- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents TRACE, an automatic pipeline for transient object removal in GS scenes. The pipeline obtains instance masks of candidate objects by YOLOv11-Seg then authenticates them as transient or persistent using three multi-view geometric cues derived from the SfM reconstruction, including point support N_pts, track consistency L_track, and view coverage R_view. When the geometric evidence is weak, the pipeline falls back to semantic verification based on the similarity of pretrained visual features. The authenticated masks then drive a greedy, coverage-aware view selection strategy for diffusion inpainting prior to GS optimization. The framework is evaluated on the WRIVA, Spin-NeRF, and Neural3D datasets.
Critical strengths
The paper cleanly separates two underexplored problems in transient object removal, such as determining what should be removed (authentication) and recovering how to remove it (coverage-aware editing). This separation makes the framework easy to follow and enables a plug-and-play evaluation of the view selection module on standard editing benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient methodological details for reproduction.
- Sec. 2.3 introduces 3 geometric cues, including N_pts, L_track, and R_view, but the paper never specifies how these cues are combined into an actual persistence decision and the threshold values (or their derivation) are likewise not reported.
- Sec. 2.3.3 states that semantic verification is invoked "when the available geometric evidence is insufficient," but this insufficiency condition is never formalized.
- Insufficient quantitative evaluation.
- The primary evaluation of transient authentication covers only 2 WRIVA sequences, which is a thin empirical basis for claims about "challenging real-world scenes." Moreover, on the Dataset_2, TRACE underperforms T-3DGS in psnr without further analysis, and the text justifies this via ssim only.
- The comparison set is currently restricted to T-3DGS (authentication) and InFusion/GScream (editing). Closely related lines of work are not compared: distractor-free reconstruction (RobustNeRF [1], NeRF On-the-go [2]) and robust GS reconstruction (SpotlessSplats [3], WildGaussians [4]).
- The paper claims to "significantly improve transient localization," yet no metric directly measures localization quality (e.g., mask IoU, precision/recall or F1).
-
Missing ablations. There is no ablation showing the impact of removing the semantic fallback. The reader cannot judge whether this component is a genuine contribution or a rarely-triggered safety net.
-
Presentation and figure quality are poor. Figure 1 is not well connected to the paper structure. The overview does not map its stages to the corresponding sections (e.g., which blocks implement §2.3.1 vs. §2.3.2), making it hard to use as a reading guide. More importantly, the key architectural components, such as, the persistence verification module, and the greedy view selection, are conveyed only through high-level pictograms, and their inputs/outputs and decision logic are not visually specified.
Questions for authors
Overall, the proposed pipeline to tackle dynmaic objects in 3D reconstruction is standard and well-established. Could you please address above concerns and clearly articulate the specific algorithmic innovations compared to existing methods?