- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents BehaviorPilot, which generates training tasks for tool-using agents around an explicit behavior taxonomy and uses failure rates to guide further synthesis. Experiments on three benchmarks show that the trained model outperforms the evaluated baselines.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practical limitation of scenario-based synthesis. Explicit behavior targets help reduce repetitive interaction patterns and improve coverage of underrepresented skills. The results support the value of behavior-guided synthesis. BehaviorPilot leads on all three benchmark averages, and its 4k-task dataset outperforms a 16k-task behavior-agnostic dataset
- The synthesis pipeline includes useful quality checks. Tasks and trajectories undergo execution and behavior-coverage checks, supported by a separate QA process and concrete verifier examples.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty is limited. Environment and task generation have been explored in AgentGen [1] and EnvScaler [2], while Agent-World [3] already uses failure diagnosis to guide further task synthesis. BehaviorPilot’s main addition is an explicit behavior taxonomy for organizing this process, rather than a new synthesis or refinement paradigm.
- It is unclear whether the gains from iterative refinement come from targeting weak behaviors or simply adding more training data. Table 2 increases the dataset from approximately 4k to 10k tasks, but do not compares this approach with adding the same number of tasks evenly across behaviors.
- A failed task does not necessarily identify which behavior the model struggles with. For example, a task targeting error recovery may fail because the model supplies an incorrect argument before reaching the recovery step. The method nevertheless uses the task’s failure to increase the training budget for its designated behavior, without evaluating whether this assignment matches the actual cause of failure; the QA checks in Appendix A.2 assess task–behavior alignment, not failure attribution.
- The caption of Table 2 refers to “Task,” whereas the corresponding column is labeled “Tasks.” Please make this consistent.
- Section 3.5 states that each behavior receives an equal number of validation tasks, but does not report that number, making it difficult to assess how reliably the failure rates are estimated.
[1] Hu et al. AgentGen: Enhancing Planning Abilities for Large Language Model based Agent via Environment and Task Generation.
[2] Song et al. EnvScaler: Scaling Tool-Interactive Environments for LLM Agent via Programmatic Synthesis.
[3] Dong et al. Agent-World: Scaling Real-World Environment Synthesis for Evolving General Agent Intelligence.
Questions for authors
See weakness.
3 comments
Reply to Reviewer XN7p (Part 2)
W2 (Failure-guided refinement versus uniform expansion)
It is unclear whether the gains from iterative refinement come from targeting weak behaviors or simply adding more training data. ... adding the same number of tasks evenly across behaviors.
Thank you for suggesting this control. To evaluate the contribution of failure-rate-based budget allocation, we added two baselines across all three rounds. All three strategies retain behavior-conditioned task synthesis, start from the same initial model and training corpus (~4k tasks), and add approximately 2k tasks per round. Behavior-random randomly assigns synthesis quotas across behaviors, while Behavior-uniform assigns equal quotas to all behaviors.
As shown in Table B, BehaviorPilot achieves the highest benchmark averages in all three rounds, outperforming Behavior-uniform by 4.8 points on BFCL and 1.8 points on τ²-Bench at approximately 10k tasks. Behavior-random and Behavior-uniform show limited gains from further expansion, as neither prioritizes the model’s weak behaviors. In contrast, BehaviorPilot allocates more tasks to behaviors with higher validation failure rates. It improves both benchmark averages in every round and outperforms both baselines at the same task counts.
Table B. Synthesis-budget allocation strategies at matched cumulative task counts. Bold indicates the best result within each refinement round.
| Round | Cumulative tasks | Strategy | BFCL Avg. | τ²-Bench Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Initial | ~4k | — | 48.5 | 44.8 |
| +1 | ~6k | Behavior-random | 47.9 | 45.9 |
| +1 | ~6k | Behavior-uniform | 48.5 | 40.4 |
| +1 | ~6k | BehaviorPilot | 49.0 | 46.4 |
| +2 | ~8k | Behavior-random | 47.5 | 46.1 |
| +2 | ~8k | Behavior-uniform | 47.4 | 43.4 |
| +2 | ~8k | BehaviorPilot | 49.9 | 47.4 |
| +3 | ~10k | Behavior-random | 47.8 | 47.0 |
| +3 | ~10k | Behavior-uniform | 47.5 | 48.9 |
| +3 | ~10k | BehaviorPilot | 52.3 | 50.7 |
W3 (Failures unrelated to the target behavior)
A failed task does not necessarily identify which behavior the model struggles with. ... The method nevertheless uses the task’s failure to increase the training budget for its designated behavior ... the QA checks in Appendix A.2 assess task–behavior alignment, not failure attribution.
Thank you for highlighting this concern. With 50 validation tasks per behavior, occasional errors unrelated to the target behavior affect only a small fraction of these tasks. If such errors occur frequently, they can also cause failures on tasks that directly test the corresponding behavior, leading us to generate more training data for that weakness. Therefore, this design helps us identify recurring weaknesses and generate training data to address them.
W4 (Table 2 caption typo)
“The caption of Table 2 refers to ‘Task,’ whereas the corresponding column is labeled ‘Tasks.’ Please make this consistent.”
Thank you for pointing this out. We have changed “Task” to “Tasks” in the caption to match the column header.
W5 (Validation-set size)
“Section 3.5 states that each behavior receives an equal number of validation tasks, but does not report that number.”
Thank you for pointing out this omission. Our fixed validation set contains 50 tasks per behavior across 100 behaviors, totaling 5,000 tasks. Each task has a single designated target behavior and is held out from training. For reference, BFCL V4 Multi-Turn, τ²-Bench, and VitaBench contain 800, 278, and 400 tasks, respectively. Our 5,000-task validation set provides a substantial evaluation budget with balanced coverage across all 100 behaviors.
Dear Reviewer XN7p,
We sincerely appreciate your careful review of our paper and your constructive feedback, which is helpful in improving our work.
As the author-reviewer discussion period will close shortly, we kindly ask you to take a look at our rebuttal and consider whether we have addressed the concerns you raised. Many thanks again for your time and assistance in improving the paper.
Regards from the authors.
Reply to Reviewer XN7p (Part 1)
Thank you for your detailed and constructive review. We appreciate your recognition that explicit behavior targets reduce repetitive interaction patterns and improve coverage of underrepresented skills, that BehaviorPilot leads on all three benchmark averages with a 4k-task dataset outperforming a 16k-task behavior-agnostic one, and that our execution and behavior-coverage checks and independent QA process are useful. We also thank you for your questions, which helped us clarify our positioning and address the remaining concerns. We respond below with our positioning against prior methods, matched-budget baselines, failure-attribution analysis, and validation-set details.
W1 (Distinction from prior work)
Thank you for highlighting these related works. They have demonstrated the value of environment/task synthesis, executable verification, and failure-guided expansion, but primarily organize data around environments, scenarios, or task difficulty. BehaviorPilot’s core contribution is controllable task synthesis for behavior coverage, with both generation and refinement specifically designed to support behavior guidance.
During generation, AgentGen expands environment diversity and adjusts task difficulty through Bi-Evol. EnvScaler generates scenarios from environment states, tools, and rules, then checks task completion. Agent-World generates executable tasks through tool-dependency graphs and programmatic synthesis. Although we share some operations, controlling tool calls or final outcomes does not ensure target behavior coverage: tool graphs describe dependencies and call order, while an agent may complete a task without exercising the intended behavior. BehaviorPilot therefore specifies target behavior combinations before generation and checks whether both reference solutions and actual training trajectories cover them. This directly controls which behaviors enter training, rather than merely adding labels to generated tasks.
For refinement, Agent-World analyzes failure traces, error distributions, and environment metadata to suggest tasks for specific environments. These suggestions do not directly specify how many tasks to generate for each behavior across environments. BehaviorPilot instead uses a behavior-balanced validation set to measure each behavior’s failure rate and determine its next synthesis quota. Thus, results from different environments jointly guide additional training data toward shared behavioral weaknesses.
As shown in Table A, we analyzed behavior frequencies in EnvScaler, Agent-World (our reproduction), and BehaviorPilot data. EnvScaler and Agent-World concentrate 84.23% and 50.73% in their top three behaviors, respectively, with near-median frequencies of only 0.00% and 0.22%–0.36%, and bottom-three frequencies of 0.00% for both. In contrast, BehaviorPilot’s top-three share is 39.11%, while its near-median and bottom-three frequencies reach 0.67%–0.76% and 0.06%–0.10%. These results show that BehaviorPilot produces training data with more balanced behavior coverage, reducing concentration on frequent behaviors while improving coverage of low-frequency ones.
Table A. Frequencies of each method’s three most frequent, three least frequent, and three near-median behaviors.