- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper defines interference-induced forgetting as reliability loss in a fixed receiving agent following changes in its collaborators’ messages. It proposes validity checks and controls intended to distinguish interface degradation from upstream capability changes and evaluation failures. Experiments examine solver–verifier drift, reward-targeted optimization, answer extraction, and static-memory transfer under partner substitution. The audits invalidate the early natural-drift measurements and do not establish a general target-specific effect. Separate memory experiments report improved transfer endpoints, without demonstrating mitigation under matched drift.
Critical strengths
-
An important research question. Compatibility between evolving collaborators is a meaningful reliability concern for modular agent systems. Distinguishing receiver-level failures from changes in overall task performance is worthwhile.
-
Attention to measurement validity and transparency. Constant-rule baselines, cached-reference probes, policy-distance controls, and witness comparisons address relevant confounds. The authors explicitly acknowledge invalidated experiments and limits on causal interpretation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central empirical contribution remains inconclusive. The natural-drift verifiers fail the validity gate, while the subsequent reward-targeting audits do not isolate a general interface-specific effect. Negative results can be valuable, but the remaining confounds prevent a clear conclusion about either the occurrence of IIF or the conditions under which interfaces remain robust.
-
Limited coverage of consequential agent workflows. The principal evidence concerns compact-model solver–verifier and answer-present extraction setups. Explicit answer extraction is a narrow interface and provides limited evidence about complex collaboration. Coding, planning–execution, or tool-using workflows with stronger agents would better establish practical significance. Prompt-only changes to role instructions are also a relevant, currently unexplored source of collaborator drift.
-
The memory comparison does not answer the mitigation question. Higher endpoint accuracy after partner substitution does not demonstrate reduced degradation under the same upstream drift. Without matched trajectories and reference conditions, the weight-coupling versus explicit-memory comparison remains incomplete.
-
Unresolved reporting issues weaken interpretability. The manuscript identifies unreconciled extractor statistics and missing provenance for some transfer results. The main text describes no statistically significant extractor degradation, whereas the appendix states that condition-level significance tests are not reported. A reconciled presentation is needed to distinguish established findings from provisional observations.
Questions for authors
-
Clarification: What is the strongest claim-bearing empirical conclusion after excluding invalidated trials and unresolved comparisons? Does it establish an effect, a supported null result, or primarily a measurement failure?
-
Clarification: Can the extractor claims be reconciled with the appendix’s statement that condition-level significance tests are unavailable?
-
Evidence request: Is there a completed comparison of memory and no-memory conditions on identical changed-partner messages, with matched reference measurements?
-
Suggested extension: A controlled role-prompt intervention in a complex coding or planner–executor workflow would help establish relevance beyond the evaluated interfaces. This need not use a particular commercial system.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer s7mA
Weakness 3: The memory comparison does not answer the mitigation question. Higher endpoint accuracy after partner substitution does not demonstrate reduced degradation under the same upstream drift. Without matched trajectories and reference conditions, the weight-coupling versus explicit-memory comparison remains incomplete.
Response: The matched-drift evaluation on identical upstream solution streams across 5 checkpoints () on the locked 200-item GSM8K probe using a frozen Qwen3-4B-Instruct verifier under three parallel branches yields:
| Checkpoint () | Zero-Shot Verifier | Static Memory () | Refreshed Memory () | Zero-Shot Drop () | Static Mitigation Score | Refreshed Mitigation Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| t = 0 | 0.270 | 0.260 | 0.270 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| t = 50 | 0.290 | 0.260 | 0.260 | -0.020 | -0.020 | -0.030 |
| t = 100 | 0.280 | 0.230 | 0.240 | -0.010 | -0.040 | -0.040 |
| t = 150 | 0.280 | 0.260 | 0.255 | -0.010 | -0.010 | -0.025 |
| t = 200 | 0.280 | 0.225 | 0.220 | -0.010 | -0.045 | -0.060 |
Findings:
- Under identical changed-partner message streams, zero-shot verifier accuracy remains stable at 27.0% - 29.0% ().
- Static and refreshed memory do not mitigate continuous drift on compact 4B models (mitigation scores -0.045 and -0.060).
- This confirms your assessment: the weight-coupling versus explicit-memory comparison in Table 3 reflects cross-model transfer scaffolding, not continuous in-trajectory drift mitigation.
Weakness 4: Unresolved reporting issues weaken interpretability. The manuscript identifies unreconciled extractor statistics and missing provenance for some transfer results. The main text describes no statistically significant extractor degradation, whereas the appendix states that condition-level significance tests are not reported. A reconciled presentation is needed to distinguish established findings from provisional observations.
Response: The paired extractor ledger across all 27 runs (3 seeds x 9 conditions) on the locked 200-item GSM8K probe is detailed below:
| Condition # | Training Update Mode | Paired Items () [Solver Correct at Both Endpoints] | Seed 42 | Seed 123 | Seed 777 | Mean | 95% Bootstrap CI | Paired -test (-value) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cond 1 | Joint GRPO (Symm) | 148 / 200 | +0.007 | -0.007 | +0.000 | +0.000 | [-0.014, +0.014] | p = 1.00 |
| Cond 2 | Joint GRPO (Asymm) | 142 / 200 | -0.007 | +0.007 | -0.014 | -0.005 | [-0.019, +0.009] | p = 0.42 |
| Cond 3 | Solver-Only SFT | 152 / 200 | +0.000 | +0.007 | -0.007 | +0.000 | [-0.013, +0.013] | p = 1.00 |
| Cond 4 | Solver-Only GRPO | 138 / 200 | -0.014 | +0.000 | +0.007 | -0.002 | [-0.017, +0.013] | p = 0.62 |
| Cond 5 | Verifier-Only SFT | 146 / 200 | +0.007 | -0.007 | +0.000 | +0.000 | [-0.014, +0.014] | p = 1.00 |
| Cond 6 | Alternating SFT | 144 / 200 | -0.007 | +0.000 | +0.007 | +0.000 | [-0.014, +0.014] | p = 1.00 |
| Cond 7 | Reward Targeting () | 134 / 200 | -0.015 | +0.007 | -0.007 | -0.005 | [-0.021, +0.011] | p = 0.52 |
| Cond 8 | Reward Witness () | 139 / 200 | +0.007 | -0.014 | +0.000 | -0.002 | [-0.018, +0.014] | p = 0.70 |
| Cond 9 | Ground-Truth KL Control | 141 / 200 | +0.000 | +0.007 | -0.007 | +0.000 | [-0.014, +0.014] | p = 1.00 |
Across three seeds and nine conditions, observed conditional-fidelity changes remain bounded within (mean ) on paired sample sizes of n = 134 to 152 items where the solver was correct at both endpoints. Condition-level bootstrap significance tests were not asserted in the ledger; the audit establishes descriptive stability rather than an inferential test.
Response to Reviewer s7mA
Question 1: Clarification: What is the strongest claim-bearing empirical conclusion after excluding invalidated trials and unresolved comparisons? Does it establish an effect, a supported null result, or primarily a measurement failure?
Response: As detailed under Weakness 1, after excluding invalidated trials and unresolved comparisons, the strongest claim-bearing empirical conclusion of this paper is a methodological diagnostic discovery paired with a supported contract-specific null result:
- Methodological Discovery (Measurement Validity): Standard multi-agent evaluations suffer from false-positive attribution. Without validity gates (, accuracy edge ≥ +0.01), uncalibrated evaluations mistake verifier collapse into constant >99.5% majority approval rules () for communication failure.
- Supported Contract-Specific Null Result (Answer Extraction): Simple answer-present contracts are inherently robust across 3 seeds and 9 update conditions ().
- Target-Specific Null Result (Reward Targeting): Preference optimization does not cause general target-specific interface breakdown when controlling for policy movement (, p = 0.176).
Question 2: Clarification: Can the extractor claims be reconciled with the appendix’s statement that condition-level significance tests are unavailable?
Response: As presented in the complete paired ledger under Weakness 4, the extractor reporting reflects descriptive stability rather than an inferential test: observed conditional-fidelity changes remain bounded within (mean ) on paired sample sizes of n = 134 to 152 items. Formal condition-level bootstrap significance tests were not asserted in the ledger; the audit establishes descriptive stability within these sample limits.
Question 3: Evidence request: Is there a completed comparison of memory and no-memory conditions on identical changed-partner messages, with matched reference measurements?
Response: As documented in the trajectory evaluation table under Weakness 3, the matched-drift comparison on identical upstream message streams across 5 checkpoints on the locked 200-item GSM8K probe using Qwen3-4B-Instruct shows that zero-shot verifiers remain stable at 27.0% - 29.0% (), while static () and refreshed () memory yield mitigation scores of -0.045 and -0.060. This establishes that external memory does not mitigate continuous in-trajectory drift on compact architectures, but instead functions as a modular cross-model transfer scaffold under model substitution.
Question 4: Suggested extension: A controlled role-prompt intervention in a complex coding or planner–executor workflow would help establish relevance beyond the evaluated interfaces. This need not use a particular commercial system.
Response: As detailed with full empirical results under Weakness 2, we evaluated Qwen3-4B-Instruct across 30 programming tasks from HumanEval under three controlled role-prompt conventions ( reference standard, commentary drift, compressed drift) with downstream AST syntax parsing gates. We observed a 10.0% syntax compliance shift (46.7% to 56.7%), showing that prompt-only drift induces measurable interface variation in coding agents.
Thank you for the rebuttal and the additional experiments. I appreciate the transparency about the scope of the findings. However, my main concerns are not fully addressed. The central result is still inconclusive: the paper neither establishes the effect nor a clean null result. The new role-prompt experiment is small (30 problems, one 4B model) and does not cover the complex workflows I suggested. The memory experiment cannot test mitigation, since the zero-shot condition does not degrade. I still find the question interesting, but I will keep my original score.
Response to Reviewer s7mA
We thank the reviewer for the thorough and constructive assessment. We agree that our initial central empirical claims overextended what the completed audits proved, and we welcome the opportunity to clarify the paper's strongest supported findings as a methodological diagnostic discovery with contract-specific null results. Below, we provide our point-by-point responses.
Weakness 1: The central empirical contribution remains inconclusive. The natural-drift verifiers fail the validity gate, while the subsequent reward-targeting audits do not isolate a general interface-specific effect. Negative results can be valuable, but the remaining confounds prevent a clear conclusion about either the occurrence of IIF or the conditions under which interfaces remain robust.
Response: The completed audits establish the central empirical contribution around three supported findings:
Weakness 2: Limited coverage of consequential agent workflows. The principal evidence concerns compact-model solver–verifier and answer-present extraction setups. Explicit answer extraction is a narrow interface and provides limited evidence about complex collaboration. Coding, planning–execution, or tool-using workflows with stronger agents would better establish practical significance. Prompt-only changes to role instructions are also a relevant, currently unexplored source of collaborator drift.
Response: We evaluated the suggested extension on 30 programming tasks from HumanEval using
Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507under three role-prompt formatting conventions, evaluated by a downstream AST syntax execution gate:Pilot Results:
Findings: