is applied across distances from one sample to different subset barycenters. Consequently, equal distances from a sample to two subset barycenters will inevitably yield identical phases. Figure 2 illustrates the authors’ design intuition using distinct orientation deviations and boundary scales; however, it is not explicitly shown how these quantities enter Equation (12). Hence the claim that distinct phases arise under equal‑distance conditions in Figure 2 cannot be justified by the given formulation.
-
There are inconsistencies between the objective function and update derivations as written. Equation (2) takes powers of complex‑valued evidential assignments, which generally produce complex numbers, yet Equations (8)‑(10) derive magnitude updates assuming a real‑valued objective built from powers of moduli. Furthermore, Equation (7) constructs the Lagrangian with the full joint objective, whereas subsequent derivatives drop the contrastive‑loss term. Although the main text mentions a surrogate objective for staged optimization, descent guarantees for the joint objective under this surrogate are not provided, and convergence proofs are missing.
-
Baseline coverage and comparison settings need improvement. Several classical clustering methods are included, yet recent approaches are under‑represented. The authors should clarify their baseline‑selection criteria and adopt stronger baselines to enable valid assessment of performance gaps.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors provide convergence analysis for the proposed method and clarify whether the staged‑update scheme guarantees descent of the joint objective?
-
Could the authors directly demonstrate the discriminative effect of phase on equidistant and overlapping‑cluster samples, alongside controlled comparisons against simple transformations that use identical distance information?
-
UFCER has been introduced in Appendix G. Why is it absent from the comparison tables? Consequently, the most recent baseline included is from 2023, which fails to meet the requirement for adequate state‑of‑the‑art comparisons. Could the authors supplement additional stronger recent clustering baselines for evaluation?