- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces , a visual compression framework for efficient closed-loop aerial vision-language navigation. The framework combines complementary-teacher distillation, which transfers spatial and semantic knowledge into a lightweight visual encoder, with state-adaptive token allocation, which dynamically retains visual evidence relevant to navigation and subsequent control. Experiments on TravelUAV show that AeroC² maintains strong navigation performance across seen and unseen environments while reducing FLOPs by 40.54% and mean end-to-end latency by 27.72% compared with the dense VLA baseline.
Critical strengths
The paper achieves strong empirical results, consistently improving navigation performance across the Seen, Unseen Object, and Unseen Map splits while substantially reducing model parameters, FLOPs, and inference latency. The two-stage framework is reasonably innovative and well integrated: complementary-teacher distillation reduces visual encoding cost, while state-adaptive token allocation decreases downstream multimodal computation. The overall system is complete and practical, and the component-level ablations generally support the effectiveness of its main modules. Overall, provides a favorable trade-off between navigation accuracy and computational efficiency.
Critical weaknesses
Insufficient support for future-control-aware visual compression. The paper argues that existing frame-local token compression overlooks the “future observability induced by each action” and proposes to retain visual evidence relevant to “subsequent control.” However, does not explicitly model how an action changes the next viewpoint or which visual tokens will benefit subsequent decisions. Its action-conditioned evidence only adjusts spatial importance using recent actions, while temporal memory accumulates previous evidence scores and retention decisions. Moreover, these history-dependent components are disabled during shuffled-frame Stage-II training and introduced as deterministic heuristics during inference. The experiments in Table 4 demonstrate the benefits of multi-cue evidence scoring, adaptive budgeting, and role-aware retention, but do not separately evaluate action-conditioned evidence or temporal memory. Figure 3 only visualizes the changing token budget . Therefore, the results support state-adaptive token allocation, but do not sufficiently validate the claimed consideration of future observability and subsequent control.
The multi-property distillation objective is insufficiently validated. Although the proposed objective combines teacher-branch features, projected features, feature scale, and spatial relations, the ablation in Table 3 only compares different teacher configurations. It demonstrates the benefit of dual-teacher supervision, but does not isolate the contribution of the four losses. Therefore, the necessity of the four-part distillation objective remains unclear.
Table 3 does not sufficiently justify the use of DINOv2 as an additional spatial teacher. Although the dual-teacher configuration outperforms the SigLIP-only variant, the latter distills the DINOv3 student solely toward the SigLIP feature space. It does not evaluate the more natural alternative of preserving the native DINOv3 representation while using SigLIP only to provide complementary semantic supervision. Therefore, the observed performance gap may result from the loss of DINOv3’s native spatial information under SigLIP-only distillation, rather than demonstrating that DINOv2 contributes indispensable spatial knowledge. The experiment only establishes that the proposed dual-teacher objective is better than single-teacher SigLIP distillation under the authors’ formulation.
Questions for authors
-
How is “future observability induced by each action” concretely modeled in AeroC²? The action-conditioned evidence uses previous actions rather than predicting how the current action will change the next viewpoint, while the remaining cues are primarily computed from the current observation.
-
Temporal memory updates token-wise scores at corresponding grid indices across frames. Since UAV motion continuously changes the viewpoint, how are visual tokens spatially aligned between consecutive observations? Without explicit geometric correspondence or motion compensation, could the same token index refer to unrelated scene regions?
-
Why are the action-conditioned and temporal-memory components disabled during shuffled-frame Stage-II training but activated during sequential inference? Does this introduce a training-inference mismatch, and can the authors separately quantify the contributions of these two history-dependent components?
-
What are the individual contributions of , , , or ? Can the authors provide loss-level ablations to justify the complete multi-property distillation objective?
-
Why is DINOv2 required as an additional spatial teacher for a pretrained DINOv3 student? In particular, how does the proposed dual-teacher design compare with preserving DINOv3’s native representation while using SigLIP only as complementary semantic supervision?
Response to the Authors
Thank you for the detailed response and the substantial additional experiments. The history-term ablations address my concern about the contributions of action-conditioned evidence and temporal memory. The loss-level ablations also validate the four components of the distillation objective. In addition, the explanation of the OpenVLA visual interface and the Native DINOv3 plus SigLIP comparison provide much stronger justification for the dual-teacher design.
My main remaining concern is the interpretation of future observability induced by each action. At step t+1, the action from step t has already been executed and the resulting observation has already been acquired. Conditioning token retention on the previous action therefore appears to be history-conditioned selection of current-frame tokens rather than prospective modeling of how a candidate action will affect future viewpoints or which visual evidence has long-term value for subsequent control. The new ablations convincingly show that these history-based heuristics improve navigation, but they do not fully substantiate the stronger claim of explicitly modeling future observability.
Overall, the rebuttal substantially improves my confidence in the empirical soundness of the method. My remaining concern mainly relates to the conceptual positioning and methodological novelty, since the framework still combines multi-teacher distillation with a deterministic allocator composed of manually designed cues, coefficients, thresholds, and retention safeguards. Nevertheless, given the additional evidence and clarifications, I am inclined to raise my score while retaining this concern about the future-control-aware claim and the incremental nature of the overall design.