- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The title and abstract displayed on the webpage do not match the content of the attached PDF. The following review comments are based on the PDF attachment.
Jointly training neural operator learning models on the original PDEs and their simplified basic forms has previously been shown to effectively improve model performance. This manuscript argues that using fixed simplifications of the original PDEs has inherent limitations and further proposes an adaptive operator selection strategy and a discrepancy-based loss weighting method to improve training efficiency and model performance. The manuscript evaluates the proposed approach on Burgers, FitzHugh–Nagumo, and Navier–Stokes equations.
However, the manuscript suffers from a highly disorganized presentation and unclear explanations, making it difficult to follow. Furthermore, the method novelty is extremely limited. Finally, the experimental results fail to demonstrate consistent performance improvements across the three benchmarks. The manuscript also lacks sufficient evaluation on more challenging 3D PDE benchmarks, where reducing data generation costs and improving training efficiency would be particularly meaningful.
For these reasons, the reviewer does not recommend acceptance of this manuscript at ICLR.
Critical strengths
The title and abstract displayed on the webpage do not match the content of the attached PDF. The following review comments are based on the PDF attachment.
- This manuscript focuses on an important research problem. Jointly training neural operator models on the original PDEs and their simplified basic forms has shown considerable promise for solving complex 3D PDEs, where numerical simulations are particularly computationally expensive.
Critical weaknesses
The title and abstract displayed on the webpage do not match the content of the attached PDF. The following review comments are based on the PDF attachment.
- The manuscript suffers from a highly disorganized presentation and insufficient explanations of the method and results. The reviewer believes that the manuscript requires a substantial restructuring to improve its clarity, coherence, and readability.
- The effectiveness of the proposed method has not been sufficiently demonstrated. First, the proposed method fails to achieve consistent performance improvements across the three benchmarks. Second, the ablation results in Table 4 of the appendix indicate that the proposed dynamic weighting method does not consistently improve prediction accuracy and may even degrade performance. Furthermore, the manuscript lacks comparisons with standard neural operator training without auxiliary supervision, making it difficult to determine whether the proposed framework offers meaningful benefits over the standard neural operator training pipeline. More importantly, the experimental evaluation is restricted to relatively simple 1D and 2D PDE benchmarks, which is insufficient to convincingly show the effectiveness of the proposed framework.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the concerns raised in the Weaknesses.