- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper address the problem of fair influence maximisation with fairness to be accounted for across multiple attributes. It models each attribute-group pair as a strategic agent. Group-specific “teacher” networks learn RR-based marginal utilities and are distilled into a shared student. The learned models only propose candidates. The final seed choice uses exact sampled reverse-reachable (RR) marginals, so a model misranking can’t by itself exclude strong nodes. On eight real networks, SAGE-IM generally achieves higher entropy and worst-group coverage with competitive spread, though not uniformly compared with existing IM algorithms.
Critical strengths
-I appreciate the novelty of studying of IM with fairness across different attributes -I appreciate the honesty of the authors in what the paper claims to cover, highlighting the limitations: the RR expectation gives no uniform-accuracy guarantee under capped banks, the weight identities are not fairness guarantees, and the gradient projection only attenuates conflict rather than guaranteeing better spread. The problem is notoriously hard to solve.
Critical weaknesses
The method has many complicated parts, but the paper’s own tests don’t show that they’re all needed. Switching some parts off barely changes the results, and sometimes even improves them.
Questions for authors
Q: how does SAGE-IM compare against a simple baseline that skips the learned teacher and student models and picks seeds directly from the group and global RR marginals with the same fairness weighting?