- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper formulates personalized coupon allocation as an offline RL problem with per-user, dynamically estimated LTV safety constraints and proposes LIGER, an implicit Q-learning variant tailored to extreme population skew. LIGER introduces a group-relative learning scheme (group-balanced sampling, reward normalization, and advantage standardization), a softmax-Q Bellman target that removes the separate value network, and a KAPPA-FLOOR mechanism to calibrate penalties arising from underestimated, sparsely estimated LTV caps. Offline FQE analysis and a month-long online A/B test on a large e-commerce platform show improvements in GMV, conversion, and cost control relative to baselines and the incumbent rule.
Critical strengths
The clearest strength of this work is its practically meaningful reformulation of coupon allocation from aggregate budget optimization to per-user LTV-aware decision-making. This directly addresses an important limitation of global-budget approaches, where overspending on persistently unprofitable users can be masked by underspending elsewhere. The formulation is well aligned with the production setting and is supported by encouraging online A/B results, showing higher GMV and conversion with essentially unchanged coupon expenditure.
Critical weaknesses
Please refers to the questions.
Questions for authors
- Can you quantify the truncation bias experiment motivating KAPPA-FLOOR (bias vs. history length, per-tier error bars) and show how κfloor was chosen and validated? How sensitive are results to this choice?
- Since you balance sampling across groups in critic training, how do you address the mismatch between this training distribution and the deployment distribution in value estimation? Did you consider importance corrections or alternative reweighting?
The reviewer is willing to increase the rating if all questions are well addressed.