- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes an approach to using a graph neural network to reason about dynamics embedded in SE(3). The paper explores an equivariant model that accomplishes the above. This is in contrast to most approaches in the literature that reason about SO(3) as embedded in a Euclidean vector space where, e.g. quaternions are treated as a vector quantity. Essentially, the proposed method reasons in exponential coordinates and projects the resulting orientation back onto the SO(3) manifold. The work is evaluated in the context of a forward dynamics model that predicts future states. Table 1 and Fig 2 evaluate performance of the model in terms of predictive error for a planar ackerman dynamics vehicle. Table 4 evaluates planning performance for MPPI using this learned model for the ackerman vehicle.
Critical strengths
The main strength of the paper was its mathematical soundness. While the tangent map introduces an approximation, I found the method generally well founded. In addition, I thought the GNN framework was appropriate.
Critical weaknesses
My main concerns relate to the experiments. The problem was that they focused primarily on the dynamics of the planar vehicle. It's just not a problem that really requires this kind of machinery. Plus, it's a problem in SE(2), not SE(3). The strength of the math is really SE(3), but that's not really needed for these experiments. I cannot believe that really good approaches to planar vehicle dymamics prediction do not exist that are significantly simpler than this.
Questions for authors
No questions. My primary concern relates to the experiments.