acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

TRACE: Transient Recognition, Authentication, and Coverage-aware Editing

Abstract

Recent advances in 3D Gaussian Splatting (GS) have enabled high-quality novel view synthesis from casually captured images, yet fully automatic transient object removal remains challenging. Existing methods rely on unreliable geometric cues or assume accurate transient masks are available, often removing persistent objects that belong to transient semantic categories. We present TRACE, a fully automatic pipeline that authenticates transient objects before editing. Candidate objects are detected using off-the-shelf instance segmentation and verified through multi-view geometric persistence derived from Structure-from-Motion, with cross-view semantic consistency resolving ambiguous cases. Using the authenticated masks, TRACE selects a minimal yet informative set of views for diffusion-based inpainting by jointly optimizing geometric coverage and object visibility. Experiments on challenging real-world datasets demonstrate that TRACE significantly improves transient localization and produces higher-quality Gaussian Splatting reconstructions than existing geometry- and category-based approaches.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Coverage Aware Editing, Gaussian Splatting, Gaussian Splatting Inpainting, Object Removal, Gaussian Splatting Transient Object Removal

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_nytbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents TRACE, an automatic pipeline for transient object removal in GS scenes. The pipeline obtains instance masks of candidate objects by YOLOv11-Seg then authenticates them as transient or persistent using three multi-view geometric cues derived from the SfM reconstruction, including point support N_pts, track consistency L_track, and view coverage R_view. When the geometric evidence is weak, the pipeline falls back to semantic verification based on the similarity of pretrained visual features. The authenticated masks then drive a greedy, coverage-aware view selection strategy for diffusion inpainting prior to GS optimization. The framework is evaluated on the WRIVA, Spin-NeRF, and Neural3D datasets.

Critical strengths

The paper cleanly separates two underexplored problems in transient object removal, such as determining what should be removed (authentication) and recovering how to remove it (coverage-aware editing). This separation makes the framework easy to follow and enables a plug-and-play evaluation of the view selection module on standard editing benchmarks.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient methodological details for reproduction.
  • Sec. 2.3 introduces 3 geometric cues, including N_pts, L_track, and R_view, but the paper never specifies how these cues are combined into an actual persistence decision and the threshold values (or their derivation) are likewise not reported.
  • Sec. 2.3.3 states that semantic verification is invoked "when the available geometric evidence is insufficient," but this insufficiency condition is never formalized.
  1. Insufficient quantitative evaluation.
  • The primary evaluation of transient authentication covers only 2 WRIVA sequences, which is a thin empirical basis for claims about "challenging real-world scenes." Moreover, on the Dataset_2, TRACE underperforms T-3DGS in psnr without further analysis, and the text justifies this via ssim only.
  • The comparison set is currently restricted to T-3DGS (authentication) and InFusion/GScream (editing). Closely related lines of work are not compared: distractor-free reconstruction (RobustNeRF [1], NeRF On-the-go [2]) and robust GS reconstruction (SpotlessSplats [3], WildGaussians [4]).
  • The paper claims to "significantly improve transient localization," yet no metric directly measures localization quality (e.g., mask IoU, precision/recall or F1).
  1. Missing ablations. There is no ablation showing the impact of removing the semantic fallback. The reader cannot judge whether this component is a genuine contribution or a rarely-triggered safety net.

  2. Presentation and figure quality are poor. Figure 1 is not well connected to the paper structure. The overview does not map its stages to the corresponding sections (e.g., which blocks implement §2.3.1 vs. §2.3.2), making it hard to use as a reading guide. More importantly, the key architectural components, such as, the persistence verification module, and the greedy view selection, are conveyed only through high-level pictograms, and their inputs/outputs and decision logic are not visually specified.

Questions for authors

Overall, the proposed pipeline to tackle dynmaic objects in 3D reconstruction is standard and well-established. Could you please address above concerns and clearly articulate the specific algorithmic innovations compared to existing methods?

Reviewer_AVz5OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents TRACE, a fully automatic pipeline for transient object removal in 3D Gaussian Splatting. To address the limitations of existing methods that rely on unreliable geometric cues or assume accurate transient masks are available, TRACE authenticates transient objects before editing. It uses instance segmentation, SfM-based geometric persistence, and DINO-based semantic verification. It then selects informative views based on geometric coverage and object visibility for diffusion-based inpainting. The method is evaluated on WRIVA, Spin-NeRF, and Neural 3D.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a meaningful problem in automatic transient object removal for 3DGS. The motivation is clear.

Critical weaknesses

Table 1 reports results only on two WRIVA sequences and compares TRACE only with T-3DGS. The PSNR is even lower on the second sequence. Comparisons with additional baselines, such as RobustSplat, is recommented.

The paper proposes to verify candidate objects through “multi-view geometric persistence derived from Structure-from-Motion, with cross-view semantic consistency resolving ambiguous cases.” However, the benefit of these mechanisms are not sufficiently evaluated through ablation studies, and the sensitivity to the parameter alpha is not discussed.

Questions for authors

Provide broader comparisons with relevant methods?

Provide more comprehensive ablation studies and hyperparameter analysis?

Table 2 shows substantially different improvements across scenes, explain this variation and report results across multiple random seeds?

Reviewer_petZOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TRACE proposes a fully automatic framework for transient object removal in 3D Gaussian Splatting. The method consists of two main components. First, it identifies candidate objects using off-the-shelf instance segmentation and determines their persistence through SfM-based geometric evidence, with DINO feature similarity used when geometric support is insufficient. Second, it introduces a coverage-aware view selection strategy that selects informative views for diffusion-based inpainting by considering geometric coverage and object visibility.

The authors evaluate transient authentication against T-3DGS on WRIVA and demonstrate that the proposed view selection improves reconstruction quality when integrated into existing 3DGS editing frameworks, including InFusion and GScream, on Spin-NeRF and Neural 3D. Qualitative results of the complete pipeline are also presented on WRIVA.

Critical strengths

1. Practical and technically reasonable framework. TRACE addresses the relevant problem of distinguishing transient objects from persistent scene content before Gaussian Splatting optimization. Combining semantic instance segmentation with SfM-based persistence verification provides a reasonable approach to automatic transient identification.

2. Modular design with demonstrated improvements. The coverage-aware view selection module can be integrated into existing 3DGS inpainting frameworks without redesigning their underlying editing pipelines. The improvements reported with InFusion and GScream provide evidence of its practical utility.

Critical weaknesses

1. Insufficient evaluation of transient authentication. Although accurate transient identification is a central contribution, the evaluation relies mainly on downstream reconstruction metrics (PSNR and SSIM) from only two WRIVA sequences. These metrics do not directly measure authentication accuracy. The paper lacks quantitative evaluation using transient/persistent classification metrics or mask-level metrics, making it difficult to assess the reliability and robustness of this component. Furthermore, the semantic verification assumes that visual similarity to authenticated persistent objects indicates persistence, which may not hold for visually similar but distinct objects.

2. Limited novelty and experimental evidence. While the proposed modules are technically reasonable and demonstrate practical improvements, the overall contribution appears relatively incremental. Transient authentication mainly combines existing instance segmentation, SfM-based geometric verification, and semantic features, while coverage-aware view selection relies on a relatively straightforward greedy selection strategy. The experimental evaluation is also limited in scale relative to the paper's claims of robustness and general applicability. In particular, Table 2 reports only six Spin-NeRF scenes without explaining the selection criteria, and several improvements are relatively modest. Although the supplementary material includes additional qualitative examples and view-selection analyses, the limited evaluation coverage makes it difficult to assess generalizability across diverse scenes and capture conditions. Moreover, the absence of novel-view rendering videos or interactive 3D reconstruction results makes it difficult to thoroughly assess the final reconstruction quality and cross-view consistency beyond selected static images.

Questions for authors

1. Transient authentication accuracy: Could the authors provide direct quantitative evaluation of transient/persistent classification, such as precision, recall, and F1, as well as transient mask IoU? These measurements would help establish authentication accuracy independently of downstream reconstruction quality.

2. Semantic verification: How does TRACE distinguish visually similar but distinct objects with different persistence statuses? For example, a permanently parked car and a passing car with similar appearances may exhibit high DINO feature similarity, potentially causing the transient car to be incorrectly classified as persistent.

3. Scene selection and robustness: Why are only six Spin-NeRF scenes reported in Table 2? Could the authors clarify the selection criteria and provide results on the remaining benchmark scenes to better demonstrate robustness?

4. Optimization and cross-view consistency: How are the original and selected inpainted views used during Gaussian optimization, particularly the masked regions of unselected views? Additionally, how does the framework handle inconsistencies between diffusion-inpainted views? Could the authors provide evidence that the selected views lead to more consistent 3D reconstruction, beyond improvements in rendered-image reconstruction metrics?

Additional Comments on Presentation

The Method and Experiments sections are unnecessarily verbose, with repeated explanations of the motivation and claimed benefits. A more concise presentation, together with more representative qualitative comparisons, would help communicate the contributions more effectively.

Minor formatting issues include a missing space in "Gaussian scene.TRACE" (Lines 143–144) and a duplicated comma after the view-selection scoring equation (around Line 292).

Overall Assessment

The paper presents a technically reasonable and practically useful framework, with experimental evidence supporting the benefit of its view selection strategy. However, the limited direct evaluation of transient authentication, insufficient evidence of robustness and cross-view consistency, and relatively incremental nature of the contributions prevent me from recommending acceptance in its current form.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.