- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
When using a teacher model that can see the whole graph and a student model that has partial observability of the graph a loss in performance is often present. This paper essentially tries to separate the performance loss in two terms, one coming from the fact that some information is missing, and another one due to the student suboptimality.
Critical strengths
- The core idea is simple and straightforward to understand
Critical weaknesses
- The paper seems to be heavily AI generated. With excessive use of useless and bad / not defined jargon (compatible-world law, matched audits, information diagnostic framework, ...), AI captions remaining (Table 1: Quantities that must remain distinct in theory and experiment), copy-pasted text that lost original pointers (Ye et al. in line 120), and AI leftovers ("Code availability. The supplementary material includes the experiment, aggregation, plotting, and validation code; raw and aggregated results; run metadata; dependency versions; and the LaTeX source.").
- Some results do not seem novel at all. For example what is the novelty of Theorem 1?
Questions for authors
- Could you be more clear about the use of AI in this work? To me it does not seem it was limited to the tasks claimed in the AI use statement
- Where is the code claimed to be submitted? Would it be possible to see it?
- What is the real novelty of this paper?