- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SARoLO, a modification of YOLO11 for SAR object detection. It introduces alternative downsampling and bottleneck blocks, cross-scale feature fusion, and a dual-scale detection head. The design combines square and asymmetric convolutions with a learnable nonlinear transformation called DyN. Results are reported on HRSID, SSDD, and, in the supplementary material, RSAR.
Critical strengths
Detecting small ships in cluttered SAR imagery is a relevant application. The proposed model has a small parameter count and reports accuracy improvements over the tested YOLO baselines.
Critical weaknesses
- The attribution and novelty of central components are not adequately established. Eq. (1), introduced as DyN, is identical to the full DyT operation in Transformers without Normalization, including the learnable input scaling and per-channel affine parameters. This work is neither cited nor acknowledged. Since DyN is repeatedly presented as a component designed for SARoLO, this directly affects the originality assessment.
- The combination of square and asymmetric convolutions also needs to be discussed against closely related work, including ACNet, Strip R-CNN, and PKINet-v2. Their implementations are not identical to SARoLO, but they are directly relevant to its architectural choices and motivation concerning elongated targets.
- The experiments do not sufficiently separate the proposed mechanisms from simpler architectural changes and additional computation. Table 3 shows that changing YOLO11 to two detection heads already improves AP from 66.36 to 67.10. The complete SARoLO reaches 68.46, but increases computation from 5.8G to 10.0G FLOPs compared with this two-head baseline, while reducing parameters only slightly, from 1.85M to 1.80M. Without measured inference latency, the smaller parameter count does not establish an overall efficiency improvement.
Questions for authors
- Is there any difference between DyN in Eq. (1) and DyT in Transformers without Normalization? If so, where is that difference? Please clarify the attribution and which part should be considered a new contribution.
- How do the proposed square-and-asymmetric convolution blocks differ from the relevant designs in ACNet, Strip R-CNN, and PKINet-v2? Do the authors have comparisons of these components under the same SAR detection setting?
- How does SARoLO compare with the two-head YOLO11 baseline at a similar computational budget? Measured latency and a capacity-matched replacement for CSAN would help determine whether the proposed design offers a better accuracy–efficiency trade-off.