acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

OSVIF: Order-Spectral Variable Interaction Framework for General Multivariate Time Series Analysis

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Cross-variable dependencies in multivariate time series involve variable combinations of different sizes. These combinations can provide distinct information for characterizing a target variable and contribute jointly through cross-scale synergies. The roles of both combination information and these synergies vary across target variables. However, existing methods often mix information from combinations of different sizes or use constructed group structures to represent only a subset of combinations separately. This organization makes it difficult to preserve distinct representations of combination information by size, limiting the modeling of this information and its cross-scale synergies, as well as its selective use for different target variables. Consequently, cross-variable dependencies remain insufficiently characterized, limiting performance on downstream time series analysis tasks. To address these limitations, we propose OSVIF (Order-Spectral Variable Interaction Framework), a general framework for multivariate time series analysis. For each target variable, OSVIF covers all variable combinations and uses two spectra to link the organization of combination information by size with the modeling of cross-scale synergies. The natural order spectrum covers all source-variable combinations, preserves distinct representations by size, and applies target conditioning to form order-specific states. The natural coalition spectrum covers all combinations formed from these order-specific states and the state of the target variable itself, modeling how information from combinations of different sizes contributes synergistically to the characterization of the target variable. Both spectra use generating polynomials to cover their respective combination spaces in full without enumerating individual combinations, keeping computational costs manageable. By combining full combination coverage with distinct representations by size, OSVIF enables the selective use of combination information for each target variable and captures cross-scale synergies. It provides a unified variable interaction backbone for five tasks: long-term forecasting, short-term forecasting, imputation, classification, and anomaly detection. Experiments on 35 benchmark datasets show that OSVIF achieves strong performance across all five tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness and generality.

Primary area:
learning on time series and dynamical systems
Keywords:
Multivariate time series, Cross-variable dependencies, Higher-order interactions, Cross-scale synergy, General time series analysis

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_5MdvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes OSVIF, a target-centered framework for multivariate time series analysis. It represents cross-variable dependencies with two spectra: a natural order spectrum that organizes source-variable combinations by size and conditions them on each target variable, and a natural coalition spectrum that models synergies across combination sizes. Both are implemented via generating polynomials and product trees, avoiding explicit enumeration. A shared backbone with lightweight heads supports long-term forecasting, short-term forecasting, imputation, classification, and anomaly detection. Experiments cover 35 benchmark datasets, with ablations on higher-order interactions, Cross-view modeling, coalition readout, and task conditioning.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper focuses on a unified backbone for time series analysis across multiple tasks. which is an important and widely studied research direction.
  2. The target-centered perspective intuitively distinguishes the roles of source-variable combinations of different sizes, which is a meaningful refinement over existing group-based formulations
  3. The multi-task evaluation clearly demonstrates the generality of the proposed framework, covering five task families within a single representation design.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The overall layout of this paper is poorly balanced and makes the paper difficult to follow. The abstract and introduction occupy a disproportionately large portion of the main text and are somewhat redundant, whereas the method section is extremely dense, introducing a large number of complex notations without sufficient explanation or scaffolding. The main text therefore requires substantial revision, and in my view, should be rewritten.
  2. The baselines compared in the experiments are somewhat outdated, with the most recent ones dating from 2024. Several recent strong baselines are not included, such as TimeMixer++ [1], OLinear [2], and T1 [3], which weakens the persuasiveness of the experimental comparison.
  3. The improvement on the classification task is very limited, with only a 0.1-point gain over a 2023 method, which weakens the claimed advantage of the proposed general framework.
  4. The introduction states that OSVIF distinguishes target-specific interaction scales and models target-specific cooperative interactions, but it remains unclear how these two quantities are actually measured. It is also unclear why two different datasets are used for illustration, and whether the observed phenomena are dataset-sensitive.
  5. The Identity/Cross decomposition is not a strict additive decomposition in the original coordinate space (acknowledged in Appendix B.2), which weakens the conceptual framing in the main text.
  6. Although the method is motivated by avoiding explicit enumeration, no efficiency analysis is reported, including runtime, memory, and scaling with respect to the number of variables, sequence length, or maximum order.

[1] Wang S, Li J, Shi X, et al. (2025). Timemixer++: A general time series pattern machine for universal predictive analysis. In International Conference on Learning Representations (Vol. 2025, pp. 16980-17016).

[2] Yue W, Liu Y, Wang H, et al.. (2025). Olinear: A linear model for time series forecasting in orthogonally transformed domain. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 38, 60573-60632.

[3] Park, Dongik, et al. (2026). T1: One-to-One Channel-Head Binding for Multivariate Time-Series Imputation. In International Conference on Learning Representations (Vol. 2026, pp. 39341-39367).

Questions for authors

Please refer to Weaknesses.

Reviewer_KfEcOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes OSVIF, a framework for modeling cross-variable dependencies in multivariate time series. It introduces two generating-polynomial-based components: a natural order spectrum that aggregates source-variable combinations by their sizes and produces target-conditioned representations, and a natural coalition spectrum that further models interactions among these order-specific representations. The framework is evaluated on five time series tasks, including forecasting, imputation, classification, and anomaly detection. Experimental results and ablation studies are presented to demonstrate its effectiveness.

Critical strengths

The paper provides a broad empirical evaluation across five time series tasks, accompanied by ablation studies and supplementary analyses of the proposed components.

Critical weaknesses

1. Limited methodological novelty and unconvincing motivation

OSVIF largely combines established techniques for higher-order feature interactions, polynomial aggregation, and target-conditioned modeling, with limited apparent methodological novelty. The paper fails to convincingly establish the claimed limitations of existing approaches or explain why the proposed two-stage construction is necessary. Furthermore, the experimental evaluation lacks direct comparisons with closely related higher-order variable interaction methods (e.g., HyperMixer, RHCL, and SGN), and the existing ablation studies do not adequately demonstrate the distinctive advantages of the proposed construction over simpler alternatives. Consequently, both the motivation and the significance of the proposed methodological contribution remain unconvincing.

2. Poor writing quality and lack of clarity

The paper suffers from serious clarity and presentation issues. The writing is excessively abstract, repetitive, and unnecessarily convoluted, making even the central research problem and claimed contributions difficult to understand. Key concepts lack clear and concrete explanations, and inconsistent terminology further undermines the coherence of the presentation. These issues substantially hinder the reader's ability to follow and critically evaluate the work.

Questions for authors

What is the distinctive methodological contribution of OSVIF over existing higher-order variable interaction methods (e.g., HyperMixer, RHCL, and SGN), and could the authors provide direct comparisons with these closely related methods on shared benchmarks to substantiate the claimed advantages?

Reviewer_BWsdOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents OSVIF, a framework for modeling cross-variable interactions in multivariate time series. It uses elementary symmetric polynomials to organize source-variable combinations by cardinality without explicitly enumerating individual subsets. These order-specific representations are conditioned on each target variable and subsequently processed by a second, coalition-level spectrum to capture interactions across different combination orders. The framework is evaluated on five tasks and across 35 benchmark datasets. The results show that OSVIF is competitive across these settings, with particularly strong performance on imputation, short-term forecasting, and anomaly detection on SWaT.

Critical strengths

1.The combination of elementary symmetric polynomial constructions, target conditioning, and a two-stage order-spectral architecture is interesting and reasonably novel. Using generating polynomials to include all subset-product terms without explicitly enumerating individual subsets is computationally well motivated. The Identity/Cross design also provides a distinctive mechanism for complementing same-coordinate Hadamard interactions with cross-coordinate interactions.

2.The empirical evaluation covers five task families and a broad collection of datasets. The paper reports per-dataset results, component ablations, hyperparameter sensitivity analyses, and several representation-level analyses. For anomaly detection, the use of threshold-independent AUROC and AUPRC rather than relying only on point-adjusted F1 is particularly appropriate.

3.The main framework is presented in a coherent progression from the natural order spectrum to target-conditioned order states and then to the natural coalition spectrum. The appendices provide additional derivations for polynomial computation, the Identity/Cross decomposition, task-specific heads, and evaluation protocols, which improves the overall clarity of the method.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The role of K is not formally defined. Table 7 and Appendix D define K as the number of “coalition groups used by the natural coalition readout,” with K=8 in the main experiments. However, K does not appear in Equations (8)–(11), where all coalition orders appear to be retained and read out independently. The paper should provide a precise mathematical definition of the grouping operation, including its inputs, group-assignment procedure, and aggregation rule. It should also clarify whether grouping is performed before, during, or after the computation of the polynomial coefficients, and whether this operation preserves the exact coalition-order representation described in Equations (8)–(11).

  2. The temporal encoder is insufficiently specified. The paper does not provide enough information about the temporal encoder used to construct the independent source-variable representations. Important details including its architecture, parameter-sharing scheme, and the construction of the target condition q_i appear to be missing. This component is central to both the subsequent polynomial construction and downstream prediction, and it may account for a substantial fraction of the model’s parameters and predictive capacity. Without a complete description of the encoder, it is difficult to isolate the contribution of the proposed order-spectral interaction mechanism or reproduce the reported results. The authors should therefore report the encoder architecture and parameter count and, if feasible, discuss how sensitive the results are to the choice of temporal backbone.

  3. The numerical stability of the high-order polynomial construction is unclear. This concern is particularly relevant for high-dimensional datasets such as PEMS-SF, which contains 963 variables. Under the stated setting M=V-1, the natural order spectrum may contain terms of order as high as 962. Repeated high-order products may yield coefficients with extremely small or large magnitudes, potentially causing underflow, overflow, or vanishing gradients. Consequently, the model may formally retain all orders while, in practice, receiving meaningful numerical signals only from low- or intermediate-order terms. The authors should explain the numerical stabilization techniques and precision settings used in the implementation and provide diagnostic evidence showing that high-order coefficients and their gradients remain finite and non-negligible on high-dimensional datasets.

Questions for authors

Regarding Weakness 1:Please provide a precise mathematical definition of the coalition-grouping operation, including its inputs, group-assignment procedure, and aggregation rule. Please also clarify whether grouping is performed before, during, or after the computation of the polynomial coefficients, and whether it preserves the exact coalition-order representation defined in Equations (8)–(11).

Regarding Weakness 2: Please clarify: 1.the complete architecture of the temporal encoder; 2.whether its parameters are shared across variables, datasets, and tasks; 3.how the target condition q_i is constructed; 4.the parameter counts of the temporal encoder and the full model.If feasible, results using an alternative or lightweight temporal encoder would help clarify whether the reported gains are robust to the choice of temporal backbone.

Regarding Weakness 3: Please clarify: 1.the numerical precision used to compute the polynomial coefficients, including whether the implementation uses FP32, FP64, FP16/BF16, or automatic mixed precision; 2.whether the high-order coefficients and their gradients remain finite and non-negligible on high-dimensional datasets; and 3.the peak GPU memory consumption and per-epoch training time on representative high-dimensional datasets, particularly PEMS-SF. This information would help determine whether the proposed full-order construction remains numerically stable and computationally practical in the high-dimensional regime.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.