- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
To address the memory overhead and quantization accuracy challenges in post-training weight quantization (PTQ) for large language models, this study proposes Low-Rank Scale Reconstruction (LRSR) without requiring calibration data. The core of the method is an upper-bounding rank-1 decomposition that approximates the ideal per-element scale matrix via a low-rank matrix. While guaranteeing no weight clipping, it pre-multiplies the scaling vector into the activation matrix parameters, thereby completing the linear layer computation through a single GEMM operation and lightweight vector scalings, which greatly saves the metadata memory overhead of the scale factors. To mitigate the approximation error introduced by the upper-bounding rank-1 decomposition, the study further introduces 1DOS and K-Means clustering strategies aimed at improving reconstruction accuracy while accounting for hardware load balancing. Evaluations on the Qwen3-4B model (WikiText-2 dataset) demonstrate that at INT4 precision, this method achieves memory footprint and inference latency close to the per-channel baseline while narrowing the generation quality gap (e.g., KL-Divergence, PPL) with the per-group method.
Critical strengths
S1. Practical engineering significance. The paper targets the pain point that fine-grained quantization (per-group) relies on custom low-level kernels in LLM deployment, attempting to balance the storage overhead of scale factor metadata and quantization accuracy under a calibration-free setting, which lowers the barrier to using the quantization pipeline S2. Intuitive formulation and low metadata overhead. Starting from the algebraic properties of the matrix multiplication reduction axis, the method decouples the scale factors via a rank-1 decomposition. The method reduces the metadata storage complexity to without altering the fundamental GEMM operation. S3. Clear theoretical derivation. The derivation of Algorithm 1 is developed under a strict no-clipping premise, and Proposition 1 proves that under round-to-nearest conditions, the elementwise quantization error upper bound of the proposed method is no worse than the per-channel baseline. Figure 1 provides an intuitive visualization of the scale factor envelope, making it easy to understand.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Imprecise positioning of research novelty. For Eq. 6, applying per-channel quantization with scale to the input-channel rescaled weights yields the exact same quantized integer weights (), which is algebraically equivalent to bilateral diagonal scaling. Thus, this algebraic property alone is insufficient to serve as one of the core contributions. The actual novelty is limited to the calibration-free upper-bounding scale construction (Algorithm 1) and the subsequently introduced clustering strategies (Section 3.3). However, the paper currently provides insufficient justification for the benefits of these two components compared to existing methods. Moreover, locking row maxima before taking column maxima in Algorithm 1 is overly sensitive to single-point outliers, causing severe degeneration (e.g., Fig. 15 & 17) W2. Operator type mismatch in experimental validation. While Section 1 motivates standard GEMM( in Eq.6) via NPUs lacking custom kernels, Section 4 are conducted entirely under the Weight-INT4, Activation-BF16 setting, applying INT4 quantization only to . In practice, any standard GEMM hardware requires both operands to have homogeneous data types. Executing a multiplication between INT4 and BF16 requires either dequantizing INT4 to BF16 beforehand or introducing mixed-precision custom kernels. The former fails to achieve compute acceleration, while the latter violates the premise of "not requiring custom kernels". W3. Thin experimental evaluation. The paper lacks comparisons with other methods. For instance, Section 2.3 discusses methods such as QuaRot, SplitQuant, and AWQ, yet Section 4 and Appendix C only compare against the most basic round-to-nearest per-channel and per-group baselines. The paper neither provides comparisons of quantization accuracy and latency against other calibration-free methods (e.g., QuaRot, SplitQuant), nor includes the quantization accuracy of calibrated methods (e.g., AWQ) as a reference baseline, making it difficult to accurately assess the accuracy cost incurred for being calibration-free. Furthermore, experiments are only conducted on the WikiText-2 dataset and a few small-scale models (1.7B/4B), lacking validation across more datasets and larger model scales.
Questions for authors
Q1. In Transformer architectures, for linear projections immediately preceded by LayerNorm or RMSNorm (e.g., q_proj / k_proj / v_proj), one could in principle follow AWQ's approach to absorb the scaling vector offline into the preceding normalization weight parameters, thereby eliminating the runtime activation scaling overhead. Please explain whether the method proposed in this paper can perform a similar offline operator fusion instead of dynamically executing the multiplication of at runtime. Q2. Regarding W2, please provide empirical accuracy results when and share the same data types (e.g., W4A4 or W8A8), or otherwise revise the hardware acceleration arguments in the paper. Q3. Regarding W3, please supplement the paper with empirical comparisons in both accuracy and latency against the calibration-free methods mentioned (e.g., QuaRot, SplitQuant), as well as accuracy comparisons against calibration-based methods (e.g., AWQ). Additionally, it is recommended to include evaluations on more standard downstream reasoning tasks (e.g., GSM8K) or larger-scale models (e.g., 7B).
We thank the Reviewer igi6 for the detailed technical feedback regarding bilateral diagonal scaling, offline operator fusion, data type homogeneity, and experimental baselines.
We agree with this assessment and have revised the contribution statements in Section 1 (lines 054–065) so that the algebraic factorability of bilateral scaling is no longer claimed as a standalone contribution. Instead, the contribution is framed around the calibration-free upper-bounding decomposition (Algorithm 1) and the clusterization strategies (Section 3.3).
Regarding the sensitivity of Algorithm 1 to single-point outliers: locking the row maxima ui in Step 1 indeed causes vk to be pinned near 1.0 whenever a column contains an element close to its row maximum in any non-collinear row, which explains the spike at 1.0 in Figure 16 and the limited gain on
gate_projin Figure 15. This property directly motivates our 1DOS and Constrained K-Means clusterization methods in Section 3.3 and Appendix B. By separating high-angular-distance outlier rows (1DOS) or grouping collinear output channels into C=3 balanced clusters (Constrained K-Means), the rank-1 bound is computed over collinear subsets rather than across the entire layer. In our expanded evaluation in Table 3 (lines 1080–1120), LRSR-1DOS and LRSR-KMeans close up an average of 75% of the KLD gap between Per-Channel and Per-Group (g=128) on the Qwen3 family (1.7B, 4B, and 8B).We address this point from both hardware execution and empirical perspectives. First, in weight-only W4A16 execution, unpacking 4-bit weights to 16-bit floats prior to or within the matrix engine is a uniform bitwise conversion independent of scale metadata. In contrast, executing per-group quantization without custom fused kernels requires slicing the reduction axis into K/g separate GEMM calls per layer, which introduces substantial launch and accumulation overhead.
Second, to provide empirical results when weights and activations share homogeneous integer data types (
W8A8andW4A4), we evaluated LRSR on a physical Rockchip RK3588 NPU (executing nativeINT8xINT8->INT32andINT4xINT4->INT16GEMM operations) alongside the RK3576 NPU (W8A16andW4A16). Please refer to our response to Reviewer SY4q (Question 4) for the complete benchmark table and analysis across Qwen3-4B, Gemma4-5B-E2B, and LFM2.5-2.6B.We expanded Section 4 and Appendix C to include Qwen3-8B, Gemma4-5B-E2B, and LFM2.5-2.6B, added the C4 dataset, evaluated a 4×3 composability matrix with Standard, QuaRot, AWQ, and GPTQ (Figures 3–4 and Table 4), and added five downstream benchmarks including GSM8K, MMLU-Pro, and HumanEval (Figure 5 and Table 6). Please see the General Response for an overview of these additions. Finally, we discuss the runtime trade-offs of online Hadamard transforms (O(KlogK)) versus offline calibration in Appendix C.3 (lines 1197–1204).
Yes, LRSR supports this offline operator fusion for the five linear projections per Transformer block that immediately follow a normalization layer (
q_proj,k_proj,v_projafter attention normalization, andgate_proj,up_projafter MLP normalization). For a single projection or when separate rescaled views are used, the input scale vector v can be multiplied directly into the normalization weight vector offline. Furthermore, when sibling projections sharing the same normalization output (q/k/vorgate/up) consume a single shared activation tensor, one can define a shared input vector as the element-wise maximum of the sibling v vectors and recompute each sibling projection's output vector u. Because the shared input vector remains bounded by 1 and upper-bounds each individual sibling vector, Proposition 1 continues to hold for every layer while allowing a single offline fusion into the normalization weights. Explicit runtime pre-scaling is then only required foro_projanddown_proj. We have added this analysis to Section 3.1 (lines 191–195) and Appendix D (lines 1384–1403).